- The cookies at Schmackary's is a can't miss
- cookies
- maple bacon
- trendy
- casual
- coffee
- (15 more)
- Popular
- Recent
- Nicole SerratoreJune 6, 2015Funfetti cookies are always a solid bet. Broadway actors sometimes help out here to raise money for charity.
- Jinnie LOctober 13, 2014my friend dragged me here to try their cookies even though I didn't want any. *however* I'm glad she did! >_<// maple bacon and cookies & scream!!! Yum♥
- Mike FriedlichMay 13, 2017Some of the best cookies in NYC. Cookies and Cream cookie and Chocolate Explosion cookie are amazing.
- Benjamin ValdezOctober 30, 2015This place has awesome cookies! Try the maple bacon! Sooo good! If you dislike salty stuff, stay away from the cookies with sea salt. Very salty.
- Ambika PaiMarch 15, 2013Had the gluten free macaroon and corn bread cookie. Both so delicious! Now I know where to get myself a good GF sweet.
- The staff know me and always make me feel welcome. The shakes take a while to make, but otherwise it's very efficient service, and it's always worth it.
- Kaitlin NelsonMarch 25, 2017Honestly, you haven't lived until you've tried the Classic Chocolate Chip. I love the subtle sprinkling of salt!
- Theresa RoldanMarch 7, 2016Cookie heaven. I can vouch for the monster, the s'more, and the chocolate chip cookies. Spot on!
- Chele RocksOctober 12, 2018Really good cookies! Don't be afraid to try the candied yam with marshmallow topping - so good!
- Srinivas VasudevanMarch 11, 2015Mocha at this place is awesome. Loved it, and will come again. The red velvet cookie was yum too.
- Ana QuillinanAugust 14, 2013The key is to trust the bakers, what a fantastic and eclectic selection and oh my, the calorie count is not something I'd want to know so don't ever tell me
- Mohammad A.October 17, 2013Many types, and most of it I tasted, you have to try, in order to know how delicious it is.
- If you are gluten-free (or even if you're not!), the Sweet Corn Cookie is one of the BEST gluten-free cookies I've ever had!
- Teddy NicholasMarch 29, 2014Milky Way shake is so delicious but it's even better when that cute boy makes it because he adds his own shake to it.
- SalAugust 22, 2017Great selection of hot sandwiches, paninis and custom salads plus a soda for a good prize
- Ashley HornJanuary 18, 2016Go for the red velvet for something a bit different. Cookies without frosting tend to be a bit drier and crumbling (in my experience).
- Kyle MOctober 19, 2012I didn't buy anything but let me tell you, the red velvet and maple bacon cookie are delicious!!! OMGee!! What is candied bacon? Crack?!!
- Super smart on the business end, being steps away from Broadway Dance Center. Celebrate all your hard work dancing by eating cookies!
- Nancy ChenJune 13, 2012Such a cute place. I love the red velvet cookie complete with a cream cheese frosting. Def recommend it for the sweet teeth out there.
- Rob Berry Jr.August 9, 2016I just had the iced coffee, which was good. My friend did love the over-sized choco-chip cookie though.
- April Wall-ParkerMay 14, 2013I have loved every cookie I've tried. Chocolate Diablo, Fluffernutter, and Lemon Poppyseed especially rock!
- The best part about this place is that the staff is as good as the cookies! Both are phenomenal!!!
- Sandro MorandinJune 9, 2015Best cookies EVER! And if you're lucky you can meet some Broadway star ! #broadwaybakes
- DacotahAugust 27, 2014Good cookies, good coffee and they open early on Sunday. Cookies for breakfast? Yes!
- Their coffee is super strong. If you're not into that go for a Cafe au Lait. It's got enough milky goodness to offset the coffee.
- ManasviApril 1, 2013Green tea cookies were amazing! I went there at 10 PM and all cookies were buy 1 get 1 free :-)
- Alex ZaltsmanJuly 29, 2012Cookie sandwich w Gelato is the way to to roll. Oh, and you will probably be dreaming about it. Wow! Just amazing.
- Janet ZhuangMay 7, 2015Loving the style! Coffee is good. Haven't tried the cookies yet but I heard good feedbacks.
- Ben FishnerApril 27, 2015The cereal bars are often better than the cookies here (but the cookies are great too).
- Guy barista used to make better coffee than the girl who works here now. Still the best latte in Hell's Kitchen though
- stephanieJune 28, 2012cookies and cream cookie is a good breakfast. can't say the same about the waaay too strong iced coffee.
- The Red, White, 'N Blue cookie feels healthful and delicious! Definitely a great way to celebrate the 4th. Get it while you can!
- Everything EVERYTHING - eat everything! But specifically, eat the Schmores cookie
- Justin LukeMay 16, 2012Get here early. THEY SELL OUT FAST! Get a cookie infusion shake. You will DIE. Also, ask about the specials.