Sagaponack
Seafood Restaurant and Bar$$$$
Flatiron District, New York
"Good lobster mac n cheese, lobster rolls or sliders and mussels."(15 Tips)
"Delicious lobster rolls, lobster mac n cheese, and sliders."(3 Tips)
"Amazing dollar oyster happy hour and 100 percent Chardonnay"(2 Tips)"Excellent service."(6 Tips)
72 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- happy hour
- healthy food
- good for dates
- salads
- scenic views
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Cole KennedyMay 15, 2016Step into this Disney-fied yacht club just steps from Madison Square Park. The booths upstairs are comfortable, and the beer list is solid.
Olessya KAugust 1, 2013Charming hidden restaurant. Classy yet unpretentious. Book through Savored to save at least what you'll end up tipping. Excellent service. Good, totally inexpensive wine selection.
Great food. Kale salad, fish tacos, lobster roll. Wine from LI vineyards.- Olessya KAugust 1, 2013What to get: scallops and beets appetizer and tuna and avocado timbale are to die for. Good lobster mac n cheese, lobster rolls or sliders and mussels. Crab cakes are so so. Mahi mahi - no good.
Hua YehAugust 17, 2014Lobster is light and fresh, not the buttered bread if that's what you are looking for. I was here for quick bite but found it's classy and romantic both. Full bar with lmtd but great selections.
Ms HeleneMarch 11, 2014The signature salad and the Baja fish tacos which came with guacamole and chips! Cute setting
Donna Lee UbertalliMarch 6, 2012Charming setting with fresh, healthy and tasty food. Very attentive to gluten free eating and I love to pop over with colleagues for a drink or lunch.
Claudia CesarJune 23, 2018Nice restaurant and very good food. It’s a little bit noisy and the waitress that was serving our table that day was not very efficient (but just bad luck). I recommend it!
marcy stoneJanuary 24, 2013Delicious salads, relaxing ans pretty atmosphere, and the looks of the lobster rolls with fries...yuuuuum. getting that next time. A bit of the east end right in nyc.
brooklyn foodieFebruary 17, 2022Fluke tartare, kale caesar, cocktails. Great, friendly staff. They should have a much higher rating. I've been to 9.0 eateries that weren't as good.
LilyOctober 6, 2013Fantastic brunch. Inexpensive, great food, great service, great atmosphere. Diamond in the flatiron rough.
Cece LJuly 20, 2013Good lobster roll, but I was more impressed with their salad and fries. The happy hour lobster roll is definitely recommended though!
Carlo CiscoMarch 24, 2014Nice relaxed atmosphere with good food and great drinks. Perfect for after work. Also, if you have Meet Select you save off your full bill!- I MFebruary 28, 2013This tasty, dependable neighborhood spot is a nice pick for a work lunch lobster roll. It is never amazing but it is good and will never offend anyone.
BlackBook MagazineNovember 16, 2012Outfitted with wicker chairs, wainscoting walls, and understated-elegant chandeliers, this Asian-influenced restaurant (where'd that come from?) transports you to its namesake beach and lounge chair. Read more- Christina CosterJune 25, 2015Makes you dream of the East End. Delicious lobster rolls, lobster mac n cheese, and sliders.
Melody GambinoNovember 13, 2014Delicious seafood and a great burger. The sagaponack salad with shrimp is my favorite
Jennifer YounSeptember 8, 2011went here w/ the bf not too long after we came back from our Montauk trip and being at this place made us feel like we were still in Montauk! Great date place!!
Maria BabochkinaDecember 21, 2013Great food, great drinks! It's not that crowdy even on Friday night, which is awesome!
Make sure you sit at the bar when Daniel is bar-tending. Hottie with and body AND gives good recommendations on what to eat :)
Jeff BairdJune 28, 2012The Veggie sandwich is amazing and he service is wonderful. No idea what is wrong with these other reviewers, maybe they are reviewing a diff restaurant?
N MaodzaNovember 7, 2011Happy hour 4:30-7p is the Lobster Roll and draft beer for $20. The lobster roll is usually $26...so...great deal!
James MullanyJanuary 14, 2019$5 draft beers during happy hour. Friendly staff, but limited bar area seating/standing room
Sheila HsuDecember 8, 2011Go for their happy hr lobster roll special and drink! Two thumbs up to their friendly wait staffs.
Diane ChienJuly 21, 2011Lunch entrees are delicious and well priced ($10ish!). Order a half ice tea, half lemonade for some refreshment.
No alcohol yet, but good food, a great view and friendly staff. The eggs chlauquiles and crabby patty cakes were EXCELLENT. Plus they have a 20% off promotion right now!
Mariana LJune 14, 2010Love the slider sampler if you can't make up your mind... Lobster roll, fried clams, crab cakes. Can't go wrong
The scallops are amazing & shareable (if that's your thing). They won't disappoint!!
269 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
New ownership est. Oct 2020
Located in Flatiron neighborhood, Sagaponack is a seafood restaurant specializing in chef- driven approachable quality.
Closed until 11:30 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Wed, Sun
- 11:30 AM–3:00 PM
- 5:00 PM–10:00 PM
- Thu
- 11:30 AM–3:00 PM
- 5:00 PM–10:30 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:30 AM–3:00 PM
- 5:00 PM–11:00 PM
(212) 229-2226
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Dessert, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 9.0
"You really can't go wrong here but oysters and sushi are a must. Get a reservation."
Valarie McCubbins - 6.5
"Very fresh fish, good drinks & nice atmosphere. Recommend the caramelized Brussel sprouts as a side dish. & oysters."
Jenny Lee - 7.3
"Interesting selection of different daily fish. Great place for the catch of the Day. Happy Hour gets packed."
Richard Revilla
Places people like to go after Sagaponack
Appears on 173 lists
Created by Mike Winston
58 items • 58 followers
Created by Midtown Lunch
47 items • 155 followers
Created by Anna Lindow
17 items • 10 followers
