Rum Barrel Bar & Grill
(Now Closed)Bar and American Restaurant$$$$
Key West
55 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Shay TaylorDecember 13, 2013Go to the rooftop bar on Thursday nights for a jam session - local musicians performing folk, blues, pop, country. Very relaxing enjoyable evening. And use the buy-1-get-1 free drink promotion!
Serena JaeOctober 7, 2013The Philly Cheese Steak Spring Rolls are fantastic. Comes with 4 on a plate with delicious house made sauce.
Corey BucekApril 10, 2011Ate outside on the deck. Great atmosphere, mild temperature and a breeze. Had Island Tacos with the buffalo shrimp and crabby fries for an appetizer. Best meal I've had in Key West so far.
Stacey RussMay 21, 2011Philly Cheese Steak Rolls are fantastic! Roof top patio is the place to be with live music. Service has always been great!
Nice selection of rum. Be sure to head upstairs to learn more about rum when the Rum Daddy is holding court!
WayneFebruary 14, 2013Great selection of draft beers and rum drinks. Server was very helpful in selecting and not selecting entrees.
Donna PerdueJanuary 24, 2012Sit on the roof! Live music in the evenings, cool breezes, sunshine and decent food. Avoid the tacos...boring! Nice wait staff and good drinks!
JimmyGotUpsNovember 8, 2014If rum is your thing this is the place to be. Their selection reads like a book... literally.
Alexis Havlik~March 10, 2012Wow, Teddy is the man!! Try a "Marooned" drink, different and great. Philly rolls, hit 'em up!!
Demi FoldsMarch 16, 2012Definitely get the BBQ burger sliders!! So good and the ranch and bbq sauce tastes similar to chick-fil-a sauce.
Becky BrownJune 4, 2012Alan is a great bartender... def get a mojito. He also makes a mean pot of chili!
Lane AndrewsNovember 7, 2011The Lobster Pot pie was amazing. On a cool night - totally an excellent meal.
Frank LoorApril 9, 2011Try rum Barrel for a drink and the Penne Pescatore is pretty fresh!!!.. With a group of 8 we got in right away..for upstairs no big groups
Shawn PattersonMay 4, 2010Upstairs bar is amazing. Nice open air setting, good place to listen to so live music and sip on a beer
Best Cheesesteak in the Keys... If you're looking for a Philly bar this is the place!!
Jay O'BrienMarch 9, 2011Great Big Ass burgers, good luck finishing it! Upstairs bar is great on a nice day
Ask Alan about Fridays and get a free shot of shitty tequilla!
Tony KnutsonOctober 2, 2011Our entire group had their Credit Card Numbers stolen from this place! No joke all received calls from banks a week later they are using a swipe machine to make new cards. Beware!!!!
John R.November 2, 2013Wasn't busy and still waited 10 min and no service. Left. Don't waste your time here. Instead went next door to Island Dog where service was better, cheaper drinks and food, etc.
If Alan is working, give him shit about the raiders. Oh, and ask for Alans shot! It's awesome!
194 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Stop in for palate-pleasing favorites like Philly cheese steak sandwiches and queen conch fritters or sample unique specialties such as Joe’s Tug Mahi Mahi.
(305) 292-7862
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Rum Barrel Bar & Grill
- 7.4
"They play great music! Good Caesar salad"
Kristina Burris - 8.5
"I loveeee this bar. We sat at the very front entrance bar and the bartender was wonderful. First time in the Keys and he made it a blast. :)"
Kaydee Mattingly - 8.6
"Atmosphere, entertainment, souvenirs, and of course the infamous Sloppy Joes. Don't miss it!"
Jill Brailey
Appears on 42 lists
Created by Donna Perdue
17 items • 18 followersCreated by Flojo_D
16 items • 4 followers