"Key lime pie is amazing."(2 Tips)
"Share apps and tacos"(3 Tips)
"ahi tuna salad"(2 Tips)
"Buffalo Soldier Chicken Taco was really good."(2 Tips)
6 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- key lime pie
- salads
- duck
- restaurants
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Lynn Bednar-RandoJanuary 8, 2019Their house made banana infused rum is 😋. Ribs,Caesar salad, duck empanadas, and wings all worth trying. Their passion fruit lager is worth a try as well. Key lime pie is amazing. No capp/espresso.
Melia JonesJanuary 1, 2017Share apps and tacos so you can have as many different tastes as you can ... everything is amazing.- Daniel AJuly 16, 2020The ahi tuna salad was so good and so fresh and the key lime pie is top Knötchen. Service was excellent.
Jamie JFebruary 11, 2018I had crab cakes. My daughter had tacos. Her boyfriend had island burger. They enjoyed it
44 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Tropical cuisine and cocktails right off the Patchogue Bay. Get ready, New York -- it’s island time.
Closed until 11:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
(631) 569-5944
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
See More
You might also like
- 6.5
"Bread is worth a skip. Excellent tuna tartar. Halibut special with lobster butter and risotto was delicious. Filet mignon was decent. Service was great and attentive. Dessert is basic."
Lynn Bednar-Rando - 8.6
"everything on the menu is delicious! ....but tonite's salad special was excellent- spinach salad, fig goat cheese, mango, papaya, almonds with a red wine vinagrette. :)"
Jessica O'Sullivan 
Places people like to go after RHUM
- 7.9
"The meatball parm sliders, with parmesian fries is totally awesome. I definitely recommend!"
Chris Carrington - 7.6
"Great food, great atmosphere, friendly staff. Loved the buffalo chicken meatballs, old fashioned, and the appetizers."
Christopher Freda - 6.8
"the Grilled Veggie Platter was awesome! The Staff and Crew always do the right thing! Great Place!"
John Lorefice
Appears on 12 lists
Created by Çağla Baybura
97 items
Created by Kim Mazza
44 items
Created by Michelle C.
193 items • 9 followers