Red Eye Cafe
Café$$$$
Montclair
Ranked #2 for cafés in Montclair
"The New Orleans Sludge Coffee and Chorizo Quesadilla were awesome!"(3 Tips)
"they have the best lattes and the dirty chai is pretty great too."(5 Tips)
"French Toast and Red Eye coffee, a combo for absolute happiness."(2 Tips)
"The turkey and pear sandwich is so delicious!"(2 Tips)
60 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- coffee
- sandwiches
- trendy
- brunch food
- lively
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Akshay PatilJune 10, 2017They have really good coffee and great sandwiches. There's also a chess board for customers to play and a whole lot of books to read for past time. It a nice cozy place. Simply the best cafe ever
A GAugust 31, 2014Great cafe in New Jersey, which are hard to come by. Great staff, okay iced coffee. The food options are to-die-for, and free wi-fi. Perfect for a bunch of occasions. Past 7pm, you have free parking!
This place is awesome. The food is fresh, inventive, and delicious. The New Orleans Sludge iced coffee is to die for. And the decor is fabulous. Love the painted lights on the walls!
Nastassia AguileraMarch 9, 2016This is a cute spot to meet up for a laid back date or to catch up with a friend. I ordered a dirty chai with almond milk, so good! I'll definitely come back (:
This place is straight up amazing. Have left extremely happy and more than satisfied every time. Bonus tip - Homemade Salted Caramel Ice Cream is life changing, true story. Also, service is great!
Stacee RonaeNovember 2, 2013Always packed on the wknd. The brunch menu is only served on wknds & they're not open until 9 on Sat & Sun BUT, I WILL COME HERE FoR THE BEST CANDIED BACON! I stop here on the way to the farmers mkt!
Nastya NaOctober 28, 2017I like this pumpkin 🎃 pancakes 🥞!!! My husband said spicy 🌶 but tasty 😋 about eggs 🥚 with beans.
- Joey LacusOctober 27, 2018Brunch is fantastic. Huevos Rancheros and Scotch Egg Bahn Mi are awesome. Great coffee and baked goods as well!!
Joelle VelascoSeptember 2, 2014Went for brunch and ordered the chipotle cheese sandwich. I added bacon (because, BACON. Mmm). It was amazing. Also had the Dirty Chai - delish!
Jay EaglesonNovember 10, 2014Such a cool spot for dinner and coffee. The food was good and the atmosphere is chill.
They are serious about their coffee here (that's a compliment, I am too) and the food is excellent as well. Small, but well thought out menu.
Montclair is becoming so SOHO or like one of those little off the beaten path streets in Paris eveyime I come home there's something new and delicious going on!
Great place for brunch with an interesting menu. Try the candied bacon!
Daylin ReynosoSeptember 11, 2017The best place on earth. The Sunday menu is the best. Dirty chai is a must. I'm addicted to that coffee- Roxy NadimJune 5, 2016they have the best lattes and the dirty chai is pretty great too. The atmosphere and waiters are both lovely.
- Jennifer RAugust 6, 2017The s'mores cookie is gooey and delish. Also recommend this place for late night coffee/desser
The New Orleans Sludge Coffee and The Highlander (scotch egg with a Vietnamese twist) are this months specials and both are amazeballs.
DaisyMarch 29, 2014Good coffee and love the walnut cake....moist not to sweet!!! Still searching for the perfect cup of coffee.
Great coffee and excellent latte. Been once for weekday lunch and was equally delicious.
M BMarch 29, 2013Great bfast! Spinach & smoked gouda omelette, red eye coffee and banana walnut pancakes! #delish...we're all VERY satisfied!!!
DaraOctober 24, 2012This might just be thee best iced coffee ever. And I am picky when it comes to iced coffee. This place is an A+ for sure!
Snooty WaiterJuly 2, 2014Order the sandwich that seems the most "out there" to you. That's what they do and that's what you should do. Live a little!
Fliyann RakatakatakaDecember 10, 2014Good espresso slamming hot chocolate with fresh home made whipped cream! Yum!!
- Alanna GuzmanDecember 30, 2013Order any of the omelets, highly recommended! Comes with toast and a fruit platter.
- French Toast and Red Eye coffee, a combo for absolute happiness.
Coffee cake with espresso glaze is delicious and not aggressively sweet (if addictive).
isabella saccoJune 28, 2013Highlander sandwich with a iced chai tea latte! Delicious! Worth every penny!
I wanted to like it, given its location near the station. This cafe has the right looks, and friendly staff, but for me doesn't deliver on coffee or food.
Can't decide! My first time here. It all sounds so good.
146 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Red Eye Café is an innovative local coffee shop in Montclair, NJ. Food. Coffee. Comfort.
Open until 11:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon
- 7:00 AM–5:00 PM
- Tue–Fri
- 7:00 AM–11:00 PM
- Sat
- 9:00 AM–11:00 PM
- Sun
- 9:00 AM–5:00 PM
(973) 509-3663
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch
See More
You might also like
- 8.2
"Many unique options, great options, very tasty food and well made. Limited seating but worth the wait."
ℳansour αℓтαууαr - 9.1
"Great local spot with quality food and drinks. Very "instagrammable" but definitely delicious"
Caitlin Sakdalan
- 7.9
"Ordered to go... got the cavatelli w/t olive oil, the quinoa salad & the soup of the day, a really unique butternut squash and barley soup! Everything was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! Can’t wait to eat in!"
Hannah Lilly
Appears on 125 lists
Created by Megan
62 items • 7 followers
Created by Soundz Org
178 items • 11 followersCreated by Monday Lisa
10 items • 5 followers