Puck Fair
(Now Closed)Pub, Bar, and Whisky Bar$$$$
SoHo, New York
138 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Backing up what everyone has already said in reference to the curry fries but I'd also recommend you to try the pulled pork sliders. Three per person should suffice, if you're having them with fries.
JoshuaFebruary 22, 2013Toasties are non-greasy grilled cheese sandwiches on wheat bread, heated on a panini press. Go for cheese (seems to be cheddar), a fried egg, and baked beans. A protein bomb, with a small side salad.
Ben MartinSeptember 21, 2013Speaking as an Irish native, this is the first Irish pub I've been to that feels in anyway authentic, without being tacky. The beef stew with a side of brown bread is what I'd recommend.
So many bars are missing the vital ingredient these days: great service. Not here. Bartenders have known me by name since the 1st time I came. They give you a drink if you stay long enough. Cheers.
Matt KMarch 21, 2011Great place to pop in for a beverage or bite to eat. Gets busy at times, but always a great diverse crowd! Tip your bartenders well! They deserve it and are some of the best in the city!
Damian BayonaMay 23, 2015Great bar in soho for a low key night. There is a downstairs bar that can also be reserved for private parties.
Heineken USAugust 20, 2014The comfortable atmosphere of this landmark Soho staple offers an innovative menu and a great place to enjoy a Heineken.
Karl With A "K"November 27, 2013Quesadillas are delicious and good if you want a light lunch. Forewarning: sour cream is not on the side: it's inside the quesadilla.
One of my favorite pubs in the city. Tuck yourself upstairs and order half pints off their major list of beers on tap.
Tons of beers on tap and a good amount of space. Nice option for a quick after-work drink.
Mercedes RodriguezMay 30, 2013Love this bar, but never coming here straight from work... The bartender on shift then always makes us wait for hours for a drink while he socializes with his buddies.
Cole KennedyJune 27, 2015Head downstairs to the dark, cozy, and quiet bar. It's a welcome relief from the cacophony upstairs.
Try a different beer. They have this refreshing great australian beer. Name: coopers sparkling ale. They have to roll it in order to give some flavor. One of my faves.
Cheap drinks and reasonable food. They have a cool private space downstairs to rent out.
Chris MonahanOctober 20, 2011Be here Saturday, October 22nd from 6-10pm to celebrate St. Crispin's Day with the folks from Crispin Cider. Bring a pair of shoes for donation and receive a Crispin Cider on us!
Kelsey LeeJune 22, 2014Perfect place to grab an after work drink - they have a great selection of drafts!
Nice selection of draft beers. Extra seating in the balcony upstairs to escape the crowd.
Jon RobinsonDecember 22, 2012Puck burger is great. Don't get turned off by the "reserved" signs on the tables. They do that so as to control which parties sit where.
Devon LawrenceFebruary 3, 2015Great after work place for a drink and food. The food menu looks yummy!
- Chris MonahanFebruary 22, 2011Be sure to try a Crispin Cider on draft! It goes great with many of their food selections, by itself, or as a Black Velvet with Guiness!
Rafi SyedMarch 20, 2013Go upstairs or downstairs for a better vibe, don't stay on the main floor which is essentially a walkway from front to back. Cheap Jameson and first-rate dive-bar food.
If you order a drink at the bar, they won't let you sit at the tables. I hate that. ProTip: Sit at a table and order with the waitress.
Vladimir RaevskiyMay 15, 2012Very food range of beers! An a historic building, too! Ask a barman for historic tip
Michelle DaileyAugust 23, 2012Pretty much the most unfriendly bartender in NY. So busy on his cell he won't say one word just throws a menu in front of us. Then when asked about summer ale just gives an FU look. Well Eff ur tip
R Bar NYC - 218 BoweryJune 4, 2010We go at least once a week after work. Great food and staff! Try the Guinness battered Fish and Chips...amazing! Tell them R Bar sent you!
Will VanderhoefAugust 14, 2013Don't overlook the bottled beer selection. It's got a few hard to find selections.
Jonathan BorinJanuary 7, 2011I just got served the most perfect looking Guinness in the 14 years of my drinking lineage... It tasted as perfect as it came!
The bartenders are amazing! I love them! <3. Especially Shane, Kristian and John.
Sneak away from the office to have a drink. There's always seating available down below.
Leah ArrAugust 2, 2011Strawberry Fields is actually really good! It's almost spicy and not really sweet at all! And drink Templeton Rye!
Natalie KFebruary 16, 2016The downstairs bartender is the slowest human on the planet. Each drink took him 10 minutes to make (we're talking vodka soda, not craft cocktail).
JenKuduFebruary 27, 2013The curry fries are, honestly, okay... Simply fries served with a side of curry dipping sauce. Try something else.
MarthaMarch 17, 2013It is in violation of city fire code not to have separate, designated doors for entrance and egress. Your bouncers should know this.
Doug PetkanicsFebruary 23, 2012If you have a hankering for Irish Beef Stew, this is your best bet in the area.
452 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Fri
- 11:00 AM–4:00 AM
- Sat–Sun
- Noon–4:00 AM
(212) 431-1200
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.1
"Nice gin selection, excellent cocktails, negroni on draught(!), awesome bar staff, cool menu"
Hutch B - 8.7
"Love the bartenders here. Super friendly and welcoming. Good place to catch a game as well"
Avin Narasimhan - 8.9
"The chicken bites and avocado fries are amazing! Beers on tap - and best tater tots"
Amber Porter
Appears on 196 lists
Created by Evelyn A
91 items • 27 followers
Created by PALM Beer
151 items • 77 followers
The Best Irish Spots in New York
Created by The Corcoran Group
18 items • 17 followers