Prospect Tavern
American Restaurant$$$$
Madison
"Anthony is the best bar tender ever!!!!! TONYNUTZ!!!!"(3 Tips)
"Try the turkey burger and French onion soup!"(3 Tips)
"Good wings and beer!"(3 Tips)
"Outdoor Seating and Karaoke"(3 Tips)
52 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- anthony
- happy hour
- great value
- karaoke
- balcony
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Love the service food and drinks!!! An amazing family run place. Great music and specials daily. We enjoy the balcony on sunny days and cool nights!!! Best bar in town.
🍕🍺Tea CurranJanuary 12, 2013Lets see. There's mounted animals on the wall, football on the tv, guys at the bar wearing full camo, no one in the place under 30 and Katie Perry dance music blasting. Who is this music for?
Tanya KaysMay 23, 2013What a great place. Awesome staff. Great owners. Love Carole, Anthony and Sean. Great food. Awesome LIVE music May 30 come out for a drink and a tube or two. See ya there
Had 1 close case where they served lobster w little neck clams when I didn’t order clams. I’m allergic from a mollusk allergy and they were totally accommodating about it. Love to go there for food.
Tiffany ZuberMay 12, 2013Fun place with a nice menu! Friend wanted a vegetarian alternative and they were more than happy to help. Definitely would come back!
Very fun place to go! Bar gets busy, so yes you do sometimes wait a second for a drink.... its worth the wait!
This has one very dominant aroma...fresh pressed apricot fruit!
ShadowMarch 29, 2010Great spot for a casual bite and good prices. Consistently good. Recommendations: Turkey Burger, Shepards Pie, Meatloaf, Quesadillas.
Monday night? Hungry? If you dont come here for a $4 bar pie than ur nuts.. Buff chick pie is on !!
Staff is extremely good looking. Whether your looking for a hot waitress/waiter or hot bartender...you can count on this place!
best bloody mary i've ever had. and I hate bloody mary's.- Try the turkey burger and French onion soup! Best around!
- Another fun night with DJ RONNIE!!! Music is great and so are the libations!
- Anthony is the best bar tender ever!!!!! TONYNUTZ!!!!
Dollar beers on Tuesday! Wooooo! Anthony is the bomb bartender- Enjoying some GREAT half price appetizers and a tall Stoli O!!!
Deron JohnsonNovember 1, 2013Food is OK but service is hideous. What's worse is they not once but TWICE took down my comment on their FB page. I'll never be back!
- William CapodannoJuly 24, 2015Just average food. Chicken Murphy was mediocre and service was not great during a less than busy Sunday
Some one needs to let the short muscle hamster bouncer Ed that he's a terrible dancer...
116 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Classic comfort food
Closed until Noon (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- Noon–1:00 AM
- Fri–Sat
- Noon–2:00 AM
(973) 295-6255
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Music
Yes
Dining Options
Bar Service
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 7.4
"Not just chicken; they also serve great, giant chargrilled hamburgers and decent ribs."
Tae Ellin - 7.7
"Great local greasy spoon. Had a delicious Taylor ham, egg and cheese"
William Capodanno - 7.8
"The turkey cheddar sandwich with ranch is a sure thing... portions are generous as well as a friendly staff. Love jumping over here from work at Honda and enjoying their comfort food."
Andrew Lowe
Places people like to go after Prospect Tavern
- 7.2
"The WiFi password is 41hopper. The bar tenders are great. Burgers are excellent. Good selection of beers. Lively atmosphere. Quality TVs for watching sports."
Kazem Edmond - 6.0
"Produce is fresh. Store well laid out. Big though"
diane wood - 6.6
"Good service always...good food always....no brainer eating here!"
diane wood
Appears on 13 lists
Created by Andrew JanMan
15 items • 1 follower
Created by Adam J. Wilson
120 items
Created by Brian Bassett
18 items