Prodigy Coffee & Wine
(Now Closed)Coffee Shop$$$$
West Village, New York
119 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
PaddyApril 16, 2016I love my small independent coffee places and this is definitely a good one. Small selection of pastries and very good espresso coffee. Nice staff and seating for about 10 people inside.
Hands down, my favorite place for espresso drinks in NYC. Get a cortado and enjoy the hardwork of others. Went here on my wedding day, foursquare should tag prodigy as "good for wedding days"
Maren ElizabethDecember 31, 2015The macchiato changed my life. I stopped in once on a whim and picked it randomly off the menu. It was the first time I actually tasted notes in an espresso. A little pricey but worth EVERY PENNY.
One of my fave places in NYC. Wonderful staff, a place to hang out, bring your dog and chill. Epitome of a neighborhood coffee place.
Alex RainertMay 22, 2013If you like babka, you owe it to yourself to get up in the chocolaty delicious loaf of goodness they sell here. Hot damn it's good. Just look at it!!!
Andrew FurmanAugust 26, 2015Solid iced coffee and a decent amount of seating to do work. Also love the wood flooring.
Lori LuoSeptember 16, 2014A cute café with a handful of seats serving up excellent coffee and a few sweet treats. The coffee beans are roasted in Brooklyn, and sourced from fair-trade organizations.
More author and professor types frequent this place. Cortados are unique, and they make great latte art on cappuccinos. Everyone's super friendly.
Gabriel HayesAugust 31, 2015Get the original Frost Bite. A delicious iced coffee treat made with cold brew over shaved ice. Like the best coffee snow cone.
Solid new spot in Greenwich Village. The line tends to get a bit crowded in the mornings, but the staff is friendly, very attentive, and the latte is solid.- Get the "Undertow." Simple syrup, hot espresso, and cold milk taken as a single shot. Great warm/cold thing going on. To be drunk on premises only.
Great people, great coffee. On of the best cappuccinos in the area.
olivier PEYRENovember 2, 2014Cute staff, and best macchiato in the neighborhood. The raisin rolls don't hurt either.
Super solid new coffee spot serving cortados, too. Best joe near the new @weworklabs Varick location. Cardcase works here, but they use the old paper loyalty card. (4 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
David BanJuly 8, 2014Nice shop, nice people. For the iced coffee snobs out there - their iced coffee is actually a combo of hot & cold brewed coffees. Not bad, just not full-on cold brew.
Lauren MacOctober 10, 2015Ham and cheese croissants here are very tasty, and the cappuccinos are high quality. Hope to be back soon!
Kley SippelDecember 5, 2012Excellent coffee; I had a soy mocha. On the pricy side, but they drink rely deliver in quality. No wifi which at first was a letdown, but I was nice to not have the distraction of work.- Slam dunk iced coffee. Though, if you're looking for anything else I'd roll around the corner to Jack's Stirbrew.
The skim iced mocha is a masterful combination of espresso and dark chocolate.. refreshing, not overbearing.
darnisha bishopAugust 12, 2016It's a small place, probably not the best for a long work session. But pop in for a coffee, sit down, and enjoy a good book.
Coffee is great, it's also nice to work there. They don't have wifi, but you can usually grab it from a surrounding place.
Gunnar AasenApril 26, 2015Nice place to hang out for the morning. They don't have wifi but it's possible to steal it from some of the neighboring shops. Also no bathroom.
Great coffee (roasted in Brooklyn!) and a nice selection of pastries in a great environment.
Racky RossDecember 3, 2014This is my favorite place for a cappuccino or a coffee when I'm in the area.- Fantastic Cold Brew, bonus points that they accept Square
They serve up a mean espresso here. Some of the best coffee in West Village.
EatMeDrinkMeNYCFebruary 7, 2014One of the few spots serving George Howell coffee, prodigy is a solid stop for the West Village.
Best lattes and amazing orange bread-- a must-try if you're in the west village.
JinniMay 2, 2013Aside from their namesake specialty, they also carry Harney & Sons teas and nunu chocolate covered espresso beans.
The lighting...the mirror, no...the painting; ok, whatever you go in there for, stay for one of the best lattes in the city !!!
L BMay 23, 2013Try the cinnamon bread. If you like cinnamon rolls you'll be in heaven with this delicious bread.
Jess ArnoldDecember 30, 2015Just got a plain latte. The roast tasted bitter at first but evolved into a much smoother flavor over time. I was pleased overall.
Great space, great coffee. Get a pour over and take a stroll around the village.
If you're a regular download the Pay With Square app & you'll just need to say your name at the counter to pay
Smooth, delicious iced coffee. A large is actually large and very competitively priced for the 'hood.- Frank RimalovskiAugust 4, 2014The cinnamon babka, is sick! If you don't know what babka is just get it.
Great neighborhood coffee shop. The orange-ricotta cake is a delicious, semi-rich treat.
Great pour overs. I prefer the fruitier varieties, like the El Salvador.
Benton PeretSeptember 19, 2013Came on a rainy day with Suz, enjoyed the paper and great cup of coffee.
309 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Prodigy Coffee & Wine
33 Carmine St (btwn Bleecker & Bedford)
New York, NY 10014
United States
New York, NY 10014
United States
rodigy Coffee is a little gem in the heart of the West Village. Our focus is on great coffee delivered with respectful service. We are an espresso bar with a long-standing passion for coffee. We also offer a selection of pastries from the best bakers in NYC.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Fri
- 7:00 AM–7:00 PM
- Sat–Sun
- 8:00 AM–7:00 PM
(212) 414-4142
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Parking
Street
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast
Drinks
Wine
See More
You might also like
- 9.0
"A surprisingly cozy café tucked into the streets of Harlem. The coffees are excellent, and if you’re hungry, the arepas are nice and filling."
Robbert van Batenburg - 8.9
"Some of the best coffee in nyc (cortado and espresso tonic and chai all great) — and hands down the best staff"
Noah Weiss - 8.9
"The iced mocha is so smooth! I also recommend the avocado toast"
Natalie Pacheco
Places people like to go after Prodigy Coffee & Wine
- 9.5
"I love coming here for the entertainment. Piano is my favorite."
Jaclyn Lam - 9.5
"They do a lot of fun events and classes upstairs. Really good selection and gourmet items downstairs!"
Paige C - 9.1
"This theater screens some of the best in independent cinema. It also screens great anime from time to time, both new and classic. It's a great place to catch great films."
Chris Raghoobar
Appears on 460 lists
Be a Local in the West Village
Created by Foursquare Swarm
30 items • 369 followers
Created by Soundz Org
203 items • 77 followers
Created by Daniel Howells
98 items • 93 followers
