Plum Pizzeria & Bar
(Now Closed)Pizzeria and Bar$$$$
East Village, New York
27 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Burcin TortopJuly 29, 2012Try the Mini Pizza With Mushroom&Olives - perfect crispy little pizza if you're not that hungry. If you are, go with the big one. Pizzas are so delicious here!! And mojitos, too.
It's like a better version of Patsy's, which is no surprise because the owner is a former Patsy's chef. Great neighborhood joint with a warm, family-friendly atmosphere.
Mommy ShortsJanuary 2, 2011New spot with lots of stroller space between tables- they bought high chairs right after we requested them and have been very friendly to the baby ever since. Not to mention— awesome pizza.
MaxAugust 7, 2011I haven't had this great of a service in a long time. Not to mention the pizzas are delicious and the pasta was to die for!
Lenora "StellaFi" SJune 2, 2012The Multigrain pizza was delish! Its usually hard to get a good whole grain dish, but this was on point!
URGE MiamiMarch 4, 2011Got the pizza with onions and peppers thought 20 was expensive but it was great I'll be back often but watch out on the toppings
sebastain mooreAugust 23, 2010The best pizza in the east village! I've tried all the pizza's in the village and this is by far hands down the BEST!
Had the pumpkin ravioli. So great. Wish they had an appetizer size. Excellent share plate for a starter.
Tee RulesOctober 16, 2010I'm in a huge group and we ordered almost everything. So anything here is awesome. You're pretty much safe.- Great pizza, red sauce like grandma used to make -- yum! Ask for Isabelle (waitress) - she's great!! :-)
Try the Linguine Nero Gamberetto Black Linguini, Shrimp, Light Garlic, And Light Olive Oil - Excellent!!!- The pizza is so crispy I didn't even have to tell them it's really a new gem spot in The neighborhood!
- sebastain mooreAugust 28, 2010I went back again last night to make sure that the first time I tasted the food my taste buds weren't teasing me...and they weren't..It was better then the first time. This place is amazing!!!
Vince is old school bartender, he understands how to make a great drink. Ask for him
- Try the Verde Salad Mixed Green Olives, Carrots, Tomatoes, Frisée And Lemon Vinaigrette
Amanda FisherSeptember 2, 2010I stopped in last night and I'm going again tonight. The pizza is off the hook!
aaron earlsDecember 10, 2011I guess I'm in the minority, food is average at best and wine by glass is below mediocre (a telling sign). No buffalo mozzarella on the bruschetta? Walk to Posto on 18th.
24 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Plum Pizzeria & Bar
157 2nd Ave (B/w E. 9th & 10th. St.)
New York, NY 10003
United States
New York, NY 10003
United States
Welcome to plum pizzeria and bar, located in the heart of East Village. We specialize in the best Italian style pizza, pasta, and salad that New York has to offer.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 5:00 PM–Midnight
- Fri–Sat
- 11:30 AM–2:00 AM
- Sun
- 11:30 AM–Midnight
(212) 375-9555
Food & Drink
Drinks
Wine
See More
You might also like
- 9.5
"Highly recommend this restaurant for its food & its atmosphere. Enjoyed: cappuccino, iced coffee, burrata plate, 4 Stagioni, parmigiana, & flourless chocolate cake with strawberry & whipped cream."
Stephanie M
- 9.1
"This place has an old school diner vibe with draft Budweiser and solid pizza. Plus there's awesome rap music always playing. Try a slice of Sicilian."
Jamie Lonie - 9.0
"Tasty slices - and the Sicilian pies looked great, too."
Jonas Bergqvist
