Pizza Papalis
Pizzeria$$$$
Warehouse Entertainment District, Toledo
"Deep dish pizza here is always amazing, and well worth the wait."(17 Tips)
"Deep dish is just as good as Chicago deep dish!"(2 Tips)
"Perfect before a Walleye or Mud Hen game."(2 Tips)
"Other pizzas & calzones are awesome!"(2 Tips)
46 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- mud hens game
- good for groups
- calzones
- casual
- (13 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
A good place to come hang out before the Mud Hens game. Pizza is delicious and the house salad dressing is "plate lickable."
Jennette GoansMarch 11, 2017Simply Great! - Booked their party room, which was extremely reasonably priced, and very simple to book. The food was so tasty, plentiful, and again very reasonably priced! The service was AWESOME
Jon HighlanderOctober 28, 2015I was in a layover waiting for a greyhound bus and was starving. I looked up to see what was close by and tried this place. Best deep dish pizza i ever had. Little expensive, but very good.
Mike ScavnickyApril 7, 2020Took the family on a road trip and brought back half baked pizzas for us to make once we got back home. Even delivered some to a couple of friends that requested it.
Christopher KlineMay 9, 2011Hey did you know that if you dial 90210 on your phone and SMS text the word Deepdish and hit send, you get back a secret deal for the day or the week, they even raffle off a free pizza once in a while- Ciera SmithSeptember 25, 2014Love the deep dish pizza here. It's the closest to the actual Chicago deep dish that I've tried.
T-town TomApril 30, 2017Yes it's a chain. But the deep dish is good. Also, the oven baked chocolate chip cookie for dessert.
Courtney LittenMarch 23, 2014It was my first experience and the pizza was fantastic! Wasn't a long wait all around:) Best pizza I've had!
Amy WarnerAugust 11, 2016The only problem we have with this pizza......there's not one in Wanamaker Indiana!
Mike PAugust 2, 2012Obviously a great place to go before the game and they have a quality craft beer selection.- Stephanie WiseJuly 10, 2013Forget the rest of the menu! Deep dish is just as good as Chicago deep dish!
- Christopher KlineJune 8, 2010On slower non baseball/hockey nights you can pre-order your deepdish pizza by calling 419-244-7722 and have it started before you get there! Why? Because it takes 45 minutes to make a Real Deep Dish!
$1 bud light and yuengling Sunday thru Wednesday. Good place to watch football on Sunday :)
Hanady AwadaNovember 11, 2011Try the Butter Crusted Pan Pizza- just took their recipe to the next level! TASTY!!
Burkett Restaurant EquipmentFebruary 26, 2010Great Pizza..its huge! Great atmosphere also, check it out if your in town. Its right near the new Arena.
- Don't come to hungry if you want a deep dish. Takes 45 mins. Other pizzas & calzones are awesome!
Make you visit the magnificent bartender Gordo. He'll take care of you all night.
- Perfect before a Walleye or Mud Hen game. $3 22oz Labatt on game days.
Toledo BladeSeptember 12, 2010The Blade's review: PizzaPapalis ***Chicago-style deep-dish pizza delights http://tol.bz/bpScFl Read more
Tina Howton LamunyonApril 7, 2013Was there for a party not impressed with the thin pizza maybe try deep dish next time
Christi FosgateJuly 4, 2012Over an hour for a pizza? This place needs to get their service together!
TCJuly 19, 2010Love the food but had the WORST service. Waiter abandoned us and never came back after food came.
101 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Years ago we began a search to discover a true pizza masterpiece- leading to the creation of PizzaPapalis. Eat hearty, have fun, and we hope to see you soon.
Closed until 11:00 AM (Show more)
- Tue–Thu, Sun
- 11:00 AM–9:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
(419) 244-7722
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Pizza Papalis
Appears on 19 lists
Created by Kelli Yingling
17 items • 5 followersCreated by Sean Hertzsch
20 items • 20 followersCreated by April Saling
5 items • 4 followers
