Pizza Beach
(Now Closed)Pizzeria and New American Restaurant$$$$
Upper East Side, New York
30 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Anna McPheeJune 6, 2018Perfect for your group of friends with all different dietary restrictions. They have something for even the gluten free “vegan” who still puts bacon on everything.- Anna McPheeJune 6, 2018The vodka pizza is a must for anyone who likes a bit of spice, and the mushroom pizza is perfect for the truffle lover! When it’s cooking in the kitchen you can smell it at your table!
Andrew CJuly 17, 2018All of the pizzas are spectacular... they have other things on the menu, but not worth it + cocktails are quite unique and tasty!!
dawn.in.newyorkMarch 14, 2015Spicy Soppressata pizza was so delicious. Watermelon martini was unique, but not that special. I would skip next time.
Leisha MagsisiJune 24, 2015Burrata is delicious. Get the corn salad. Watermelon martinis are a must. Oh, and good pizza too!
Paige CFebruary 27, 2015Wait staff is very friendly, but the service was beyond slow. Took forever to order and get the check. The mushroom white truffle pizza is definitely a hit. I recommend it. Lamb pizza was just ok.
Hannah LaHoodApril 15, 2015This place has a great atmosphere and helps give a much needed cool factor to the UES. Plus they make a perfect pizza!
Brittany SübersMarch 4, 2017This is a cute spot, but not the best pizza in the area. Try SAN Matteo (more authentic).
Kristen PeiranoJuly 7, 2015The squash pizza has zero flavor. You can tell they use cheap ingredients as the Parmesan I asked for to give my pizza flavor also had no flavor. Sopressata was good service was good
Michelle AlexanderSeptember 12, 2015Stick to the pizza, the pasta offerings are missing depth of flavor.
Caleb LubarskyMay 31, 2015Nothing special. Pizza sauce was just canned tomatoes. Pasta w/ Short Rib was tasty, but overall the place is way overpriced and the pizza was underwhelming.
Ryan GallagherApril 26, 2015Nothing is good. Awful service as well as food. Expensive for what it is as well. If you want good thin crust pizza as a sit down take the trip to Marta.
Rebecca WJuly 3, 2015Food is too expensive. Portions are small. Service is mediocre. The food is good but not worth the money or the portion size.
Gianna SantelliDecember 22, 2016Average - I was expecting better. Extremely low lighting almost comical.
61 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Pizza. Beach. Sleep. Repeat.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Wed, Sun
- 11:30 AM–11:00 PM
(646) 666-0819
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Dinner, Dessert
Drinks
Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.7
"Probably the best pizza in the UES. Staff is also really friendly! The eggplant parm was also very nice if you want to try something a little different."
Amy Park - 9.1
"Pizza of course. NY Style Large Slice. Fold it and eat it. Amazing!"
John Howard - 9.0
"Amazing pizza! Good for a slice on the go when walking in the West Village. only 6 seats, cash only!"
Vincent Steurs
Places people like to go after Pizza Beach
- 8.7
"Upbeat and nice bar that can get crowded. Well made drinks. Must try the oyster sliders!"
Lisa F - 9.5
"You have to reserve at least a couple of whole day for met, it is unbelievably large and each piece is amazing!"
Ayşe Nur Ayyıldız - 8.4
"Super tasty! Eurotart with peanuts, yogurt chips, coconut, honey, and caramel."
Shannon *
Appears on 165 lists
Created by Melody R.
193 items • 4 followers
Manhattan To-Do's (Above 59th Street)
Created by Rachel W.
97 items • 6 followersCreated by Christa Hoegler
135 items • 20 followers