Pie Face
(Now Closed)Pie Shop and Bakery$$$$
Theater District, New York
50 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Flat white, start my heart blend is what gets me through the day whenever I need a kick. The meat pies are to die for, I love the small ones so that I can enjoy it and not get stuffed - great snack.
Јс тояяєѕMarch 17, 2013I enjoyed my time at Pie Face SO MUCH, tasty pies, good coffee (kick my arse, the best) and the guys at the counter (Cassandra, Pam and Joe) are awesome!!!
The chunky steak pie stacked is freaking delicious. Don't forget the Aussie style coffee! Matt makes the best lattes with awesome latte art. Give it a shot!
The Wall Street JournalApril 5, 2012The sweet pies, such as pear ricotta or chocolate, are just a few bites, so customers can enjoy them with minimal guilt or, perhaps more fun, sample a few. Read more
You can get a large soy (at no extra charge) latte for less than the price of a regular/grande at nearby Coffee Bean/Starbucks #FTW
Duncan PflasterAugust 10, 2012This place: open 24 hours, fantastic pies both sweet and savory. Make sure to get a card to you can get a free pie once you buy a certain number.
Karin RMarch 31, 2012Try the Mince & Tomato Stack - #tasty #warm #comfortfood on a cold spring evening, mate. I'm rather fond of another sitdown Aussie Pie shop, but this is good.
Brooke RosenblumFebruary 24, 2012Try the coffee and any of the pies (stacked!) the mini pies are great for snacks. I love the Thai chicken curry yummm
Nancy HeOctober 10, 2014The egg, bacon and cheese pie is such a great breakfast. Coffee is good as well!
Ramya SampathApril 25, 2013Crazily delicious veggie pie made of basically butter masala in a pie. So good!
Jonathon MatthewsSeptember 23, 2012Get the BBQ Pulled Pork with Smash and Gravy. It's like an entire southern meal in one!
Open 24 hours. Mince beef mini pies are the best bet... and their pumpkin mini pies
Vidhi BallaneyAugust 23, 2013Their lil chocolate pies are delish..Get them if you are a chocolate lover
Soyul Bia KimAugust 31, 2012AHHH! Their almond sticks are divine. Note that the "eggs, bacon and cheese" PFs don't come in minis.
Every Wednesday it's half off coffee from 8 - 9 am. Delish!
Luke BauerNovember 10, 2012An interesting place to grab a quick breakfast, but the pies are delicious.
Vivian GuJanuary 24, 2012The Mexican Pie was delicious. For a limited time enjoy a free cup of coffee with your meal.
The chicken-mushroom is the best chicken pot pie you've ever eaten, squared.
love the thai chicken curry stack! the bacon, egg and cheese pie... not so much.
Joanna WeinsteinJanuary 24, 2012Free coffee coupons all weekl! Try the classic chicken and mushroom pie stacked.
M BSeptember 26, 2013A bit pricey for little pastries but hey it's NY...yummy pies though (beef roll delish)
Jenai ChinJanuary 23, 2012Pie is ok. Crust is flaky and chicken is moist white meat but the gravy inside is like jelly. Work on the gravy!
Banshee 🐰 BunnyOctober 31, 2013Thai chicken curry pie is tasty. Ordered the Aussie iced coffee during the day, which was supposed to be made with espresso but guy said they were "out"... used coffee instead. Terribly sweet. Meh.
Got the Minced Beef & Tomato pie stacked! Yum but still hungry.. MOREEE!
Josh BabetskiFebruary 12, 2012I dropped a Collectivus Cherry Lime Chocolate Cupcake of Nom-Nom-Nom Thingie here. Look for Thingies near here too. Read more
Leslie OroFebruary 25, 2012They should work on the options offered. I personally don't like gravy, so i didn't like the chucky steak pie. The crust was good.
Pam B.February 14, 2012Excruciatingly slow, so you'll have plenty of time to listen to the terrible music.
john laskowJune 11, 2012$7.00 for a roast beef sandwich with two practically transparent pieces of meat. Don't waste your money.
Patrick GavinFebruary 7, 2012Bland meat pies. Skip this place and hit up Tuck Shop in the East Village or Chelsea Market instead.
315 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Australia's favorite 24-hour bakery café brings iconic Aussie meat pies, baked goods and premium espresso to New Yorkers at its first location outside of Australia
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 7:00 AM–11:00 PM
(855) 444-3388
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
See More
You might also like
- 9.4
"Pineapple Linzer cookie is amazing; great service; delicious teas."
Beni Chhun - 9.3
"Adobada and chicken tacos are amazing, also worth trying the quesadilla"
Emmanuel Kontokalos - 9.4
"Potato gnocchi is a MUST, as are the roasted mushrooms. Extraordinary restaurant, all New Yorkers must try at least once."
Mike Nickerson
Places people like to go after Pie Face
- 8.6
"LOVE their combo platters! Great white sauce."
Ayesha Rehman - 8.4
"Always my favourite place to be when I am in NY. Love the dynamic."
Atika Al-Bimani - 8.6
"Nice place to sit outdoors with usually live music during the summer and during the winter to get into the holiday season. Beautiful lighting and atmosphere."
Erica Choi
