See all
158 photos

Pappardella

Italian Restaurant$$$$

Upper West Side, New York

Save

Pappardella

7.3^/10

266

ratings

Ranked #9 for pasta in the Upper West Side
"Excellent pizzas and orchiette baresi."(2 Tips)
"Get a to-go picnic basket and eat at Central Park."(2 Tips)
"the pappardella buttera is amazing."(2 Tips)
"Pappardelle Funghi E Tartufo is fantastic"(2 Tips)

57 Tips and reviews

Filter:

baresi
picnic basket
good for dates
buttera
wine
gluten-free food
bruschetta
good for groups
gelato
brunch food
coffee
asparagus
salads
spinach
bacon
dinner
meats
orecchiette
pesto
good for special occasions
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Andrew BaronNovember 11, 2012
This is one of my favorite Italian restaurants in nyc. The very best dish is the baked asparagus appetizer with mozzarella and pesto. The penne pasta with tomato sauce is also a favorite. Mmmmmm.
Matt ZoufalyAugust 9, 2014
The orecchiette is absolutely fantastic. One of my favorite pasta dishes anywhere in NYC. Also try the tricolore salad with one of their Italian red wines.
Steven YanJuly 1, 2013
I absolutely love their Prosciutto Pizza with some Sausage! So thin crusty and yummy! Tried some others in the menu, but still love the Prosciutto. Have to try their Gluten-free selections.
Francesco MastracchioJuly 19, 2016
I truly enjoyed the Orecchiete barese while my wife enjoyed the lobster ravioli. Outside seating was great with courteous and personable staff.
April DitoSeptember 13, 2015
They have an entire gluten free menu which is great. The chef made me a gluten free eggplant Parmesan even though it's not on the menu.
HolidayDecember 15, 2017
Top Classic Italian. I had the Pollo Solaire with the Mozzarella starter and I believe a bottle of Bolaro. Stunning.
Stu MarkMay 14, 2022
Everything!! Great food and service. Super GF menu if you’re w peeps that need it.
Johnny BaryahAugust 4, 2014
Great food, great people and great ambience! As soon as we stepped in it felt like we teleported to Italy.
Erin SmithMarch 14, 2012
Amazing gluten-free menu. Get the GF bruschetta with prosciutto, goat cheese, and fig!
Nitzan BJuly 26, 2017
Took the picnic in the park deal, food was nice and came with the cutest picnic table cloth too!
Cheapeats IncJanuary 14, 2015
A staple in neighborhood for a long time. 3 course lunch for $16.85. You can't beat that.
AllyOctober 31, 2013
This place has the perfect comfort food. The tagliatelle was amazing and service was great too :)
KEApril 15, 2016
Food was great but atmosphere was off. The music was super quiet then loud and my date and I literally stopped talking at one point bc we were the only sound in the room. Music was also weird 80s?
Stacey GeddieJune 17, 2011
Amazing food and service. Had the small plater for app and shell fish pasta for main. We will be back next time in NYC.
Sharat PotharajuMarch 7, 2015
Loved it! Highly recommend it. The eggplant Parmesan and the gnocchi was delicious.
Karen UriotApril 25, 2011
The bread is good. The gnocchi and the penne with spinach very tasty. May be too much expensive regarding the quantity of food (pizzas seem small). Try "il caffé" !
Ryan McMahonMay 10, 2015
Decent pastas and pizza. Biggest draw is that they have big gluten-free selection of your group requires it
Alex FishAugust 3, 2015
The pasta is spot on and the wine is very reasonably priced
Mark LombardiNovember 1, 2014
Chicken Parm is excellent. Gets busy so make a reservation.
Chelsea BalkanJuly 15, 2017
#DubiDONT their version of a Margherita pizza was just a regular cheese pizza and wasn't good. Broccoli rabe pasta was too oily and bland and the sausage wasn't good. Don't waste your money.
nymagApril 4, 2011
Sponsored Tip: Order San Pellegrino or Acqua Panna water at this casual Italian spot and a donation will be made to Share Our Strength! Read more
Gilt CityMay 31, 2011
We've been told that regulars include such icons as Dustin Hoffman, Michael Douglas, Jerry Seinfeld and Sean Penn. It must be the truffle-laced pizza with ricotta.
BlackboardEatsApril 19, 2011
Menu musts: Porchetta (pork loin and belly) with Tuscan herbs and the orecchiette with sun-dried tomatoes, rapini, Baresi Italian sausage. Read more
Ashley LippolisDecember 8, 2013
If you're into the goat cheese and beets thing, the caprino salad is soooo tasty!
Bryanne PashleyOctober 13, 2012
Don't come in large groups: food delivered to the wrong person that gets eaten a little and sent back, is reheated and given to the next/correct person.
John ConteDecember 27, 2014
Solid b+ food was tasty, servers are polite. Good choice.
Bryanne PashleyOctober 13, 2012
Beware of coming in large groups. They may forget to bring half of your drink orders until reminded (even though they are all the same).
Delverde Pasta USAOctober 10, 2011
Try their Spaghetti Polpette. It has just the right amount of spice and their meatballs are delish!
Julie QiuAugust 31, 2011
Pappardelle Funghi E Tartufo is fantastic
Crystal WardJune 8, 2015
Just picking up our prepared Picnic Basket ;)
Kalikina VJune 11, 2013
Get a to-go picnic basket and eat at Central Park.
Michael Fox-RabinovitzDecember 26, 2015
Decent neighborhood Italian, prosciutto, eggplant parm are OK. Used to be better.
Will HarahanAugust 9, 2018
Been here 25+ times
The food was much better than I remembered, but the service needs a little work.
clear blueJanuary 17, 2015
Asparagus with pesto is awesome
Irina SimatovaMarch 14, 2015
Nice seafood linguine but was waiting about 40 min! 10min for soup.
Jessica KolnosJanuary 14, 2016
The salads are all phenomenal.
Ali WattsJune 14, 2011
awesome brunch - pizza was amazing but panini isn't a traditional i.e. not presses so bread was a bit much Read more
Cristina ROctober 10, 2011
Been here 25+ times
Amazing food, amazing service, but VERY small portions - especially for brunch.
James BrownSeptember 26, 2016
Nice little place near Central Park
AaronAugust 24, 2011
Great food. Great place for avdate or special occasion.
Dina AndroicMarch 18, 2019
Pasta, cavolo salad
Christopher ThorpeMay 2, 2011
Excellent pizzas and orchiette baresi. Definitely come again.
JenKuduMay 28, 2012
Pappardelle buttera is highly recommended!
Sam KrasnikMay 14, 2016
Good chicken parmesan
Veronica UribeAugust 2, 2018
Hostess was rude, food was good but not worth the bad experience. Not a place to go with kids.
Tanya ColletteJuly 11, 2012
Great service, awesome pasta!
Игорь ТорикJuly 21, 2018
The steak tastes like half baked not grilled..
Paul RMarch 20, 2018
Mushroom piZza
S MMarch 8, 2011
Went in for tiramisu...wish it had more chocolate & less cream though
TeaSeptember 12, 2010
Been here 5+ times
The focaccia with herbs is so worth it.

1 2

158 Photos

Pappardella

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Pappardella

Appears on 157 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.