53 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
JTSeptember 17, 2014The Tiramisu Cheesecake is phenomenal!!! All the desserts are huge! Save room for a slice of cake or pie. All the food is delicious and large portions. Truly a great place with an amazing staff!!
Hansel VerasApril 14, 2016We are getting Take out tonight😋 cakes hear look BOMB tho!!! Omg😬 I'm on a diet right now so can't slip💪🏽 ordered the buffalo wings & cheese burger deluxe to go.every thing looks good on the menu
Me and my co-workers come here at least once per week. We love this place. Food is good at a good price, and fast friendly service. We love it here.
Robin FarrowMay 11, 2016Greek salad with Chicken and sweet potato fries-beware large is HUGE! Very filling and chicken was flavorful!
Ian TarasevitschJuly 13, 2014Oh. My. God. The dessert case alone will keep you coming back. Good food, huge portions, attentive staff. What's not to like?
Tina TreichNovember 8, 2018Fantastic food with HUGE portions. Definitely going home with extra for later and the cheesecake is killer, awesome amazing!!!
Sean BonusFebruary 2, 2015If you're debating between pancakes and the French toast, don't even waste your time with the pancakes. Their French toast is amazing.- Tabitha SerranoJune 29, 2015Love this place, food is great and their desserts are out of this world. Large portions that I always take home.
Nice family place. Good food and lots of it for not a lot of money.
Meredith StandMarch 31, 2012We come here every morning when we visit the area and they make a fantastic breakfast!!!
Hans MoritzFebruary 28, 2015Friendly hostess our server Sonya R was very nice, our breakfast came quickly and hot !
Yuval TalAugust 11, 2017Portions are huge! I went for a Greek Salad which was ok but nothing more. The place in general doesn't feel clean and the restroom are a proof of that.
Kari AnthonyFebruary 6, 2012Great food, reasonable prices and definitely a place I will visit every time I am in NJ.
Food and service used to be awesome. Food slowly getting better. Service still blows. They need to hire waitress' without track marks.
VAugust 31, 2013Not a bad diner by any means. Mostly good service and when the owner is there to ring up the bill he's pleasant (an improvement from the grouchy old folks that used to do it).
Amanda TarasevitschJuly 13, 2014Eggs Benedict, followed by Lemon Meringue Pie...OMG! #Delicious #BakeryHeaven
Always great food and early morn ask for Sue!
Tony TamondongSeptember 3, 2011MY FAV DINER BY MY HOUSE GOOD PRICES OPEN 24 HRS N THEY HAVE KILLER CAKES N PIES :)
Brian RiveraJuly 20, 2011Absolutely amazing cheesecake. Try the Tiramisu. Life-changing!!! Hella good!!!
Latisha M.August 17, 2011Tiramisu cheesecake and Chocolate Covered Raspberry CHeesecake... Must tries!
Effie Bliziotis PantagisJune 7, 2012Cheesecakes are baked at Pantagis Diner and come in small , medium and large!
Friendly staff, never had a bad meal here. Known for their awesome cheesecakes-try a slice!
Tony BatmanNovember 7, 2011We had a great meal here while in town for Exxxotica Expo
Laura BodnarAugust 27, 2014Food was ok. Friendly staff. Cakes aren't the best but will try a cheesecake next time.
Chris BaileyApril 15, 2018No enough help sitting people. Cashier too busy to seat customers. Waited 5 mins Seated our selves
47 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 6:00 AM–Midnight
- Fri–Sat
- 6:00 AM–2:00 AM
(732) 709-3555
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Dinner
See More
You might also like
- 6.8
"Had a great breakfast. The service was great, notable and fast."
John😎🐕🍻 Kelly👍☘☘ - 8.1
"Amazing service from Brian and the manager. Fantastic food, service, and decor. Can't wait to come back. Get the Thanksgiving sandwich!"
Joe Ginese - 7.7
"Nice place, great food! Good service! Very family orientated place !!! AMAZING SOUP"
Jennifer Medina
Places people like to go after Pantagis Diner
Appears on 19 lists
Created by Jimmy Kastner
199 items • 984 followers
Created by Scott B
197 items • 43 followers