Paneantico
Bakery and Italian Restaurant$$$$
Bay Ridge, Brooklyn
"A wide variety of Italian pastries."(8 Tips)
"Some of the best Italian sandwiches in Brooklyn."(2 Tips)
"Pignoli actually better than the rainbow cookie"(2 Tips)
"fried eggplant and sopressata."(2 Tips)
59 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- sandwiches
- coffee
- lively
- casual
- cookies
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
TaniaOctober 16, 2016One of the best places for brunches! Cappuccino is great, cheesecake and baked eggplant with mozzarella cheese❤️
- AmateurConciergeDecember 10, 2016Some of the best sandwiches around. Hot soppresata is your move. Skip the frittata. Pignoli actually better than the rainbow cookie
Karen ZJuly 30, 2015Eggplant parm sandwich and chicken mozzarella balsamic.(amazing balsamic) Best splitkies ever!
Mary JasenNovember 6, 2016Dessert is great, Strawberry Shortcake lite and fluffy with "real" whip cream, tiramisu also tasty and light.
Rosamaria P.November 24, 2013Great service and decent coffee. Nice place to catch up with friends. Their sandwiches have always been great too.
Reason number 2 for going to Bay Ridge, one of the best places to eat anything from sandwiches on a hero to cannolis (4 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
Siobhan McNallyFebruary 9, 2014Very good if you watch the prices. Their pizza is good value and the Italian cookie cake is perfect for any special occasion. Love the cannolis.- Some of the best Italian sandwiches in Brooklyn. Get Mozzarella and Prosciutto on their bread!
Tom MaximFebruary 14, 2015Awesome sandwich cafe with outside seating. Their balsamic is out of this world.
Laura Diana-GarrattApril 7, 2012Try the stuffed artichoke...amazing..honestly ...all of the food is amazing you really can't go wrong .. And make sure to sit outside
The pignoli cookies are amazing, really chewy and almond-y. Love them!
Andrew WeiserJanuary 26, 2018B8: Prosciutto, smoked mozz, fried eggplant and roasted peppers on a hard or soft hero.
Sarah TierneyMay 17, 2015Their eggplant parm is amazing, as is the sandwich with fried eggplant and sopressata.
- Hailey TobmanAugust 20, 2018The sausage pepper and onion sandwich was amazing as well as the cannolis
- Delish. A wide variety of Italian pastries. Love the Pusties!!
The young girl Gianna is friendly and very helpful.
Victoria DimApril 22, 2017Everything is so terribly sweet! Your lips may stick together even before you bite it.
Get the # 9 sandwich on brick oven bread with chicken cutlet - the best!!
The male employees wear their hats like jerkoffs there. Wear your hats straight, tools. Management should be embarrassed.
122 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 10:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 7:00 AM–10:00 PM
(718) 680-2347
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch
See More
You might also like
- 7.4
"Kringle is dense and delicious. Raspberry > apricot. Pecan ring is a light, yeasty cake that goes well with coffee"
Lori K. http://www.lkpheartsfood.net - 8.1
"Nice lunch place & cool pastries"
Hany Youssef - 8.1
"Step back into time to a truly old school bakery reminiscent of the good old days of Brooklyn. Everything is amazing! Hope this place stays open forever!"
Antonella
Places people like to go after Paneantico
- 8.9
"Try the Peanut Butter Cookie - One of the best ever"
Mike Chau - 7.6
"Now that they’ve gone through their renovations this is a great place. Staff is super friendly - they make an effort to know your name and your order. Lots of seating..."
Mark B - 7.1
"Turning into my favorite grocery store in Bay Ridge. Better selection than most, thanks to its size. Great fresh produce. Tends to be packed on the weekend so remember to bring your patience..."
Mark B
Appears on 81 lists
The Good Life Guide™ Business Participants
Created by Jovi Offitto
27 items • 7 followers
Some guy from South Brooklyn told me about these
Created by Steve Spillman
27 items • 10 followers
Created by Matt Finder
79 items • 8 followers
