See all
42 photos

Pancho's Cantina

(Now Closed)

Mexican Restaurant$$$$

Island Park

Save

Pancho's Cantina

22 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Andrew BermanFebruary 19, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Consistently the best Tex-Mex north of the Rio Grande.
Will SchollMay 5, 2015
Spacious, fun interior. Staff is happy to have you and very accommodating. Enchilada was particularly tasty.
Tara House JaffeOctober 20, 2012
Chihuahua chicken soup is amazing and low cal. Their traditional margaritas are made fresh, no mixes. And come prepared to draw on the paper tablecloths.
DustinJune 4, 2016
Been here 10+ times
Want Panchos but also want to avoid the crowds? Come for weekend brunch. Full menu, plus brunch specials, *plus* $3 drinks.
Christopher WalshDecember 17, 2014
What can you say? Get the fajitas. That's what they're known for. Margaritas were tasty as well.
A. Imelda GuardadoMay 1, 2016
the. Portabella mushroom fajitas are amazing and there's always room for fried ice cream…
DustinDecember 29, 2015
Been here 10+ times
Always busy; they don't do reservations, but call 30 minutes ahead so they can put you on the list.
Daniel ShermanNovember 19, 2014
Now Open For Brunch....Sat/Sun 11:30-3:00
Alex GreenbergJune 6, 2014
Order came in 5 minutes. impressive.
larry trasciattiNovember 25, 2017
I really liked the Nevada cheeseburger 🍔
Inaki OrozcoJuly 14, 2012
Try the cadillac margarita with Riazul Tequila!! Out of this world
larry trasciattiJuly 13, 2018
Good food, Fine waitress
Pancho's CantinaMarch 5, 2014
Every Wednesday Is Ladies Night!
Andrew SchnallJuly 11, 2013
Margarita chicken and Panchos salad.
Erin ShawDecember 21, 2011
Been here 5+ times
mustache mondays! rock a mustache, get a free dessert!
Michael AndreoApril 15, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Cattle men's steak
Alicia AlvaradoSeptember 12, 2013
Not nearly as good as it was before Sandy. Margaritas are good but come in a teensy tiny cup.
JoJo BeansMarch 26, 2011
The Mexicali Blue drink is awesome =)
SarahAugust 24, 2013
Margarita yumyum!
Ryan DOctober 23, 2010
Been here 5+ times
try the enchiladas!
Elisa WeissFebruary 14, 2010
Love the fajitas!
Evelyn BrennanAugust 1, 2010
FAJITAS!!!!!!!!!!!! Mmmmm

42 Photos

Pancho's Cantina

4245 Austin Blvd (at Audubon Blvd)
Island Park, NY 11558
United States

Get directions

Pancho's Cantina Provides Restaurant, Barbecue Cuisine, Mexican Cuisine, Weddings Dinners, Wedding Rehearsal Dinners, Reunions, Private Parties, Holiday Parties, Private Rooms, Tex-Mex Cuisine to The Island Park, NY Area.