See all
18 photos

Nicky’s Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Italian Restaurant, Pizzeria, and American Restaurant$$$$

Madison

Save

7.4^/10

ratings

Ranked #3 for Italian restaurants in Madison
"Great service...great food...and great atmosphere."(2 Tips)
"Sausage and Sicilian pizzas are my favorite here, but it’s all good."(11 Tips)

23 Tips and reviews

Filter:

pizza
food and great atmosphere
great value
good for dates
wraps
sausage
pesto
green sauce
dinner
lunch
town
(6 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Russell SiminoffSeptember 27, 2022
Been here 5+ times
Sausage and Sicilian pizzas are my favorite here, but it’s all good. Very friendly service too.
Cassie RoeloffsMarch 15, 2017
One of the cutest restaurants in town, great pizza and Italian food and great atmosphere for a sit down meal
Laura LEEApril 29, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Amazing thin crust pizza! Great specialty pies too. Friendly staff , cute decor....try it NOW!
George LMarch 30, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Nice thin crust pizza...the pesto pie with both red and green sauce is a personal fav :)
Henry JayJuly 28, 2016
Great service...great food...and great atmosphere. Enjoyed it very much.
Courtney SmithOctober 9, 2013
The food was great n all the neat fire items that surround place to me is better kool
ᴡ LundeDecember 10, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Frequent coupons come in the valpak mailer. And they have slices/soda lunch specials on weekdays.
Bruce BoillotatOctober 2, 2016
What's Good Here? Everything! never been disappointed
Jerret WestApril 15, 2012
Just re-opened after a yearlong remodel. The interior looks great and pizza was quite good.
AndrewFebruary 7, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Best pizza ever no question. I've worked in pizzerias for 5 + years I know good pizza
A KOctober 22, 2014
Good place for Italian dinner with family.
Clint VarnamNovember 6, 2012
Order the burger. SO GOOD
Daria BlednovaJuly 19, 2016
I lovvvvvve the food here!
Jackie BarraNovember 23, 2012
Best grandma pie !!
Sara GaonaSeptember 3, 2011
My favorite pizza in Madison!
Darcie KingNovember 5, 2010
Nicky's special pizza is outstanding!
Alicia KJanuary 10, 2011
got a rancho wrap to go; delicious!
Mike GuimondJune 17, 2013
Nicky's salad
ShadowMarch 29, 2010
One of the better pizza places in the area.
ELOQUENT STUDIOSDecember 9, 2010
Been here 5+ times
The best pizza anywhere!
Bryan MortensenJuly 6, 2015
The food was boring.
Leigh WexlerMarch 5, 2013
I would not recommend this place
Matt ZahandJanuary 14, 2011
Worst coleslaw ever! Seriously, avoid at all cost.