Nicky’s Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
Italian Restaurant, Pizzeria, and American Restaurant$$$$
Madison
Ranked #3 for Italian restaurants in Madison
"Great service...great food...and great atmosphere."(2 Tips)
"Sausage and Sicilian pizzas are my favorite here, but it’s all good."(11 Tips)
23 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- food and great atmosphere
- great value
- good for dates
- wraps
- (6 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Sausage and Sicilian pizzas are my favorite here, but it’s all good. Very friendly service too.
Cassie RoeloffsMarch 15, 2017One of the cutest restaurants in town, great pizza and Italian food and great atmosphere for a sit down meal
Amazing thin crust pizza! Great specialty pies too. Friendly staff , cute decor....try it NOW!
Nice thin crust pizza...the pesto pie with both red and green sauce is a personal fav :)
Courtney SmithOctober 9, 2013The food was great n all the neat fire items that surround place to me is better kool
Frequent coupons come in the valpak mailer. And they have slices/soda lunch specials on weekdays.
Jerret WestApril 15, 2012Just re-opened after a yearlong remodel. The interior looks great and pizza was quite good.
Best pizza ever no question. I've worked in pizzerias for 5 + years I know good pizza
18 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Nicky’s Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
15 Central Ave
Madison, NJ 07940
United States
Madison, NJ 07940
United States
Since 1991, Nicky's Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria has been serving up fresh, delicious Italian cuisine in a family-friendly atmosphere.
Open until 10:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Tue–Sat
- 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
- Sun
- Noon–10:00 PM
(973) 765-0565
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
See More
You might also like
- 6.9
"Their hawaiian pizza is my favorite by far."
Brian Chase - 8.0
"Easily one of the best Italian restaurants in New Jersey. Excellent service and the food is unbelievable. They do fish and meat very well. It's BYOB as well."
Alex Zaltsman - 6.8
"This is a find! After a long day of teaching at FDU. A chill vibe. Delicious food. Sweet servers. With Latte. Happy to unwind here before my drive home."
Jane Seaman
Places people like to go after Nicky’s Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
- 7.4
"Great variety of beers. Perfect place to meet with a crew after work."
Chris Gieger - 9.0
"Love the wine, love the beer, love the cheese. It's a triple win. And the staff is super friendly & helpful."
Megan P - 8.2
"Widest selection of flavors I have ever seen, and huge sizes to make sure you get your fill. I love this place"
Cassie Roeloffs
Appears on 6 lists
A local’s guide: 48 hours in Florham Park, NJ
Created by Joe Locascio
18 items • 1 followerCreated by Freddie P
125 items • 1 follower