Nick's Pizza
(Now Closed)Pizzeria$$$$
Forest Hills
97 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Nick's Pizza is probably one of the best pizza I've ever had... Forget the price! Just order a small pizza pie with your fav toppings and don't forget a small calzone! They're delicious! 😋
Sharon PithawallaSeptember 9, 2016The junior's cheesecake was amazing! Also worth getting the pizza half red and half white. Both are amazing. And topped with chopped basil <3
Kimmie OhhDecember 2, 2019Awesome brick oven pizza. Get the half red / half white pizza & house salad. Get their sweet tea to drink. If you still have room for dessert, get Junior’s cheesecake or a cannoli.
Congrats, you’ve just encountered one of the best options for good NYC Pizza. Red and White Square Pie is a sleeper hit, not as thick as your typical. House Salad is a given…
MrjlpzJanuary 8, 2016Sausage and peppers pizza! Always get the house salad, which comes with an awesome dressing. Put the salad on your pizza, folder as a New Yorker should, put some of the salad dressing on it, and enjoy
Marci HyattSeptember 3, 2017Best brick oven pizza in NYC! Get a pie (meatball is my favorite) and a calzone. And after your meal get a cappuccino!! Staff is so friendly! I highly recommend this restaurant!
Christy FMay 9, 2014One of my favorite pizza places in NYC. Their house salad is the only restaurant salad that I actually crave and their pizza is divine. Cash only, but that's not an issue if you know in advance.
Had been coming here on and off since it opened. Now that I live nearby, I visit regularly. Sun dried tomato, sausage and onions are my favorite toppings. Stay for a homemade cannoli.
Half White, half red. A bit expensive as toppings add up but very delicious if you want to splurge a bit. Tiramisu gets a thumbs up. The space is cute with old school vibes
Astghik Martirosyan-ManukyanOctober 4, 2013Wonderful small place with really yummy pizza. I think I could eat their crust even with no topping. We enjoyed it a lot with my son. They also have a strange cappuccino machine :) Should try it :)
refinery29August 3, 2014Though it's only been open since the early '90s, this is some of the best pizza in all of New York City—yes, it ranks up there with Di Fara and Lombardi's. Read more
Adam KubanJune 10, 2015Make sure to get the house salad. It's delicious. As for pizza, it's all good—whatever calls to you should be fine.
Wendy WangApril 27, 2014Absolutely delicious cannoli! You got to try it. Plain no additional toppings pizza is amazing and the house salad just has this unique dressing that makes you devour it. Sweetened ice tea too~
Gabriel HerterOctober 10, 2022You can’t go wrong with anything here. My usual is either half pepperoni or sausage and peppers on a large pie.
Shawn ZaharewiczJune 10, 2018The ability to customize your pizza! It was amazing!! Very nice place to relax and have fun with friends!!
The new grandma is delicious. Thin square pie. Get it with pepperoni.
Aaron DancygierJuly 22, 2012Nick's Pizza got a health rating of A with 10 points. Download the nyc health ratings android app to view and share restaurants on FourSquare
Shira DubeyMay 25, 2011I recommend the white pizza...it is super tasty and delicious! Wash it down with a reasonably priced beer. Pure joy! Watch out, you might find yourself inhaling your own large pie...
Broccoli rabe and garlic, bad for a first date, good for your taste buds! There's a wait on the weekends.
Tom FortierSeptember 12, 2011Get the meatball pizza - it's like having awesome little slices of meatloaf on your pizza, without making the pizza soggy. Still crisp & delicious. Best pizza in Forest Hills!
Serious EatsMarch 26, 2014The best pizza in Forest Hills, thin crust and smoky with quality mozzarella.
Andreas GebhardDecember 30, 2018Everything, really. You can’t go wrong with either of their pizza options.
Pizza is great, not too heavy, house salad is amazing. Very friendly staff.
Get the white pie with broccoli rabe, sausage, garlic, ricotta and mozzarella. Best pizza ever.
Skip the salad and share a large pie. Be sure to ask for "light on the sauce" so you can actually taste the wonderful cheese and toppings.
Gajtana SimonovskaSeptember 12, 2015Excellent fresh, thin pizza. Great table service too. Highly recommended.
So good. Hot-Cherry Peppers are a good option if you can handle spicy.
Any pizza you get will be delicious. Also get the house salad, there is something just so good about it.
Alessandro de GuzmanOctober 9, 2014Best pizza on Austin street in Forest Hills. Fresh garlic on everything. No slices!- Red or white, Nick's makes an amazing custom pizza to order. Their crust is also very good
Dare I say... best pie in NY? Best in Queens for sure.
Delicious, fresh ingredients. A great place for a date night.
BravoJanuary 26, 2010This small restaurant quickly became a top favorite for locals. Order the Cheese pizza and a Caesar salad to share. Yum! -Alex Eusebio, Top Chef
dada DukesApril 3, 2012The waiters here seem like they are high as a kite! Hello share the wealth my brothers and sisters lol. Excellent place for good pizzas
Christina ArfstenJanuary 27, 2012Awesome pizza. Closer to real Italian pizza than most others I've had in New York City.
Tony BritaAugust 7, 2011The pizza is fantastic but definitely try the cannoli for dessert. It is light and scrumptious.
160 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Nick’s Pizza Forest Hills has been serving up thin crust pizzas & calzones for over 20 years. Melty mozzarella and fresh ingredients in Forest Hills, NY.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 4:00 PM–8:00 PM
- Fri
- 3:00 PM–9:00 PM
- Sat
- Noon–9:00 PM
- Sun
- Noon–8:00 PM
(718) 263-1126
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Outdoor Seating
No
Music
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Beer
See More
Places people like to go after Nick's Pizza
- 9.0
"Kitchen sink cookies and black forest cupcakes are amazing!!"
Heather Emanuele - 8.9
"Love the coffee chip ice cream! Super creamy. Get the orange freeze too if your a dreamicle lover"
Susan Liang - 9.1
"Beautiful, mid-size outdoor music venue. They book great acts and the shows are well organized and fun to attend."
Alex Still
Appears on 218 lists
Created by D
161 items • 213 followers
Created by Nora Gomez
38 items • 132 followers
Created by Richard Torres
200 items • 121 followers