My Tomato Pie

My Tomato Pie

Italian Restaurant, Pizzeria, and Gluten-Free Restaurant$$$$
Amherst
Save
Share
My Tomato Pie
8.2/10
62
ratings
  • Stars
    Ranked #2 for Italian restaurants in Amherst
  • Tips
    Pumice T. M.
    "Can't go wrong with Pizza Bread for starters."(2 Tips)
    Andy S.
    "Calzones are great."(2 Tips)
    Collin M.
    "Try the pizza with Chicken Fingers and Hot Peppers!"(2 Tips)
    John D.
    "The Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad Sandwich is great."(2 Tips)
Tips and Reviews icon18 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • sandwiches
  • lively
  • healthy food
  • good for working
  • paninis
  • (15 more)
User icon
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Pumice T. M.
    Pumice T. MendolaAugust 7, 2011
    Can't go wrong with Pizza Bread for starters. Pasta Maria is great, as is the Chicken Finger Calzone.
  • John D.heart icon on user image
    John DavisMarch 31, 2021
    Been here 100+ times
    The Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad Sandwich is great.
  • Diane W.heart icon on user image
    Diane WonchJuly 31, 2016
    Pizza is always good here.
    Upvoted 3 weeks ago
  • Jillian R.
    Jillian ReadingSeptember 16, 2012
    Turkey focaccia w cranberry mayo delicious. Spaghetti and meatballs bland.
  • Jim M.heart icon on user image
    Jim MoranApril 11, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Yum. The Mediterranean platter is delicious!
  • Anne Shirley
    Anne ShirleyJune 5, 2013
    The eggplant Parmesan panini is delicious!
  • Collin M.
    Collin M.April 17, 2012
    Try the pizza with Chicken Fingers and Hot Peppers! It's amazing.
  • Biz T.
    Biz TraveldudeOctober 31, 2014
    Tomato pies are like pizza, I guess
  • Max L.
    Max LeClair 😜🎭August 14, 2012
    Has great vegetarian options
  • Ashlee A.
    Ashlee AmoiaOctober 3, 2010
    the gluten-free pizza is awesome!! mmm I want some right nowwww:)
  • Sarah J.
    Sarah JaneDecember 2, 2010
    Try the Carissa pizza with sour cream. Yum!
  • JP M.
    JP MooreMarch 16, 2013
    Good stuff!
  • Anthony S.
    Anthony ScioliJuly 18, 2010
    Been here 25+ times
    Order the Strawberry and Goat Cheese Salad
  • Andy S.
    Andy StapleJanuary 15, 2011
    Calzones are great.
  • Josh
    JoshJune 3, 2010
    Steak and Rosenary pita is awesome!
  • Anthony S.
    Anthony ScioliJuly 19, 2010
    Been here 25+ times
    Have My Tomato Pie cater your next event. Read more
  • Karl K.
    Karl KozlowskiJuly 8, 2010
    Have the Pizza Bread...Mmmmm
  • Alex H.
    Alex HaumesserMay 6, 2010
    Great food!
Photos23 Photos

Related Searches

  • my tomato pie amherst •
  • my tomato pie amherst photos •
  • my tomato pie amherst location •
  • my tomato pie amherst address •
  • my tomato pie amherst •
  • my tomato pie amherst •
  • my tomato pie inc. amherst •
  • my tomato pie, inc. amherst •
  • my tomatoe pie amherst •

Foursquare © 2025  Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA

Compass icon
My Tomato Pie
3035 Niagara Falls Blvd (at E Robinson Rd)
Amherst, NY 14228
United States
Get directions
Information icon
Locally owned and operated, Our menu includes homemade soups, gourmet pizzas, calzones, pastas, and sandwiches.
Clock icon
Closed until 11:00 AM (Show more)
  • Mon–Wed
    • 11:00 AM–9:00 PM
  • Thu–Sat
    • 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
  • Sun
    • Noon–8:00 PM
Phone icon
(716) 838-0969
World Wide Web icon
Facebook icon
mytomatopie
Twitter icon
@mytomatopie
Instagram icon
@mytomatopie
Venue icon
Order from Grubhub
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner, Dessert
See More

You might also like

Places people like to go after My Tomato Pie

Appears on 7 lists

See all
United States » New York » Erie County » Amherst »