See all
81 photos

My Little Pizzeria

Pizzeria$$$$

Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn

Save

My Little Pizzeria

8.4^/10

163

ratings

Ranked #5 for Sicilian in Brooklyn
"Best pizza in Brooklyn Heights."(2 Tips)
"Fresh mozzarella Sicilian and Supreme slices are the best."(2 Tips)
"White pizza and garlic knots FTW!"(2 Tips)
"Best for delivery"(2 Tips)

49 Tips and reviews

Filter:

pizza
supreme slices
delivery
casual
gardens
great value
homemade gelato
good for a quick meal
good for a late night
vodka
Sicilian
fresh mozzarella
basil
neighborhood
garlic knots
local spots
city
lunch
tomatoes
lines
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Sandra RubinchikSeptember 29, 2014
Been here 5+ times
If aliens invaded the planet & we only had one chance to show them that our human race was capable of wonderful things & deserved to be spared from total annihilation, we would feed them this pizza.
Valerie SecklerAugust 26, 2011
A superior slice is lifted by flavorful olive oil and fresh basil leaves. Don't miss My Little Pizzeria if you are in or around Brooklyn Heights or downtown Brooklyn.
Cameron WDecember 31, 2017
A solid NYC slice. This place reminds me of the many great pizza places I used to go to when leaving in the city. Now I can come back here over the holidays for some NYC comfort food.
Jenn AllenOctober 1, 2015
Cozy authentic pizzeria. Fresh pizza and slices. Tasty. Absolutely delish and not too pricey either. Their fruit punch is good too.
Adam LangdonFebruary 19, 2017
Been going here for almost 20 years (started very young). It's so solid. Nice plain pie. Love it!
Jonathan OatisJuly 24, 2021
Been here 10+ times
Great basic pizza, with a garden courtyard. Get the fresh mozzarella slice.
Mario RojasApril 27, 2011
The Mafia somehow didn't prevent this place from using real cheese because it is amazing. My Little, going strong now since I discovered it in 2005. I will always remember this place.
Kate HableAugust 19, 2011
Pesto pizza and spinach rolls are sick. They give you all the cheese you want (unlike spot on Court that gives zero). Friendly. Authentic.
Erika PerziJuly 11, 2016
Good Sicilian slices, like the fresh mozzarella option with their sauce - tasty.
Kevin SkobacDecember 20, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Our favorite local spot for a classic New York slice
Moo JuMarch 24, 2012
Fresh mozzarella Sicilian and Supreme slices are the best. Just ask to heat the Sicilian a little longer as they lose heat quickly.
Cassel KrollAugust 22, 2014
Been here 10+ times
These guys may make the best regular slice in the city.
Matt DorvilleAugust 10, 2014
They have basil, grab some and crushed red peppers to make your slice even better
Skyler RichardSeptember 9, 2013
Outside seating towards back. Also they leave fresh spinach for you to add onto your pizza without any extra charge
Gina BiancoAugust 13, 2012
Get the Sicilian fresh mozzarella and tomatoes with basil on the top... Delicious.
HashtagNYUAugust 29, 2014
It’s worth the wait! Plus it’s only minutes from NYU's engineering school. Read more
Nate TMay 27, 2014
Shhh... There's a courtyard out back. Perfect for nice days.
Rich KelleyApril 2, 2013
Been here 50+ times
It saddens me to report that the quality of pizza has declined considerably under the new management and I now much prefer Pronto a few blocks south.
John ΤσεντζεληςJuly 15, 2015
Definitely have to have their old fashioned slice!
Rick SAugust 6, 2018
Food is OK...not the best pizza.
Jason LeibowitzSeptember 8, 2012
Been here 5+ times
One of the best pizza places in New York, not even Brooklyn!
John WalshMarch 8, 2012
Best pie I've ever eaten, wish they had this down in south jersey.
Calvin LammersMay 20, 2017
Not a great pizza place. Lack of options in the area make this a go to pizza spot in the neighborhood
Cameron WJanuary 4, 2015
This place provides a solid NYC slice.
TAZ JamesAugust 18, 2011
Been here 10+ times
Best pizza around the line maybe long from 12-4 but the line moves fast
James G.August 1, 2012
Treat yourself to a milkshake. They're awesome!
flyflyaway ...November 15, 2014
Round pizza for two? Omg....
Ken AndersenJune 13, 2010
Great homemade Gelato - and only $1 a scoop. It's in the back past the pizza counter.
Christina ChinDecember 2, 2017
Easy slice in the neighborhood, nothing special
Leap Of Faith SkateboardingJune 18, 2012
Definitely the best pizza in Brooklyn!
Observer4169December 20, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Best general "neighborhood pie" around. Can't go wrong.
Ciaran O.October 12, 2012
Arguably the best pizza in Brooklyn
Patti P. RiceMarch 19, 2016
Perfect NY pizza no yuppie bullshit
Kate KMay 9, 2010
Been here 5+ times
What this place lacks in ambiance it makes up in taste. Hands down best slice in BoCoCa. (Er, did I just say BoCoCa?)
Rhea GalsimApril 19, 2013
You need more than one slice.
samantha trinajsticOctober 2, 2011
The pene a la vodka is amazing !!
Fil BSeptember 15, 2011
Good local pizza, but "we don't do hawaiian" is a touch of the WTF
Kenji SummersJuly 25, 2010
The cheese slice is one of the best in Brooklyn.
Cassel KrollDecember 4, 2011
Been here 10+ times
Great place to grab a slice and go
Spif FaeJuly 19, 2010
Been here 25+ times
Order a supreme slice. You won't regret it.
ErinNovember 7, 2011
White pizza and garlic knots FTW!
Alain RMarch 22, 2011
V and R pizza on court street in Carroll Gardens is the best pizza shop in the area and for thoses of you who said this place is the beat are retarded u obviously have never had a real Brooklyn slice
Jamily GrayJuly 4, 2011
Feels like you are the heart of Brooklyn
Todd FlorioMarch 10, 2010
Go by and try a pie as @funwithiago reco'd on twitter. Read more
Patrick SelveyOctober 3, 2011
Been here 10+ times
Great White Pizza
ShahSeptember 20, 2014
Best pizza in Brooklyn Heights and they deliver, though you might not be able to fit a large pizza in your apartment.
John SNovember 28, 2009
Best for delivery
Loren BFebruary 11, 2010
ate a broccoli roll
Rich KelleyJanuary 16, 2010
Been here 50+ times
Best pizza in Brooklyn Heights.

81 Photos

My Little Pizzeria

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after My Little Pizzeria

Appears on 61 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.