See all
27 photos

Montague Street Bagels

Bagel Shop, Coffee Shop, and Sandwich Spot$$$$

Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn

Save

7.1^/10

113

ratings

"The fat tony will change your life."(2 Tips)
"sausage egg n cheese sandwich on an everything bagel"(3 Tips)
"The sun-dried tomato cream cheese is amazing!"(7 Tips)
"All sandwiches & wraps r amazing"(2 Tips)

40 Tips and reviews

Filter:

bagels
fat tony
sandwiches
great value
breakfast food
bakeries
good for a late night
wraps
eggs
brunch food
cream cheese
tomatoes
town
lunch
neighborhood
well
(11 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Arthur DanskinJune 24, 2018
Great bagel and sandwich spot, huge selection of excellent cream cheese flavors and fresh bagels. Try the garlic and herb or chive. Eat your bagel on the promenade.
Mike MFebruary 13, 2013
Been here 25+ times
Best bagels in the area, and best prices I've found as well. Whole wheat wraps are great for lunch.
KVEDApril 30, 2021
Kind of surprised the rating is this low. The sausage egg n cheese sandwich on an everything bagel was perfect. Super underrated.
Daniel L.March 18, 2011
Been here 10+ times
The sun-dried tomato cream cheese is amazing! Grab a bag of bagels for the week and a small container of your favorite cream cheese.
New York HabitatOctober 21, 2011
Great bagels and bagel sandwiches at this small bakery in Brooklyn Heights. Just look for the big glowing red "Hot Bagels" sign out front.
Christian AdroverMarch 14, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Great place to stop by after a night out. All sandwiches & wraps r amazing
KVEDApril 30, 2021
Classic sausage egg n cheese on an everything bagel.
Anthony TonMarch 7, 2015
Tasty, fresh everything bagels. Disappointed that they aren't slathering the cream cheese like they used to
JennJuly 30, 2013
50% off coupon is legit. Paid 25¢ for breakfast. Can't beat that!
KEJanuary 4, 2018
VERY slow service. Bodega vibe. You order in the back (basement level) - not much light. They were out of almost all bagels by 12pm. Self-serve coffee. Not worth it, go to the bagel place on Court St.
Julian EhrhardtNovember 13, 2010
Great bagels, poor service. But they're kind of worth it. Walk your bagel down the street for a superb view of the Manhattan skyline.
Jhokania D.September 9, 2013
Menu is great! Cream cheese variety is good!!
Ani H.September 23, 2016
Try the cilantro cream cheese
xaxanFebruary 17, 2019
best in town. Try the Fat Tony.
Emily KolodnerApril 28, 2015
Been here 10+ times
If you like a toasted bagel, ask them to toast it twice. Otherwise it will just be warm.
Morgan CroneyAugust 18, 2015
Best bagels in the neighborhood.
MacOctober 1, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Try the Bagels!!!
Sergey SmirnovMay 13, 2017
Been here 10+ times
It used to be good... Something changed. Not so great bagels and service anymore :(
Lisa KrugerDecember 12, 2011
The BEST NY bagels I've ever had! :)
VICTOR GREENJanuary 11, 2012
Brooklyn's best bagel. Fluffy center and crisp crust.
Mark SmithSeptember 9, 2014
Terrific sundried tomato!
Billy HenehanMarch 9, 2011
Been here 10+ times
They hide their Grade Pending sign from the Health Department in the back behind the bagel counter instead of in the window where it belongs.
Ricardo SandyOctober 31, 2011
Been here 10+ times
Try the "Pope of Montague"...awesome!
Richard BlueDecember 1, 2013
Been here 5+ times
The fat tony will change your life.
Jerayne JohnsonMay 25, 2011
OMG did you hear the owner was on the NYPost on 5/18/11 on page 22 for trying to run over his Dad twice?What has come to our area?Animals
Billy HenehanOctober 1, 2010
Been here 10+ times
Pass by this place at night and smile at their often broken sign, which tends to say "HO BAG S" every now and then.
Stephanie CamejoMay 25, 2013
24hrs open ! Talk about food anytime
Jon GoodmanFebruary 7, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Best Loxspread in town!
Melissa FudorJune 15, 2013
Avoid at all costs unless its 5am and you need a 24 spot. Hallow out your bagel and please don't get the muffins.
Alex BondarenkoFebruary 12, 2012
Been here 5+ times
They upgraded to an 'A' sanitation rating!
Noelle CrumpJuly 6, 2012
Just got an entire egg shell in my bagel. Don't do it!!
Michael ConneryMarch 12, 2011
Been here 50+ times
The redesignnlooks nice but service has gone way down hill since they flipped owners and staff.
Jared BrodskyJuly 27, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Stop by on Thursday - July 29, 2010 and get a free 12oz coffee for Customer Appreciation Day!!!
GabeDecember 19, 2011
Been here 100+ times
Pauls way or the highway.
justmushJune 6, 2011
Been here 25+ times
Tofu Cream Cheese
Steve DolanOctober 29, 2010
Great bagels. Horrifying service. Not worth it.
Jude GeigerFebruary 18, 2012
Been here 50+ times
$4 for a cheese bagel?!?
GabeApril 2, 2011
Been here 100+ times
Paul's Way!
Anthony DeRicoAugust 14, 2010
Food is good but the service here is horrible - the ordering and paying process is chaos. Be ready to wait and fight for your food. Too bad :(
QbertplayaDecember 8, 2010
Been here 10+ times
Double check your food before you leave -- they often screw up orders.

27 Photos

Montague Street Bagels

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Montague Street Bagels

Appears on 34 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.