Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
I Scream!

I Scream!

Creator Avatar
Created by Mark Neurohr-Pierpaoli • Updated On: September 16, 2024

An ongoing life project to document the best soft-serve & hand dipped ice cream and custard stands.

Rich's Ice Cream is one of I Scream!.

1. Rich's Ice Cream

8.3
65 Route 37 E (at King Street), Toms River, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 5 tips and reviews
Curly's Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt is one of I Scream!.

2. Curly's Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt

9.3
30 State Rt 23 (Windbeam), Riverdale, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 31 tips and reviews
Surreal Creamery is one of I Scream!.

3. Surreal Creamery

8 Easton Ave, New Brunswick, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · No tips or reviews
Don & Berts Custard is one of I Scream!.

4. Don & Berts Custard

8.6
635 W Broad St, Paulsboro, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 5 tips and reviews
Terry's Ice Cream is one of I Scream!.

5. Terry's Ice Cream

19 Park Dr, Bridgeton, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · No tips or reviews

6. Sugar Shack

929 Fairview Lake Road, Stillwater, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · No tips or reviews
Cream King is one of I Scream!.

7. Cream King

7.9
Pennington, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 6 tips and reviews
Buck's Ice Cream & Espresso Bar is one of I Scream!.

8. Buck's Ice Cream & Espresso Bar

7.4
25 Bridge St (Kline's Court), Lambertville, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 11 tips and reviews
Mackey's Orchard is one of I Scream!.

9. Mackey's Orchard

8.2
284 County Road 519, Belvidere, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 5 tips and reviews
Thomas Sweet Ice Cream & Chocolate is one of I Scream!.

10. Thomas Sweet Ice Cream & Chocolate

29 Palmer Sq W, Princeton, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 19 tips and reviews
Evergreen Dairy Bar is one of I Scream!.

11. Evergreen Dairy Bar

8.2
1643 Route 70, Southampton Township, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 7 tips and reviews
Jersey Freeze is one of I Scream!.

12. Jersey Freeze

8.5
120 Manalapan Ave, Freehold, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 32 tips and reviews
White Dotte Dairy Bar & Grill is one of I Scream!.

13. White Dotte Dairy Bar & Grill

8.6
2345 Route 206 (at Rt 38), Southampton Township, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 23 tips and reviews
Margate Dairy Bar & Burger is one of I Scream!.

14. Margate Dairy Bar & Burger

8.5
9510 Ventnor Ave (Corner of Ventnor and Madison Avenues), Margate City, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 20 tips and reviews
Dover Dairy Maid is one of I Scream!.

15. Dover Dairy Maid

8.9
240 US Route 46 (Depew Ave), Dover, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 9 tips and reviews
Twin Cone is one of I Scream!.

16. Twin Cone

8.9
Bloomingburg, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · 10 tips and reviews
Gronsky's Milk House is one of I Scream!.

17. Gronsky's Milk House

8.8
125 W Main St, High Bridge, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 15 tips and reviews
Custard & Cakes Creamery is one of I Scream!.

18. Custard & Cakes Creamery

9.1
5461 Ridge Ave (at Righter St), Philadelphia, PA
Ice Cream Parlor · Manayunk · 24 tips and reviews
John's Water Ice is one of I Scream!.

19. John's Water Ice

9.0
701 Christian St (at 7th St), Philadelphia, PA
Dessert Shop · Bella Vista - Southwark · 39 tips and reviews
McGinty's Ice Cream is one of I Scream!.

20. McGinty's Ice Cream

7.4
225B Levittown Pkwy, Levittown, PA
Ice Cream Parlor · 4 tips and reviews
Ice Cream Shoppe is one of I Scream!.

21. Ice Cream Shoppe

8.2
43 3rd Ave (Mcaneny St), Neptune City, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 11 tips and reviews
Graeter's Ice Cream is one of I Scream!.

22. Graeter's Ice Cream

8.9
2704 Erie Ave, Cincinnati, OH
Ice Cream Parlor · Hyde Park · 26 tips and reviews

23. Pelican's Snoballs

101 Creek Rd, Mount Laurel, NJ
Dessert Shop · 1 tip
Curly's Ice Cream is one of I Scream!.

24. Curly's Ice Cream

8.0
220 W Route 130, Burlington, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 1 tip
The Custard Shack is one of I Scream!.

25. The Custard Shack

7.5
600-698 New Jersey 168, Blackwood, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 3 tips and reviews
Soda Jerk Diner & Dairy Bar is one of I Scream!.

26. Soda Jerk Diner & Dairy Bar

7.1
403 E Main St, Hummelstown, PA
Diner · 39 tips and reviews
Confectionately Yours is one of I Scream!.

27. Confectionately Yours

8.7
3185 NJ 27, Franklin Park, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 34 tips and reviews
Royale Crown Custard is one of I Scream!.

28. Royale Crown Custard

8.5
1051 South White Horse Pike, Hammonton, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 20 tips and reviews
Sundaes The Ice Cream Place is one of I Scream!.

29. Sundaes The Ice Cream Place

8.8
3217 Route 88 (Bridge Ave.), Point Pleasant Boro, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 27 tips and reviews
Handel's Ice Cream of Royersford is one of I Scream!.

30. Handel's Ice Cream of Royersford

627 Main St, Royersford, PA
Ice Cream Parlor · 2 tips and reviews
Dairy Fresh Ice Cream is one of I Scream!.

31. Dairy Fresh Ice Cream

8.2
430 N Black Horse Pike, Williamstown, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 8 tips and reviews
Cherry On Top is one of I Scream!.

32. Cherry On Top

26 South Main Street, Mullica Hill, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 1 tip
Fine Fellows Creamery is one of I Scream!.

33. Fine Fellows Creamery

8.6
313 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 5 tips and reviews
Holsten's is one of I Scream!.

34. Holsten's

8.8
1063 Broad St (at Watchung Ave), Bloomfield, NJ
Burger Joint · 48 tips and reviews
Bischoff's is one of I Scream!.

35. Bischoff's

468 Cedar Ln, Teaneck, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 23 tips and reviews
Hoffman's Ice Cream is one of I Scream!.

36. Hoffman's Ice Cream

9.1
800 Richmond Ave, Point Pleasant Beach, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 54 tips and reviews
Skipper Dipper is one of I Scream!.

37. Skipper Dipper

9.0
9305 Long Beach Blvd (at 94th St), Long Beach Township, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 37 tips and reviews
Owowcow Creamery is one of I Scream!.

38. Owowcow Creamery

9.0
237 N Union St, Lambertville, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 17 tips and reviews
Cliff's Homemade Ice Cream is one of I Scream!.

39. Cliff's Homemade Ice Cream

9.5
1475 US Highway 46, Ledgewood, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 58 tips and reviews
TK's Ice Cream is one of I Scream!.

40. TK's Ice Cream

9.2
331 Route 539, Cream Ridge, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 13 tips and reviews
Peace Pie is one of I Scream!.

41. Peace Pie

8.6
326 Carpenter Ln, Cape May, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 5 tips and reviews
JoJo's Ice Cream is one of I Scream!.

42. JoJo's Ice Cream

7.6
8801 New Falls Rd, Levittown, PA
Dessert Shop · 7 tips and reviews
Eddie's Sweet Shop is one of I Scream!.

43. Eddie's Sweet Shop

8.7
10529 Metropolitan Ave (at 72nd Rd), Forest Hills, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · 109 tips and reviews
Denville Dairy is one of I Scream!.

44. Denville Dairy

9.0
34A Broadway, Denville, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 44 tips and reviews
Lighthouse Italian Ice is one of I Scream!.

45. Lighthouse Italian Ice

8.7
64 Bridge Ave, Red Bank, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 7 tips and reviews
The Lighthouse Strollo's Homemade Italian Ice is one of I Scream!.

46. The Lighthouse Strollo's Homemade Italian Ice

8.1
64 Bridge Ave, Red Bank, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 1 tip
Ice Cream on 9 is one of I Scream!.

47. Ice Cream on 9

8.2
2300 U.S. 9, Howell, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 10 tips and reviews
The Chill Factor is one of I Scream!.

48. The Chill Factor

7.3
5807 Bensalem Blvd, Bensalem, PA
Ice Cream Parlor · 5 tips and reviews
Gibbys Ice Cream is one of I Scream!.

49. Gibbys Ice Cream

8.1
3301-4099 Veteran Hwy, Levittown, PA
Ice Cream Parlor · Plumbridge · 5 tips and reviews
Twin Kiss is one of I Scream!.

50. Twin Kiss

8.0
25 S Delsea Dr, Clayton, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 8 tips and reviews
Twistee Treat is one of I Scream!.

51. Twistee Treat

7.1
3401 Longshore Ave (Frankford & Longshore), Philadelphia, PA
Ice Cream Parlor · Mayfair · 3 tips and reviews
Polar Bear Ice Cream is one of I Scream!.

52. Polar Bear Ice Cream

8.7
130 State Route 36 E, North Middletown, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 14 tips and reviews
The Ice Cream Boutique is one of I Scream!.

53. The Ice Cream Boutique

Bordentown, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · No tips or reviews
Ummm Ice Cream Parlor is one of I Scream!.

54. Ummm Ice Cream Parlor

6.3
236 High St (at W. Union St), Burlington, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 7 tips and reviews
Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburgers is one of I Scream!.

55. Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburgers

6.9
5051 Edgmont Ave, Brookhaven, PA
Burger Joint · No tips or reviews
Kurver Kreme is one of I Scream!.

56. Kurver Kreme

8.1
1349 Central Ave, Albany, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · 13 tips and reviews
Drip N Scoop is one of I Scream!.

57. Drip N Scoop

8.8
960 Asbury Ave, Ocean City, NJ
Coffee Shop · 6 tips and reviews
Yellow Brick Road Ice Cream Carousel is one of I Scream!.

58. Yellow Brick Road Ice Cream Carousel

8.7
1857 Hooper Avenue, Toms River, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 6 tips and reviews
Jake's Cree-Mee Freeze Too is one of I Scream!.

59. Jake's Cree-Mee Freeze Too

7.2
337 State Route 33, Manalapan, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 10 tips and reviews
Olivia's Ice Cream is one of I Scream!.

60. Olivia's Ice Cream

619 State Route 33, Millstone Township, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 1 tip
Scoopy Lou's is one of I Scream!.

61. Scoopy Lou's

16 S White Horse Pike, Lindenwold, NJ
Dessert Shop · No tips or reviews
The Meadows Frozen Custard is one of I Scream!.

62. The Meadows Frozen Custard

4037 Route 130, Delran Township, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 10 tips and reviews
Dari Delite is one of I Scream!.

63. Dari Delite

583 Hamilton St (at Dunham Ave), Somerset, NJ
Dessert Shop · No tips or reviews
Dairy Delight is one of I Scream!.

64. Dairy Delight

6000 New Jersey Ave, Wildwood Crest, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 2 tips and reviews
Duffer's is one of I Scream!.

65. Duffer's

8.4
5210 Pacific Ave (at E. Hildreth Ave.), Wildwood, NJ
Mini Golf Course · 46 tips and reviews
Red Eagle Produce is one of I Scream!.

66. Red Eagle Produce

Blackwood Ter, NJ
American Restaurant · 1 tip
Curly Creme Ice Cream is one of I Scream!.

67. Curly Creme Ice Cream

8.5
244 S River St, Plains, PA
Ice Cream Parlor · 16 tips and reviews
Sundaes is one of I Scream!.

68. Sundaes

9.3
185 N Route 73 (btwn Prospect & Fairview), Berlin, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 28 tips and reviews