Important Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.Mimi's Pizza Kitchen
(Now Closed)Pizzeria$$$$
Upper East Side, New York
The experts at The Corcoran Group and Serious Eats recommend this place
49 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
The Corcoran GroupApril 30, 2012There’s something seriously special about this pizzeria – the crispy crust and sweet and tangy sauce are pure perfection – try the Marengo, White Pizza or the Classic Margherita.
- AJ JacobsMay 25, 2015I grew up eating Mimi’s pizza with my family. To me, it’s the perfect amount of salt and grease and tomato sauce.
Darren MarksOctober 5, 2013I love this place. Best Italian. Don't miss the potato croquet sand the shrimp fra diavalo
DJ_DoobieJune 10, 2012I had 3 slices; 1 white slice, 1 fresh mozzarella & 1 regular slice.....the regular slice was the best of the three. Pretty good regular slice.....wasn't impressed by the rest.
Michelle SchlesingerNovember 18, 2012Hubbie loves it, but they put a teaspoon of cheese and sauce onto a thick piece of bread, fire it, then charge you $2.75 for it. Beef patties are $3 too--wtf?
Liz WrightJune 21, 2011Great slices -- always ask for a fresh slice out of the oven. If a pizza is coming out in a few minutes, it's worth the wait!
Heather LeighNovember 19, 2013If you go into the ladies' room, don't be surprised if the hand dryer turns on when you shut the door.
Yani ImanNovember 3, 2012Lasagna's nice & cheesy. Found it weird that they added $0.50 to my chicken Marsala though. Tip's included in check.- Best pizza in this area, even better if you take your pie over to Carlow East and watch the Sox game!
Sean FlemingOctober 1, 2014One slice of pepperoni, one regular slice, one small soda = $8. I would only go there if I was really hungry with no other place to go.
K. W.August 16, 2013just a couple of blocks away from The Met if you don't want museum food. decent pizza, but not the best in NYC.
Consistently scores a B on the DOH inspections, but so good I keep coming back. Best pizza in the 'hood
Danny OlivaJune 8, 2015Heard an interview with Seinfeld, he said he eats here, and Bobby Flay used to work here
William KerrMay 25, 2011Best pizza on UES. ordering delivery is usually not as good. Fuck the sox, go back to Boston.
My favorite slice of white pizza in the whole damn city!
Mimi smileJune 15, 2013Horrible service. Rushed me to order, eat, and pay bill. Owner added tip himself with 20%. Double charged my card! And won't reply to question with straight answer. Don't recommend it to anyone
- Mimi smileJune 15, 2013The food sucks! Pizza might be good, bc everyone seems to be ordering that...but it was too late for me to order.
60 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
(212) 861-3363
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Outdoor Seating
No
See More
You might also like
- 8.9
"One of the best pizzas in the village. Usually has a line, but it moves quickly."
Polina Weitz - 8.8
"The big le Matt burger was a crowd pleaser, and I absolutely adored the Caesar salad with real anchovies"
Natalie LeMoss - 8.8
"Excellent pizzas, excellent view, and the crispy mashed potatoes with truffle sauce... OMG."
Cécile
Places people like to go after Mimi's Pizza Kitchen
- 9.5
"Incredible museum. I could spend days in there. Loved the medieval room but it was all great."
hello_emily - 6.2
"Clean, classic rock playing, dive bar, with friendly bartenders and a decent beer selection."
Lisa L - 9.7
"Love my park. I've been taking 6 mile walks around Central Park 3 times a week. Sheep's Meadow is a great place to hang out for a picnic. Tavern on the Green is an awesome spot to grab a drink."
Leigh Ann
Appears on 40 lists
Best Thing I Ever Ate Year-Long Challenge
Created by Anna Lindow
100 items • 14 followers
Created by Scott Heinze
200 items • 13 followers