Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop
Ice Cream Parlor and Bakery$$$$
Hamilton Park, Jersey City
"earl grey fudge and the midnight cocoa"(4 Tips)
"lemon olive oil ice cream with a side of chocolate chip cookie..."(3 Tips)
"Stumptown and malt chip flavors are out of control good."(2 Tips)
"Stumptown coffee ice cream is delish!!!"(3 Tips)
41 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- ice cream
- earl grey fudge
- cookies
- casual
- great value
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Zara KhanAugust 19, 2018Delicious! Loved the salted caramel, earl grey fudge and the midnight cocoa with activated charcoal. Tiny shop but terrific ice cream. This place should be one of NYC’s best ice cream shops!
Lori LuoAugust 23, 2014A small shop serving creative ice cream flavors such as S'Mores and Earl Grey Fudge, Milk Sugar Love is sure to be a JC favorite. One scoop is a little pricey at $3.50, but it's worth the splurge.
Small servings (do at least 2 scoops!), but very rich and creamy. The Honey Lavender and Ginger Creamsicle combo is refreshing and then the ginger kicks in to warm up your throat. Give it a try!
Michelle LoraAugust 31, 2015Vegans rejoice!!! You had me at dairy-free cookie butter. Buy the pint. Seriously. Do it and thank me later. Ask if you don't see it in the fridge.
Eat here if you want the best tasting stuff ever. It's like eating frozen unicorn tears while riding atop Robocop's broad robot shoulders. Yeah... THAT good.
Kae MckinniJanuary 6, 2022The chocolate chip ice cream sandwich is delicious! Try it with their unique ice cream flavors.
Autumn ChoiJuly 5, 2022Unique flavors, their flagship lemon olive is oh so good. The texture is not as thick as some other places like Jeni’s. Owner is rude/shitty but good ice cream I guess
Sean BonusAugust 23, 2014The inside of the actual location smells wonderful. It's the first thing I noticed. Also, you have to get the snicker doodle cookie with your scoop of ice cream.
Preeti MackerMay 25, 2015Cute place with evolved favors like PB cherry. Ingredients are sourced locally and organic. Wish they would be a tad generous with their serving esp for a $3.5 per scoop, left me wanting for more.- MichelleJuly 19, 2014Best ice cream you can get. Kind people, great place! Always innovating new flavors! Stumptown and malt chip flavors are out of control good.
Dina RughaniMarch 31, 2015Honey lavender is my favorite flavor. The icecream sandwiches are great as well. My favorite icecream shop in jersey city
DanielleDecember 22, 2014Delicious ice cream and baked goods. You can't go wrong with any of the flavors. Definitely get a blondie while you're there!
What's Good HereSeptember 27, 2014Morning Bacon, coffee ice cream with bacon. Unfortunately, there's not much bacon or bacon flavor nor is there a richness in the coffee ice cream.
Amy RoweJune 23, 2014Malt chip is my favorite flavor. Snickerdoodle is great, too. This organic ice cream shop is a nice addition to Hamilton Park.
Jacqueline MosqueraSeptember 28, 2015The lemon olive oil ice cream is like nothing you'd ever dream about! Be daring & try it! U can't taste the olive oil. It just makes the ice cream creamier.- Adrienne PetrinoJune 23, 2014Get the lemon olive oil ice cream with a side of chocolate chip cookie... Or go all in and get an ice cream sammie!
Alaa BelhadjAugust 19, 2015Early grey ice cream sundae with cake bits and whipped cream was delicious!
The owner is super friendly. Get a milkshake. You won't regret it.
Lemon olive oil ice cream was no joke, so incredibly good!
Delicious, but be advised that "one scoop" is really just "one scoop"!
BrkgnyDecember 3, 2014Dondurmalar güzel, çikolatalı ve tarçınlı donut lı olan iyi, zencefilli cookie iyi değil
140 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop
19 McWilliams Pl (at 9th St)
Jersey City, NJ 07302
United States
Jersey City, NJ 07302
United States
Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop is churning delightfully delicious ice cream, cakes and baked goods using grass-fed, organic dairy and local NJ produce.
Closed until 11:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–9:00 PM
(201) 984-0530
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Parking
Street
Food & Drink
Menus
Dessert
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop
- 9.2
"This is a nice neighborhood park. Dog runs, tot lots, playground, open grass, tennis courts, and basketball courts. Can't go wrong here."
R - 7.7
"Love this market. Prices are very reasonable for the high quality natural healthy brands they carry. Store is always clean and well stocked."
Debra Tucker
- 6.6
"Great mall! So many stores, and a lovely skylight. Easy access via the PATH."
Vicky Kennedy
