Delicious! Loved the salted caramel, earl grey fudge and the midnight cocoa with activated charcoal. Tiny shop but terrific ice cream. This place should be one of NYC’s best ice cream shops!
A small shop serving creative ice cream flavors such as S'Mores and Earl Grey Fudge, Milk Sugar Love is sure to be a JC favorite. One scoop is a little pricey at $3.50, but it's worth the splurge.
Small servings (do at least 2 scoops!), but very rich and creamy. The Honey Lavender and GingerCreamsicle combo is refreshing and then the ginger kicks in to warm up your throat. Give it a try!
Eat here if you want the best tasting stuff ever. It's like eating frozen unicorn tears while riding atop Robocop's broad robot shoulders. Yeah... THAT good.
Unique flavors, their flagship lemonolive is oh so good. The texture is not as thick as some other places like Jeni’s. Owner is rude/shitty but good ice cream I guess
The inside of the actual location smells wonderful. It's the first thing I noticed. Also, you have to get the snicker doodlecookie with your scoop of ice cream.
Cute place with evolved favors like PB cherry. Ingredients are sourced locally and organic. Wish they would be a tad generous with their serving esp for a $3.5 per scoop, left me wanting for more.
The lemon olive oil ice cream is like nothing you'd ever dream about! Be daring & try it! U can't taste the olive oil. It just makes the ice cream creamier.
Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop is churning delightfully delicious ice cream, cakes and baked goods using grass-fed, organic dairy and local NJ produce.