Milk Burger
(Now Closed)Burger Joint and Sandwich Spot$$$$
East Harlem, New York
42 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
NearSay NYCJuly 22, 2011One of our favorite places to stop in Spanish Harlem, Milk Burger kicks it back old school shoestring style with classic fires and flavorful cheese sauce.Don't forget to try their rich milkshakes!
Tash ConcepcionAugust 17, 2014I haven't actually eaten in the restaurant but delivery is quite fast. A solid burger that hits the spot...since Shake Shack doesn't deliver. And quite a bargain too.
Jeff CaseyNovember 18, 2014I was shocked to learn that Milk Burger recently decided to only open for dinner. For a place that can seat fewer than my apartment, I am confused by the change. Lucky for me, Joy Burger is closer.
Dennis OwensAugust 18, 2014I had a double burger and fries. It was fresh and delicious. It's also conveniently located at the express bus stop.
The guac burger is great with the jalepeño sauce but you have to try the classic Milk Burger with bacon and a side of sweet potato fries (the Cajun salt it's awesome).
Harlem AmbassadorFebruary 2, 2013You may not be accustomed to a $14 burger tab, (and that's before the fries) but then again...Shake Shack would be a lot more pricey. You will work up quite an appetite trying to find it. Worth the $$
Barkima LaneMay 8, 2014The burger was smaller than I expected. It was ok. The cheese fries were good, but needed salt & they put 0 packs in my bag😞. The fresh squeeze lemonade was refreshing. Overall I give them a 7.
Jay CintronFebruary 23, 2013The "El Barrio Burger" Cheese Fries and a Half/Half that was my winning combination! Def would come back.
Josiah David ChapmanJune 22, 2015Fantastic burgers. Although they are a little small and the cook isn't very generous with toppings. Maybe I'll get two next time.
Milk burger is awesome. It comes with "milk sauce" which is a mustard based sauce but it complements the burger very well.
Now serving both crinkle cut (get these!) and straight fries. Request your preference when you order.
Ask for The El Barrio Burger, on the secret menu, sooo good and you gotta try the sweet potato fries, really good- I can't stop coming here for the Guac burger. It's divine.
Ashley WashingtonAugust 22, 2013Gaucamole burger, Hawaiian burger.. yum yum.. vhivken burger yum.. shakes.. omg yum!!! Oreo Shake!!!!
Jessie CatanaOctober 3, 2015Hit or miss unfortunately. When it's good, it's really good. Today tho, the turkey burger supposed to be "cooked to perfection" was absolutely not. Bummer. Regular burger was burnt to a crisp. Yuck :/
Get the milk burger and fries, with your choice of crinkle cut or shoestring
New location- better vibe than last- get the guacamole burger !
54 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Milk Burger offers only Fresh and Never Frozen High Quality Beef. The freshness in our burgers are unlike any burgers you have ever tasted.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Tue–Thu
- 5:00 PM–11:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
- Sun
- Noon–10:00 PM
(212) 360-1988
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & MasterCard)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Parking
Street
Restroom
Yes
See More
You might also like
- 9.0
"Need I say more?! Absolutely love shake shack! Always there for me rain or shine. Provides the ultimate comfort, I'm emotionally attached to this place. Just keep in mind you DO have to sit outside"
ℳ𝒶𝓎♍ - 8.5
"Awesome food. Turkey Burger, Ahi burger heaven🎉"
David Rosales - 8.3
"Get the bistro burger! This place lives up to the hype! Delicious!"
Josh Warfield
Appears on 68 lists
Priceless New York - Best Burger Bites
Created by MasterCard
17 items • 35 followersCreated by Durinda Underwood
16 items • 18 followers
Created by Hendy Ongkodjojo
177 items • 25 followers