Mama Lisa Restaurant
Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant$$$$
Mastic
"Try the grandmas pie!! Mama Lisa's make the best pizza."(8 Tips)
"Penne La Vodka with shrimp or chicken parmesan is the best!"(4 Tips)
"... with Angel hair pasta tonight for me & GF Chicken Marsala for my..."(3 Tips)
"Amazing food, great dinner specials."(7 Tips)
25 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- chicken parmigiana
- DJs
- good for dates
- good for groups
- good for working
- (5 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Ordered take out dinners last night and the takeouts dinners are just as good as the in restaurant dinners, plus the portions are huge enough for 3 people or 3 meals. Absolutely delicious 😋- Early dinner with my love.Chicken Parmigiana for me and Chicken Marsala for her. Great Gluten free menu, even the bread is and it’s good. So was the Chocolate Ice Cream 🍦
Can’t go wrong here! Everything is delicious and the owners and servers are fantastic! Excellent choice to host a gathering!- Food was great and atmosphere was nice..Service was a little slow but for a party of 6 they brought it all out together starting with Apps & Drinks, then entrees
- Chicken Marsala for her - Delicious and GF Chicken Parmigiana for me Delicious. Birthday dinner her. Love this restaurant
5/6/12(Joyous Communion Leanne) Congrats Nino & Mosè on your beautiful new location! We love it! We wish you the best in health and the best in business! Jèq&Denis- Kimberly C.October 1, 2013Amazing food, great dinner specials. The pizza is delicious, and the chicken francese was out of this world. Best italian place around!
- Great staff and great food, chicken parmigiana with Angel hair pasta tonight for me & GF Chicken Marsala for my love..🇮🇹🇮🇹
- Chicken parmigiana and GF Carbonara. Always delicious, love this restaurant 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
- We love this Restaurant..Great Gluten free menu and entree’s are just as delicious as regular entree’s
Shane GambaleJanuary 26, 2013For as crowded as this place always is, it's entirely over rated. The service is great food is okay but I've had way better pizza and pasta
- Penne La Vodka with shrimp or chicken parmesan is the best!
Ranae JamesJune 30, 2010Most pizza places have either great Pizza or great dinners, Mama Lisa has both.- Arlene GAugust 9, 2010Try the grandmas pie!! Mama Lisa's make the best pizza. The staff is very friendly.
Kyle SchmidtMay 10, 2016food not as good, staff changed and not attentive. Ill take my night out elsewhere.
27 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Mama Lisa Restaurant serves Mastic as the top spot for great Italian cuisine.
Closed until 11:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:00 AM–10:30 PM
(631) 395-4600
Features
Reservations
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Drinks
Cocktails
See More
