Little Pie Company
Pie Shop, Bakery, and Dessert Shop$$$$
Hell's Kitchen, New York
The folks at Food Network and Serious Eats like this place. Would you agree?
"get the sour cream apple walnut pie or banana coconut cream pie"(10 Tips)
"Get the SOUR CREAM APPLE WALNUT PIE!"(8 Tips)
"Their signature sour cream Apple is delicious."(7 Tips)
"Mississippi Mud Pie & German Chocolate Cupcakes"(7 Tips)
95 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pies
- cream apple
- cake
- casual
- family-friendly
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Justin OrdovezaJanuary 6, 2017The sour cream apple walnut pie is one of the best apple pies I've had. The apples are sliced thin so the pie is akin to a French tartine than the traditional apple pie.
Rod GrayMarch 10, 2015The sour cream apple walnut pie is so incredibly rich with he correct balance of acidic apples, sour cream, butter, walnuts and sugar. I've been so decadent as t have one by myself for dinner.
Wejdan ✨May 11, 2017I used to get my favorite pie of all time "the sour cream apple walnut pie" at j.g. melon all the time. Got the Mississippi mud today, it was awesome. Can't wait to try more pies!!
- The BEST PIES in NYC! Straight up good crust, amazing filling. No fancy dressed up hipster yada yadas. Just plain good old pie! Get the SOUR CREAM APPLE WALNUT PIE!
Cam_in_BrisJuly 15, 2023Peach pie was delicious! Modern, spotless store. Staff are also very friendly and helpful 🥧🥰- Rod GrayMarch 10, 2015Banana coconut cream pie. It is so light and fluffy. With a rich bottom layer of ripe bananas and custard topped with whipped cream and toasted coconut flakes mm mmm. Mmmmmm GOOD
Anne SOctober 25, 2015Loved the sour cream apple walnut pie. Don't have to get mini pie (which can easily be split bt 2 ppl); can get slice. They also ship to states on east coast. I'm from SC so will def be doing that!!
Alyssa B.December 7, 2021The sour cream apple pie tastes better than it looks! In terms of appearance, the classic apple pie looks more of a showstopper for an occasion like thanksgiving.
Food NetworkDecember 17, 2014While this bakery's reputation was built on the Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie, it's the "all-American" Mississippi Mud Pie that keeps chocolate cravings in check around the Big Apple and beyond. Read more- PaddyMarch 19, 2016This place smells so good and you can smell it from like 3 blocks away. Their signature sour cream Apple is delicious. Tried the pear apple crumble too; also delicious.
Amazing pies! Sour cream apple is their Signature! Love the 5 inch size, ready to snack and try a couple of flavors.- estherSeptember 3, 2014The sour cream apple pie is amazing. The apples thinly sliced rather than cut into pieces which is one of the reasons why it tastes so good.
Serious EatsApril 23, 2013Go for the signature sour cream apple pie, the coconut cream pie, or any of their fruity double-crusted pies
Rami IsmailJuly 15, 2018The sour cream apple pie was a recommendation I got, and I'm paying that recommendation forwards. It's really good.
CompassMay 15, 2014Find every kind of pie you could ever dream of at the pie shop on West 43rd Street. Try the Mississippi Mud, Key Lime or a small pie sampler.
Christina ChinDecember 23, 2019Apple pie is big and poofy style crust on top. Not too overly sweet, hit with family.
Nidhi KayNovember 24, 2018Great pumpkin pie and Mississippi mud pie, also appreciate how very organized they are during holidays
Tessa DomzalskiNovember 24, 2015I got the apple pie, key lime pie, and mud pie. Apple pie was bad. Key lime was okay, although the crust was very weak. Mud pie was the best, but more like chocolate cake than it was a mud pie.
Harumi UAugust 29, 2014Threeberry pie is the best in my opinion. Try to visit this place the day before Thanksgiving. It is a sight
Little Pie CompanyJanuary 8, 2015Many of our fresh seasonal pies are available for national shipping. Just visit our website... Read more
Alice EunjinNovember 25, 2015Good value pies (for takeout), but their signature sour cream apple cake only lasts a day- Brenden BeuJuly 17, 2016Sour cream walnut apple pie is the best! They also have a good chocolate cake.
Maureen KelleyJuly 17, 2014Order to stay and you will get steamed milk for your coffee and your pie served warm. Perfection.
Matt 🐹January 3, 2015Do it right! Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie and a scoop of vanilla ice cream. Ya! 💫
Kanchana SeneviratneMay 28, 2012Mississippi Mud Pie was my favorite. This was after trying the sour cream apple walnut and strawberry walnut.
- Stephanie CaraglianoJanuary 13, 2011Chocolate fiends: Mississippi Mud Pie & German Chocolate Cupcakes are where it's at. Sour Cream Apple Walnut (a la mode!) is not to be missed either.
Even though they are known for their pies, try the applesauce carrot cake and the red velvet cake!
Get the Apple Sauce Carrot Cake. OMG. BEST THING EVER. LIKE EVER.
Feisty RedheadApril 23, 2013Their apple pie is always a disappointment. It smells wonderful but doesn't have that tangy bite. If you like sweet apple pie with no bite, go for it. If you're like me, try something else.
The sour cream apple walnut pie is bananas. Well, its apples, but you know what I mean
Laura vanZandtFebruary 22, 2012The Mississippi Mud Pie was so decadent, especially since they warmed it up for us since we ate there!
ReggieMay 25, 2013My trainer is going to kick my a$$. This food is so damn good. Lovin the banana coconut cream pie
Vidya IAugust 2, 2011Try the sour cream and apple pie! Their Old Fashioned Chocolate Cake is really good too!
225 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Dessert made from scratch, using only fresh, honest, pure ingredients mixed together by hand in a thoughtful way—never any artificial preservatives.
Open until 8:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Fri
- 8:00 AM–8:00 PM
- Sat
- 10:00 AM–8:00 PM
- Sun
- 10:00 AM–6:00 PM
(212) 736-4780
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Visa & American Express)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Dessert
See More
You might also like
- 8.8
"While the Cronut gets all the press don't miss out on the fresh made to order Madeleine or the DKA both are fantastic."
Eric Abergel - 8.6
"Try the almond brioche toast!!! Awesome!!!"
Gustavo Mello - 8.9
"I have loved every cookie I've tried. Chocolate Diablo, Fluffernutter, and Lemon Poppyseed especially rock!"
April Wall-Parker
Places people like to go after Little Pie Company
- 5.0
"Full grocery, bakery, hot ready to eat, sushi. Prices are a bit high, but the hours are very convenient."
John A - 7.3
"Can't go wrong with the homemade phyllo pastries soaked in nuts and honey! Coffee is surprisingly cheap and good."
Amy 🍦
- 8.4
"Always my favourite place to be when I am in NY. Love the dynamic."
Atika Al-Bimani
Appears on 483 lists
12 Perfect Places for Pie in NYC
Created by Foursquare Swarm
12 items • 123 followers
Created by Foursquare Swarm
50 items • 221 followers
Created by Allison D.
199 items • 88 followers
