Grocery Store · East Village · 32 tips and reviews
Serious Eats: This small shop near Curry Row is packed with dried spices and grains, fresh herbs, and plenty of beer. A neighborhood destination for Indian and south Asian pantry goods.
Herbs and Spices Store · Rose Hill · 133 tips and reviews
Serious Eats: If you're looking for obscure spices and specialty ingredients from India, the Middle East, Asia, and beyond, Kalustyan's probably has it.
187 Atlantic Ave (btwn Clinton & Court St), Brooklyn, NY
Gourmet Store · Brooklyn Heights · 96 tips and reviews
Serious Eats: Destination Middle Eastern market for spices, olives, coffee, yogurt, cheese, prepared foods, and more. Be prepared to get lost in the aisles; bring a big shopping bag.
Gourmet Store · Little Italy · 74 tips and reviews
Serious Eats: 100-year-old Italian specialty market with incredible mozzarella and fresh porchetta. Expect long waits, but they're worth it for Louie's selection of imported and deli products.
Lily: NYMag 2014 Food & Drink Issue: "Every one of its departments, from produce to meat, is better than it needs to be. And the ancillary stuff—dairy and pantry items, fresh pastas and dried—is top-notch."
179 E Houston St (btwn Allen & Orchard St), New York, NY
Gourmet Store · Lower East Side · 419 tips and reviews
Serious Eats: Jewish appetizing store that's one of the last of its kind. Your go-to source for every kind of smoked and cured fish, caviar, whitefish salad, and more.
Serious Eats: This butcher shop sells a wide variety of humanely raised meats sourced from local farms. A selection of cold sandwiches and hot dishes is available for lunch.
Lily: NYMag 2014 Food & Drink Issue: "Knowledgeable meat cutters man the counter to cut Delmonicos and vend lamb sausages alongside jars of whipped lardo and a handful of cheeses."
67 Irving Pl (btwn E 18th & E 19th St), New York, NY
Cheese Store · Gramercy Park · 39 tips and reviews
Lily: NYMag 2014 Food & Drink Issue: "The swanky new Irving Place shop (spun off from the Williamsburg branch) holds regular classes and 'meet the maker' events. But you can learn a lot just by browsing."
Cheese Store · West Village · 265 tips and reviews
Serious Eats: One of the city's top cheese shops with incredible selection and always-friendly staff. Grilled cheese sandwiches and sweet snacks are winners, too.
Gourmet Store · North Slope · 122 tips and reviews
Serious Eats: Pricey but lovely market with great sandwiches, cheese, pantry and prepared foods, ice cream, and more, with many products made in Brooklyn.
Lily: NYMag 2014 Food & Drink Issue: "Team Boulud bakes the baguettes and makes the charcuterie; Gallic groceries include Hervé Mons-aged cheese, Burgundy snails, and candied clementines from Corsica."