10 NYC Restaurants For Keylime Pies & Margheritas

7.5

1470 1st Ave (btwn 76th & 77th St.), New York, NY

Mexican Restaurant · Upper East Side · 29 tips and reviews

Matt Borst: Omg biggest margaritas ever! And how can I decide between the goat cheese or the duck quesadilla. (Seriously how do I decide?!)

7.6

89 E 42nd St (Grand Central Terminal), New York, NY

Seafood Restaurant · Midtown East · 404 tips and reviews

Julie Qiu: THE Biggest selection of oysters in the city, hands down. Reasonably priced.

7.9

633 3rd Ave (at E 40th St), New York, NY

Seafood Restaurant · Murray Hill · 90 tips and reviews

8.3

259 Front St (at Dover St), New York, NY

Mexican Restaurant · Financial District · 162 tips and reviews

7.8

519 Hudson St (at W 10th St), New York, NY

Tex-Mex Restaurant · West Village · 159 tips and reviews

Michael E. Gruen: frozen margaritas. snoochies.

13 1st Ave (at 1st St), New York, NY

Mexican Restaurant · East Village · 37 tips and reviews