Island Pizza Restaurant
Pizzeria$$$$
Sanibel Island
"The island pizza is the way to go!!! Fantastic!"(22 Tips)
"Try the Caesar Salad Pizza - it's great"(2 Tips)
"Best pizza on the island!"(4 Tips)
"Good pizza and very friendly staff."(2 Tips)
29 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- casual
- delivery
- Caesar salad
- calzones
- (4 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Polish Punk OffroadJune 23, 2012Buy one get one during happy hour on draft beer! Pizza and Caesar salad are excellent!
Janet WilsonAugust 1, 2015The crust is unusual. Rolled up on the edges and a little sweet. You can wait a very long time in season for dine in or delivery. Gets packed.
Kayla RodriguezJuly 25, 2015The cheese sticks/Caesar salad/pepperoni and sausage pizza are all good but the four cheese pizza is horrible and the garlic bread we got had a hair
Mike SDecember 27, 2014We came for a Greek salad. Not what you want to have here, we can't speak for any other food items. Service was rather poor and we almost left just waiting to get service after we first arrived.
LinettJuly 24, 20131 hour and 3 minutes from the time we ordered to when the pizza arrived. Decent pizza but I rather my waitresses not reek of cigarettes and vodka at a family restaurant.
Cole SmithMay 23, 2018Save your money and your time. There's significantly better pizza on the island. Also, the service is consistently atrocious.
35 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
What makes Island Pizza Company stand out from other pizza restaurants is that we believe that customer satisfaction is the key to a successful business. O...
Open until 10:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
(239) 307-0035
Features
Reservations
No
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Music
Live Music
Food & Drink
Menus
Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 7.4
"The bread with dipping oil = phenomenal! Family friendly, but fun for adults, too! Our waitress, Jen, was the best!"
Darlene Cieri - 7.2
"We had breadsticks with marinara, a pepperoni pizza and bbq ribs. All were outstanding. This place is a hidden gem."
Joe C - 7.8
"Try the fresh pasta caprese - fresh mozzarella , fresh tomato, and hand-made pasta"
Aj Black
Places people like to go after Island Pizza Restaurant
- 7.8
"Their cinnamon swirl bread is delicious. We always make sure to grab a few loafs while on our annual Sanibel vacation. The grocery prices are a little high but thats to be expected. Always clean too"
Russell H. - 8.1
"Great location. Love the old school walk up window."
Scott Williams - 8.2
"Extremely Gluten-Free friendly. Ask for GF recommendations when ordering. Lots of selection and GF knowledge!"
Cat Flippen
Appears on 12 lists
The 20 best value restaurants in Sanibel, FL
Created by Doc Bruce
4 items • 8 followersCreated by Susan
17 items • 3 followers
Created by Sanibel Sam
96 items • 8 followers