Insignia Prime Steak & Sushi
Steakhouse, American Restaurant, and Sushi Restaurant$$$$
Smithtown
Ranked #4 for steakhouses in Smithtown
"Delicious not lady like Sushi- pieces too huge."(2 Tips)
"saffron-tinted seafood chowder and refreshing crabmeat cocktail"(7 Tips)
"high end food but forgot to pay attention to the food."(3 Tips)
"The 100 day dry aged steak is to die for!"(2 Tips)
31 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- steak
- good for dates
- good for groups
- creamed spinach
- foie gras
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Marco NavarraApril 28, 2015OMG! Great room! Great service! Great food! Filet and creamed spinach both outstanding, as was the Black Forest desert. Expensive, yet worth it! I'll be back!
Julie⚓️February 27, 2013Steak is ridiculous! Truffle mac n cheese was delicious as well! I was here on a Tuesday night and it was busy, I'd suggest reservations!
Nat SangNovember 26, 2012I've been here several times since it opened. It is awesome. The food is perfection. The only place I want a steak from, great sushi too. A must must must on the to do list.
Restaurant Critic Who Enjoys What He Does Follow Me To Read Reviews Before Heading OutOctober 6, 2015Good attempt at a fancy place with high end food but forgot to pay attention to the food. Maybe turning the lights way down is the approach. Great place for cocktails before moving on.
CharlieMarch 9, 2012The perfectly prepared Wagyu Boneless Rib Eye sated the palate, and the awe-inspiring wine list offered a distinctive pairing! Impeccable ambiance...
Mike SeilbackNovember 12, 2012Beautiful restaurant with delicious food and drinks. Bring your wallet because it is very pricey (but worth it)- Explore Long IslandFebruary 12, 2013Our critics enjoyed the saffron-tinted seafood chowder and refreshing crabmeat cocktail (with crunchy seaweed). Read more
Larry GrebFebruary 3, 2012Another Scotto brothers masterpiece .... Was the old Boulder Creek. Now a beautiful place with a high price tag... Good eating though.. I actually made quite a few deliveries during change.
K GrazianoFebruary 8, 2012Seared yellow fin tuna steak w a spicy crab roll, watermelon radish & sweet soy-lime sauce is tonight's fish special @ 38- K GrazianoFebruary 8, 2012We have a 32 day dry aged Kansas city sirloin special (26oz bone in) topped off w. a decadent black truffle foie gras butter @59
JeSsiCa 🐳 MirandaApril 13, 2012Great place! But Sushi pieces way to big, really hard to eat it without messing everything up. Not classy- The 100 day dry aged steak is to die for! You have to try it!
Scott BrunengraberFebruary 10, 2013They still aren't better than Blackstone. Ordered a filet rare plus with heavy char, came out LAST and was WELL DONE. Really? They then brought me out a raw steak with barely a sear
David RosenDecember 24, 2011They always send you to the bar first, even if tables are all empty. Sleazy way to make an extra few bucks...
CFI WilliamFebruary 4, 2012Grenades! Never saw a bigger gathering of has-been battle axes in one place. Yikes. Food was disappointing only topped by the poor wait staff. Can't say I'll ever come here again.
119 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Insignia Prime Steak & Sushi
610 Smithtown Byp (Mount Pleasant Rd)
Smithtown, NY 11787
United States
Smithtown, NY 11787
United States
Closed until 5:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Wed
- 5:00 PM–9:00 PM
- Thu–Sat
- 5:00 PM–11:00 PM
- Sun
- 4:00 PM–9:00 PM
(631) 656-8100
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Appears on 28 lists
Created by Thomas Seery
23 items • 1 follower
Guide to New York's best spots
Created by Charlie
51 items • 9 followers
Created by Orlando Salcedo
14 items • 1 follower