Hicks & McCarthy
(Now Closed)American Restaurant, Tea Room, and Breakfast Spot$$$$
Pittsford Village, Pittsford
43 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Hicks & McCarthyMay 8, 2014If you're looking for a last-minute Mother's Day gift Hicks & McCarthy wine dinner on Friday, May 16 is the perfect idea. They will absolutely love you for it! Call 586-0938 to make your reservations.
- Hicks & McCarthySeptember 28, 2013High-end wines and Holly Howell, a recipe for an unforgettable evening. Please call 586-0938 to secure your reservation for Friday, October 4th at 6:30 PM. We hope to see you there.
Vince FrisinaOctober 27, 2013Try the Main Street Skillet for brunch when it goes on the regular menu. Perfectly seasoned hash over an onion potato cake. And the spicy ketchup is more "spicy" than "ketchup".
Arjun MishraJanuary 2, 2013Excellent breakfast foods, from indulgent pancakes and Belgian waffles to eggs and combos. Just an overall happy atmosphere that fits the quaintness of the village.- Hicks & McCarthySeptember 28, 2013High-end wines and Holly Howell, a recipe for an unforgettable evening. Please call 586-0938 to secure your reservation for Friday, October 4th at 6:30 PM. We hope to see you there.
- Hicks & McCarthyOctober 9, 2014Team Trivia tonight at Hicks & McCarthy which starts at 6:30 pm. Happy Hour Specials & our chef's creations all night
- Hicks & McCarthySeptember 16, 2014Talented Chef Kevin McMaster hosting this "Palate Explosive" Wine and Food pairing event to Hicks & McCarthy Friday, September 26 at 6:30 pm.
Mark BaumlerFebruary 14, 2015Had beef on wick with fries. Absolutely great! Service was wonderful, very nice place an good people.
Keri FrazerJune 7, 2013Bananas Foster is truly as good as everyone says. There is no point in this tip other than to persuade you to treat yourself!!- Hicks & McCarthySeptember 14, 2013Call 586-0938 to secure your reservation for this incredible event. 23 S. Main St., Pittsford, NY, 14534 I hope to see you there.
- Hicks & McCarthy spent 18 days in July remodeling and it looks beautiful especially the wine bar! Also you must check out the brand new dinner menu.
- Hicks & McCarthyOctober 16, 2014Celebrate Halloween with us - Thursday, October 30th at 6:30 PM. We're taking trick-or-treating to a whole new level!
H HMarch 18, 2015There's actually no gluten free menu but they do have a "oat nut" or house gluten free pancake.
Kieran DraperOctober 15, 2011For those who have not been here in a while Come! It is great! New owners are doing a nice job. Hope it does not get too busy to get in!
Anything...Anything you have here Rocks!...THE STAFF IS SO FRIENDLY!....I love small towns!
Get the Bananas Foster for something sweet! Prepared much better than French toast at other places.
Lisa MusialJuly 27, 2011Pam and Liz are the best waitress' here. Make sure to ask to sit in their section! & Don't forget to tip!
- Chris COctober 26, 2011Make sure to bring the Monte cristo kid with you to help navigate the breakfast lunch hybrids.
Beth MossworthMarch 25, 2012Expect if you don't fit the look of the location you will wait longer for a seat to open in the back.
Want to grow your business??? Visit the Peak Performers networking group here every Tue 7:15am!!! #BNI #rochester
Erin Izzy GriffinAugust 31, 2014It smelled like vomit when we came in. I ordered a vanilla bean malt and it tasted peculiar.
Peter BrozowitzDecember 31, 2010The waitress will eat food of your dish... And the food sucks anyway
70 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Hicks & McCarthy
23 S Main St (btw State & Lincoln Ave)
Pittsford, NY 14534
United States
Pittsford, NY 14534
United States
Hicks & McCarthy in Pittsford, NY celebrates over 100 years as a landmark All-American restaurant serving great food, beer, wine, and high tea.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Tue
- 7:00 AM–3:00 PM
- Wed
- 7:00 AM–9:00 PM
- Thu–Fri
- 7:00 AM–9:30 PM
- Sat
- 8:00 AM–9:30 PM
- Sun
- 8:00 AM–2:30 PM
(585) 586-0938
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch
Drinks
Wine, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 6.0
"Friendly service, but don't come when you are in a rush. Very low sense of urgency"
Aileen M - 8.5
"Easily the *best* buffalo chicken wrap I have ever had. Not messy, great flavor. Decently priced and the 20 minute wait was so worth it."
Stephanie Toomey - 7.9
"Greek salad with of course the greek dressing and grilled shrimp-super amazing!!!!"
April Mcevoy
