Hamilton’s Soda Fountain & Luncheonette
(Now Closed)Diner, Ice Cream Parlor, and American Restaurant$$$$
West Village, New York
34 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Carly HeitlingerFebruary 11, 2015A super cute old-fashioned luncheonette in the West Village. Go for a malt milkshake and a side of fries for the perfect sweet/salty combination.
Caitlin ClementsAugust 7, 2014Amazing prices - and tasty burgers. But the real winners are the sodas and shakes. Sit by the bar to see them prepared before your eyes by the talented staff!
Ben YoungNovember 22, 2014Popped in for breakfast, great food, prices and service. Be great for a couple of drinks after work once they get their license.
Valerie SecklerSeptember 2, 2014A bubbly malted milk shake made with vanilla ice cream and butterscotch syrup is reason enough to visit. Patience helps; the service is lacking.
Sandwiches are okay. Almost too simple but good for a quick meal. Waffles are tiny and same goes with the standard burger. The side of french fries is literally about 7 fries for $4-found that overpri
David XuFebruary 15, 2016great vibe, fantastic music, chill place to sit and chat. sodas are alright.
Stephanie MMay 3, 2015The milkshakes were fantastic and the sandwiches and fries solid. However the service was awful, the waitress forgot my friend's food and kept mixing up our orders (there were 3 of us).
Jill MulliganApril 18, 2015The sandwiches were good, but we never got the fries or mac & cheese we ordered without any explanation. It also took a few requests to get a soda. 😕
Miguel LopezMay 23, 2015Good place with cheap prices and an open, airy feel. Good for people watching.
msMarch 12, 2015Super cute, but feels a bit underdeveloped. That being said - it wasn't too pricey and I loved the pineapple soda
Katherine BarnaAugust 9, 2014Great egg cream, but the food and the service could use some serious help
MayaAugust 16, 2014Fun retro sodas and shakes don't make up for inexcusably bad service and beyond-mediocre food.
aisha baiocchiJune 2, 2015The malts are GREAT! And the ice-cream is delicious but the burgers are okay, nothing special .
Adam SheldonOctober 15, 2014Burger and milkshake were good enough, service needs a total overhaul; slow, no follow up once the meal was deliver, or when we wanted to pay the cheque.
Nicole SerratoreJune 3, 2015Terrible, inattentive service--like forgetting silverware for quite a while while food got cold. Enjoyed the fountain sodas.
Leo SkvirskiyJuly 29, 2015Здесь из-под полы продают неплохое красное по $20 за БУТЫЛКУ. Оно в магазине-то стоит $15. Я не знаю, где в Сити можно выпить еще дешевле, да еще и в месте для завтраков. Только тс-с-с.
68 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
SHORT
Hamilton’s Soda Fountain & Luncheonette transports your taste buds back to the 1940s with sodas & classic food. Stop by our Greenwich Village shop today.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- 6:00 AM–Midnight
- Sun
- 6:00 AM–11:00 PM
(212) 661-1515
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Dessert
See More
You might also like
- 8.5
"Perfect for a leisurely weekday breakfast or lunch. Had a great BLT, and the sweet potato fries are better than the crinkle cut."
Cole Kennedy - 8.1
"Great breakfast food including French toast, waffles, omelettes and brunch food. Good service, friendly staff."
Diana Pardue - 8.8
"Tuna melt, breakfast sandwich, and pancakes all insanely inventive and tasty. Momofuku alum elevating the diner."
Noah Weiss
Places people like to go after Hamilton’s Soda Fountain & Luncheonette
Appears on 86 lists
Created by Bitches Who Brunch
9 items • 11 followers
Created by MTTC
203 items • 2 followers