See all
984 photos

Guy's American Kitchen and Bar

(Now Closed)

American Restaurant$$$$

Theater District, New York

Save

196 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Sara NineDecember 15, 2013
Terrible service, two-page menu, no toilet paper in restroom & found a strand of hair buried in my $18 salad. Was reassured by the waiter that "no one in the kitchen has that color hair." Nice.
Jesse HDecember 6, 2014
It's like the food is making fun of you for eating it
Steven LoweryDecember 26, 2012
That scathing review in the Times was partially true. The service is horrendous but the comments regarding the food were exaggerated.
Connie MartinJuly 13, 2013
Eat everything!!!
HillelJanuary 5, 2014
Sat down, waiter came by asks us what we want to drink. We mention some food he responds with,"I asked if you need drinks not food." We promptly left.
Tom Kammerer IIOctober 20, 2012
The California egg rolls were meh. Get the other appetizers.
Sebastian FactorNovember 1, 2014
Dragons breath fries
Kelly Reeves 🐱September 11, 2012
Sit in the Fender room and ask for AJ
Tee JimenezAugust 11, 2014
Shrimp Kabobs
Katie CarpenterMay 27, 2013
Worst service EVER! Ordered an appetizer, drinks and dessert. Waitress never brought silverware, plates, napkins or refills. Heck, waitress didnt return after taking order. We left and won't be back.
Claire VeeningaDecember 8, 2012
Totally unimpressed by this place. Burger meat tasted low quality... Fries tasted like they came from frozen... My friends steak was overcooked twice... The only saving grace was the italian nachos...
Andrew FletcherMarch 2, 2013
Flavor Town doesn't have much flavor.
Julia AdrianoSeptember 13, 2014
The food is good, but not remarkable
Louis WayneDecember 5, 2015
The chicken is okay, but the table is too small and servers are not that friendly.
Teresa FletcherJanuary 5, 2013
Pulled pork sliders!!! Gorgeous
Richard H.April 27, 2013
Groups: don't ask them to split the checks because they won't.
AJ AyeNovember 17, 2012
Thought this would be funny but it's not. It's actually trying to be a real restaurant, didn't realize...
Shaun RatteeNovember 19, 2012
Food was great service was slow
Bin YangJanuary 11, 2015
It doesn't get worse than this - run.
bobby fingerSeptember 11, 2012
Try the...EVERYTHING!
Joseph CatalanoNovember 17, 2012
Good burger
Kristin KnottJuly 31, 2013
So so...nachos were not that tasty
Steve AOctober 18, 2012
The menu looks like it from the mind of an eleven year old.
Paul ZakMarch 20, 2013
Soda was flay - pretzel chicken strips did not taste like pretzels.
Crystal MacJune 6, 2013
Don't get the rotisserie chicken it's really dry
SamanthaOctober 11, 2013
Won't split checks.
Tyler MDecember 26, 2012
Do yourself a favor and don't order anything with "Donkey Sauce". I fail to understand how any human would enjoy that crap.
C MSeptember 29, 2012
Service is very good, but food is WAY OVERPRICED for what you get. Go to Juniors instead and ask for Brandon
Gregory LopezJanuary 2, 2013
This place smells so good that cartoon food smell in the air the swiftly line
Sana Al-DosaryAugust 18, 2014
The service was very bad and we left without trying the food because of that.
Sydney WellsAugust 6, 2015
I definitely recommend the bacon, Mac-n-Cheese burger!! It's amazing!!!
William MinterAugust 22, 2015
Avoid the chicken tenders at all cost! Independence pale ale is OK. Way overpriced!!!
Sarah GordonOctober 11, 2013
Won't split checks. Didn't
Birim GonulsenOctober 19, 2013
Avoid!Mediocre food, total disappointment! Don't let the venue or the celebrity name to impress you!
Tom Kammerer IIOctober 20, 2012
I get better food at a green turtle for a third the price. Not coming back here.
Jason LeeMarch 5, 2013
Avoid the calamari at all costs. It's old, cold, and barely edible. Not even the donkey sauce can save it.
Mauricio GarcíaJuly 2, 2014
An expensive Applebee's. Bad food and bad drinks.
Lauri OllariApril 7, 2013
Over advertised.
Henry RamirezDecember 16, 2012
Don't waste your time or your money. It's not worth it
Max KingSeptember 23, 2012
Ridiculously overpriced. The shrimp po'boy was downright bad.
Yelda UzunJuly 4, 2015
Herşey çok güzel, porsiyonlar büyük, steak Tek kelimeyle mükemmel, sarımsaklı patates kızartmasını mutlaka tadın
Aysun ÖzdağJuly 5, 2015
Ambians muhteşem, müzik keyifli.. /Wonderful ambiance with nice music..
Débora GomesDecember 29, 2013
Excelente opção se vc está na times square e não quer ficar duas horas na fila do Hard Rock Café.
Atakan PortakalMarch 10, 2015
Sicak bir yer personel ilgili ve guler yuzlu.
Pavel ZolotarevMay 22, 2013
Один из лучших ресторанов американской кухни в НЙ.
Vitor Ferreira FernandesFebruary 16, 2013
Muito bom ! Melhor jantar de NY !!!!

1 2 3 4

984 Photos

Guy's American Kitchen and Bar

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Guy's American Kitchen and Bar

Appears on 88 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.