Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
9 Toasty Subterranean Bars To Hide in 'Til Spring
Le Boudoir is one of 9 Toasty Subterranean Bars To Hide in 'Til Spring.

1. Le Boudoir

7.5
135 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Speakeasy · Brooklyn Heights · 15 tips and reviews

GothamistGothamist: Scope out the secret bookshelf at Chez Moi in Brooklyn Heights and follow the staircase to this basement lounge inspired by Marie Antoinette. Read more.

Sweetwater Social is one of 9 Toasty Subterranean Bars To Hide in 'Til Spring.

2. Sweetwater Social

643 Broadway (at Bleecker St), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Greenwich Village · 59 tips and reviews

GothamistGothamist: Nestled beneath Coco & Cru, this bar beneath Broadway bar serves fun cocktails and tasty bar bites to wile away the long, chilly nights. The bar rocks a nice foosball table, too. Read more.

The Shakespeare is one of 9 Toasty Subterranean Bars To Hide in 'Til Spring.

3. The Shakespeare

7.5
24 E 39th St (btwn Madison & Park Ave), New York, NY
Gastropub · Murray Hill · 71 tips and reviews

GothamistGothamist: Pull back the velvet curtain and descend into a 16th-century style British pub decked out in tons of wood, a low ceiling and a mock fireplace. Read more.

Bar Below Rye is one of 9 Toasty Subterranean Bars To Hide in 'Til Spring.

4. Bar Below Rye

247 S 1st St, Brooklyn, NY
Cocktail Bar · Williamsburg · 8 tips and reviews

GothamistGothamist: Beneath Williamsburg's living room-esque restaurant Rye is a sister bar decked out in rustic wood panels reminiscent of a cozy cabin in the woods. The restaurant's known for its aged Old Fashioneds. Read more.

The Up & Up is one of 9 Toasty Subterranean Bars To Hide in 'Til Spring.

5. The Up & Up

9.0
116 Macdougal St (btwn W 3rd & Bleecker St), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Greenwich Village · 116 tips and reviews

GothamistGothamist: It's both a welcome respite from the insanity of NYU land and also chilly weather and blustery winds. Their seasonal menu's got belly warming cocktails like the Conflict Mint ($15). Read more.

Riddling Widow is one of 9 Toasty Subterranean Bars To Hide in 'Til Spring.

6. Riddling Widow

127 Macdougal St (W 3rd St), New York, NY
Wine Bar · Greenwich Village · 8 tips and reviews

GothamistGothamist: This spot is dedicated to the delightful effervescence of sparkling wines. The "underground champagne parlor" is quite small, with just 16 seats for sampling their selection of bubblies. Read more.

Jimmy's No. 43 is one of 9 Toasty Subterranean Bars To Hide in 'Til Spring.

7. Jimmy's No. 43

43 E 7th St (btwn 2nd & 3rd Ave), New York, NY
Bar · East Village · 135 tips and reviews

GothamistGothamist: This 7th street standby welcomes adventurous beer drinkers and anyone who just likes a pint in a casual, convivial environment. Read more.

Shalel is one of 9 Toasty Subterranean Bars To Hide in 'Til Spring.

8. Shalel

8.5
65 W 70th St (Columbus Ave), New York, NY
Lounge · Lincoln Square · 76 tips and reviews

GothamistGothamist: This Upper West Side date spot embodies the epitome of romance. Rose petals, candlelight and cushions for canoodling spell a winner for twosomes looking to kindle some quality time. Read more.

Slowly Shirley is one of 9 Toasty Subterranean Bars To Hide in 'Til Spring.

9. Slowly Shirley

121 W 10th St (at Greenwich Ave), New York, NY
Speakeasy · West Village · 48 tips and reviews

GothamistGothamist: There are classics like Old Fashioneds and Martinis. Before descending into drunkenness, try one of their bar snacks, like the mac n' cheese bites and a smoked fish dip served with Ritz crackers. Read more.