See all
145 photos

Giorgio's of Gramercy

New American Restaurant and Italian Restaurant$$$$

Flatiron District, New York

Save

8.4^/10

212

ratings

Ranked #7 for bread pudding in New York
"Get the s'mores bread pudding and you won't regret."(4 Tips)
"Roasted oysters, desserts, drinks, service - my new fav place!!!!"(10 Tips)
"... etc) and yummy pastas (half portions a HUGE plus!)."(2 Tips)
"Best meal I've had in ages, prix fixe all the way baby!!!"(3 Tips)

58 Tips and reviews

Filter:

good for dates
prix fixe menu
happy hour
half portions
bread pudding
s'mores
desserts
restaurants
great value
gelato
infused vodka
veal
surf & turf
spicy food
bar
pork chops
tequila
grilled cheese sandwiches
staff
sunsets
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Joe MedvedApril 12, 2019
Returned for 1st time in 12 yrs. There's good reason it's stood the test of time. Cozy atmosphere, incredibly friendly service, great food, reasonably priced. Love the chicken and burger.
IrmaZandl ZandlSlantFebruary 23, 2018
An odd vibe with strange table placement. saturday nite half empty. HOWEVER, food and service wonderful. had mussels and cacio e pepe (and you can order half portions of pasta). DELISH.
The Corcoran GroupApril 3, 2012
Attentive and friendly service doesn’t outshine the food. The prix fixe is a fab deal for $35 – get the Fried Oysters, the Surf ‘N Turf and the S’more Bread Pudding.
Gianna NebbiaOctober 29, 2017
Had such a great meal here. The prices are reasonable and the portions are large. Loved my veal and the mussels appetizer
Anderson DuPontAugust 1, 2015
Ah man, Roasted Oysters, roasted oysters, roasted oysters. The food, the staff, the place is simply great. A very good place for an intimate dinner for two.
Lori LuoAugust 10, 2014
This Italian restaurant serves up one of the best burgers in the city. It's topped with caramelized onions and melted gruyere, all next to a substantial portion of truffle fries.
Sara KNovember 13, 2011
Been here 100+ times
Sit at the bar and talk to the amazing bartenders. Delicious infused liquors, yummy bar snacks (truffle grilled cheese, cheese fries, etc) and yummy pastas (half portions a HUGE plus!).
Kerry BargerAugust 8, 2012
Prix Fixe is the way to go - fried oysters, seared veal chop (one of the finest cut of meats I've ever had) and s'mores bread pudding. Great atmosphere, friendly service.
Matthew BechardNovember 12, 2017
Been here 10+ times
Ask for James to be your waiter if available, spectacular service every time we go to see him! Been going to Giorgio’s for almost 15 years now.
Alexander BinderFebruary 20, 2014
Went there for dinner, excellent service. Friendly and helpfull. Fantastic food. The fries with truffle where great! Also very good value.
Stephanie MNovember 7, 2015
The mac and cheese and brussel sprouts were really tasty. Definitely a place to take family/out of town visitors or a date.
Kari OsborneDecember 22, 2015
The food is flavorful, and the portions are rather large. Price is very reasonable. Recommend the penne pasta, salad, and linguine.
kara silvermanApril 27, 2014
This place is beyond accommodating. The staff if so sweet and kind and helpful. And I haven't even mentioned how wonderful the food is. Love!!!
Jwala GApril 1, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Some of the friendliest bartenders around. A great place to meet friends for happy hour - dont forget to check out their homemade infused liquors!
Tara Maylyn Frankel LeavittFebruary 19, 2017
Roasted oysters are amazing. Must get the s'mores bread pudding. Cozy but great for groups.
Ashley OrkinJuly 16, 2013
Great atmosphere and great service. Biggest piece of veal I've ever seen! Get the s'mores bread pudding and you won't regret.
Stephen MilbankFebruary 23, 2016
The veal parm is epic! Veal pappardelle and baked macaroni were also delicious.
Frances M.March 8, 2014
I had a great dining experience here. Delicious food & great staff. Would definitely recommend this place!
Mandi GrossAugust 14, 2014
Super friendly staff - very intimate location and attentive service. Would definitely return!
E. T.March 24, 2013
Make a reservation and show up late because they definitely wont seat you for 30 min! Worst food I've had in NYC, aside from the mac and cheese. OTBS, ask for Brian to do your drinks!
Giselle ValdezOctober 25, 2023
Great drinks, oysters, and drinks! Awesome hospitality made me want to move back to NY
Whitney Wood BaileyJuly 4, 2013
The tuna is divine and so is the friendly staff. A neighborhood gem for sure!
Melissi PantsAugust 14, 2016
Barrata is amazing, port house for two is amazing. Desserts - AMAZING!
Laurie D.February 12, 2013
Josh is a great bartender! Very knowledgeable. Ask him for a recommendation - you won't be disappointed :)
Jill GaynorAugust 26, 2013
Monday night happy hour. 😻😻😻. The Sunset is amaz and only $5.
Matt LanganJune 29, 2012
Awesome spot to avoid the happy hour clusterfucks along Park & Broadway. FYI bottled beers only (no draft).
Caroline LeMarch 13, 2015
great date spot, wonderful menu, and great service
Derrick ChouJuly 14, 2011
Definitely recommend this spot for anyone thinking of going. Small quaint great service great food. Worth the pre fixe $
PuBtasticAugust 1, 2013
Unusually red! Well, really good food with good wine pairing recommendations.
Michael MisiorskiDecember 13, 2017
The pastas are great and not expensive
Jess PengJune 19, 2014
delicious brussels sprouts, scallops, and waiters
AMANDA MJanuary 16, 2011
The bartender Chris is the best!!! We came in on a Saturday night & he was super nice to us! Always be kind to your bartenders!!! xoxoxo
foodforfelJune 5, 2012
The gnocchi with lobster is fantastic - Not too rich and super savory.
Wu YiApril 3, 2015
Pork chop was excellent and portion was big
BonnieSeptember 27, 2010
Any place that infuses their own liquor-amazing! Roasted oysters, desserts, drinks, service - my new fav place!!!!
AppFirst, Inc. HQApril 12, 2013
nice prices and amazing food and drinks. highly recommend.
SPQRAugust 13, 2014
Amazing food and a vibrant bar scene
Matt BorstJuly 22, 2012
Omg my veal was unreal! Great, spicy cocktails too.
TimJuly 20, 2012
The best forks between park & broadway, spoons are average but the forks OMG!!!
Dana VanpamelenOctober 19, 2011
Try the Apple cinnamon infused bourbon! Bartenders are creative and friendly!
Michael DiscenzaMarch 4, 2016
Hidden gem of a lunch place!
Gary TorielloApril 10, 2013
Get the Tiramisu Gelato for dessert!
Katherine ChenMarch 13, 2014
Excellent food! Prix-fix
Moses AMay 4, 2011
Been here 25+ times
Awesome infused vodkas, bourbons, tequilas, and gins changed seasonally.
JohnApril 8, 2016
Burrata and the Papardelle
Bob HoeglerSeptember 21, 2013
Great food, great staff, great experience!
Toby MatejovskyMarch 5, 2015
The Yellowjacket is delicious
estherAugust 14, 2014
.... the complementary bread was the best part
Thibault LeruitteDecember 22, 2016
Réservation doesn't really mean anything for them. Had a reservation at 8pm. We were there at 8 sharp. Weren't seated before 8:35 and food was served after 9pm.
Julie AvraJune 15, 2017
Good pasta and happy hour

1 2

145 Photos

Giorgio's of Gramercy

You might also like

Places people like to go after Giorgio's of Gramercy

Appears on 152 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.