Fratelli La Bufala NYC
(Now Closed)Italian Restaurant$$$$
Upper West Side, New York
20 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
BlissFulThoughtsDecember 29, 2012Very nice stuff , professional and prepared. Food a little over priced but normal for NY's upper west side. Nice date spot for an appetizer, wine and a small but rich pizza
Peter IkladiousFebruary 22, 2014Pizza was great... Fresh ingredients, tasty. Coffee also was really good. And they're really accommodating of kids
ivy♥November 1, 2012You know this place is legit when everyone who works here communicate in Italian, and so does the majority of guests!
Gianluca TarozziOctober 20, 2012Very good, very Italian! Pizze are excellent, try the 'paccheri' if you're in mood for pasta
Mathias WiecherSeptember 22, 2012Best Pizza on the Upper West Side. Finally an Italian restaurant run by Italians.
Brad LaneyApril 30, 2012Don't miss the buffalo mozzarella...they fly it in from Naples three times a week!
Jessica W-snopJanuary 8, 2013Not the best pizza but a nice place to relax. Service was great. Good price on wine
Daryl EdelsteinJuly 24, 2012The menu is odd salads and pizza .. dont get the chicken, its smoked and tastes like Gouda .. unless you love Gouda, that is
Anton ZykinNovember 28, 2012Ordered rib-eye steak, they brought sirloin instead. Almost everyone of their staff are Russians.
Philips McCartyJune 21, 2012Don't be fooled by the meat dishes on the menu. They don't serve them. Go figure
rob zandJune 15, 2012strangely, this place doesn't have a bar. the pizza crust is thick and kinda rubbery.
Amanda CormierJune 12, 2012Overpriced. Much of the menu is not available at any given time. And the service is not great by any metric. Skip this place.- Amanda CormierJune 12, 2012Overpriced for what you get. Much of the menu isn't available at any given time. And the service is sloppy. Skip!
61 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
(212) 496-5303
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Wine
See More
You might also like
- 9.2
"We loved this place. Good was good, service was exceptional, and the place is very friendly and welcoming. Best part was the coconut cake!"
Magician Matias - 8.9
"Great authentic Italian. Cute date spot, really friendly staff. Cash only!"
Hannah B - 8.9
"Really classy ambiance. Enjoyed the bread w aubergine, steak for 2, spinach ravioli (although a bit eatery), and pecan pie. 18 santa barbara chardonnay and rum, pineapple cocktail"
Elizabeth Burstein
Places people like to go after Fratelli La Bufala NYC
- 9.2
"Fantastic theatre. Great staff. Clean bathrooms. A great view from most seats."
L. T.
- 8.7
"I like this theater. Lots of options, comfortable seats. Popular movies get sold out so make sure to book in advance."
I K - 8.4
"I have tried every flavor 150 times. Whether you like fruity or creamy flavors; my favorite flavor is Angel Food Cake."
John
Appears on 23 lists
Created by Jenn S
141 items • 21 followers
Created by Lesley K
64 items • 3 followers
Best Cheap Food (College Student Guide)
Created by Nathan Sukonik
105 items • 11 followers
