Fatty Fish
(Now Closed)Asian Restaurant$$$$
Upper East Side, New York
54 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Ms HeleneFebruary 4, 2017Sushi pizza was pastry based with seaweed salad and tuna topped $14, Fatty Fish salad with salmon $22 and sautéed edamame $6 all good
HectorMarch 30, 2016New management as of March 2016 - no longer serving sushi. They offer ramen. Still BYOB. Get the skewers, especially salmon and shrimp.
wonderful must try BBQ ribs and amazing sushi pizza. service is excellent. black widow spider roll very tasty. Will definitely will be coming back.
Suzanne DarmoryDecember 1, 2013Byob is amazing, as is the back garden. Threesome sushi is a must. Ribs are not what you expect, in a good way.
Susan KimAugust 14, 2014Sashimi seems to be really fresh here.. My new "go to- delivery" place for sushi. I never fail to order sashimi deluxe. Yum. 😍
nyc eboAugust 5, 2015Good place to visit if not everyone is into sushi. Their cooked food was delicious.
WeilynMarch 7, 2015Sushi sandwich, sushi pizza, & kimchi pancakes topped with filet mignon... BYOB too!
Jenny SchliessmanNovember 7, 2012My favorite sushi spot in all of Manhattan! Sushi is so fresh and delicious, be sure to try the sushi pizza
Rich Wolf RubelMarch 7, 2012Great Asian paella in coconut broth with lots of shrimp Chinese sausage, bean sprouts, edamame, mussels and chicken!
Jordan ParkerJanuary 27, 2017Hidden gem! Very extensive menu, friendly staff, heated, covered outdoor seating area.
Alison WonderlandMay 20, 2014Unusually crowded for a Monday night. Reservation recommended. Sushi pizza is a must.
Matthew ColemanSeptember 9, 2012Really awesome outdoor garden seating. Sushi pizza and the spicy kani sandwich are a must!
Marc SchneebergerMarch 4, 2017Dinner is not a good deal for the food quality but the brunch is really great!!!
Andrea GraceJune 8, 2013Loved the sushi pizza and avocado & octopus salad. Didn't love the green curry -was a little bland.
New York HabitatDecember 13, 2011Not so much fatty but certainly fishy, this innovative Asian fusion restaurant has great fish dishes at a good price. Try the salmon burger.
Elle ToussiFebruary 2, 2013If looking to get dessert, get the banana tempura. Hands down the best thing ever!
Luv ur food & not ur rude waitress..insisting Brunch is w/ only coffee or tea when cocktail or soda's also part of deal..no apology + gv sharing restrictions. WTF! Brunch isn't bottomless nor a buffet
Carrie MacFebruary 6, 2012Great for appetizers and drinks at dinner. Entree's not as good but fantastic presentations.
StefanieJune 23, 2011Sunday brunch is excellent!!! Great menu - try the coconut French toast - amazing!
Taylor FinkelsonAugust 3, 2011The lychee martini isn't very good .. Spice the Thai restaurant or Philip chow has the very best in the city
This Asian fusion restaurant offers large-portioned bento boxes, a kobe beef burger, and sweet potato fries. What else is better in life??
Lai HuangNovember 13, 2010the sashimi is excellent, and so is the gyoza. creamy green tea cheesecake!
Rafi RomeroJanuary 2, 2016If you're a sushi connoisseur/snob then stay away. It wasn't fresh, even in the middle of winter. I'd say half of the pieces were bad, and half mediocre. No truly good pieces.
S. Daniel G. TurokAugust 8, 2010No charge for bottles or beer! Bring your own and order any box or the spicy udon!
dealigeeDecember 1, 2010$40 Worth of Asian Fusion Fare at Fatty Fish Restaurant for $30. See dealigee.com for details.
- NEVER returning! (Malay) host yelled-like a Chinese gangster-@ me + my mom after he heard us complaining he had a bad attitude. WTF!? With downhill record of RUDE SVC + BAD FOOD, you'll surely close!
114 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:00 AM–10:30 PM
(212) 813-9338
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails, BYO
See More
You might also like
- 8.1
"Must try the pork dumplings! The tingly beef was great too, flavorwise. The noodles themselves are sub par but flavor was on point. Definitely coming back"
Jessie Catana - 7.2
"The best hand roll spicy salmon I've ever tried!"
Diego Borges - 8.8
"You can't go wrong with their spicy tuna tartare on crispy rice and soy ginger glazed salmon!"
Anna Shapiro
Places people like to go after Fatty Fish
Appears on 86 lists
Created by Lindsey M
200 items • 150 followers
Created by Evelyn Ling
150 items • 17 followers
Created by New York Habitat
48 items • 559 followers
