Reloading results...

Suggestions for Pie Shop near Theater District, New York

Filters:

8.5
1. Junior's Restaurant & Bakery
American • $$$$ • View Menu •
1515 Broadway (at W 45th St), New York
Save
- 3 items on the menu match pies
7.6
2. Angelina Bakery
Bakery • $$$$ • View Menu •
1675 Broadway (52nd St.), New York
Save
- 3 items on the menu match pies
7.9
3. Starbucks
Coffee Shop • $$$$ • View Menu •
1700 Broadway (at W 54th St), New York
Save
- 4 items on the menu match pies
6.7
4. Au Bon Pain
Bakery • $$$$ •
625 8th Ave (btw 40th & 41st St), New York
Save
- Rajiv F. • December 30, 2011Hands down, #1 reason I keep coming back are the chai spice whoopie pies!
7.4
5. Starbucks
Coffee Shop • $$$$ • View Menu •
1500 Broadway (btwn W 43rd & W 44th St), New York
Save
- 8 items on the menu match pies
8.1
6. Redeye Grill
American • $$$$ • View Menu •
890 7th Ave (at W 56th St), New York
Save
- Karon W. • October 20, 2014This place is overpriced but the banana cream pie is amazing. Doesn't really make up for paying a fortune for the entree.
7.4
7. Starbucks
Coffee Shop • $$$$ • View Menu •
870 7th Ave (at W 55th St), New York
Save
- 4 items on the menu match pies
7.4
8. Brooklyn Diner
Diner • $$$$ • View Menu •
155 W 43rd St (at Broadway), New York
Save
- 13 items on the menu match pies
8.2
9. Wolfgang's Steakhouse
Steakhouse • $$$$ • View Menu •
250 W 41st St (at 8th Ave), New York
Save
- 2 items on the menu match pies
6.9
10. Jack's Restaurant and Bar
American • $$$$ • View Menu •
147 W 40th St (7th Avenue & Broadway), New York
Save
- Todd H. • April 5, 2016Great place amazing staff and try the shepherds pie - best in the city
8.6
11. The Capital Grille
American • $$$$ •
120 W 51st St, New York
Save
- Dennis C. • March 18, 2011Shrimp cocktail is out of this world as well as the filet mignon. For desert go for the cg strawberries and coconut cream pie!!
7.4
12. Connolly's Pub & Restaurant
Irish • $$$$ • View Menu •
121 W 45th St (at 6th Ave), New York
Save
- 4 items on the menu match pies
8.3
13. Oceana
Seafood • $$$$ • View Menu •
120 W 49 St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave.), New York
Save
- 1 item on the menu matches pies
8.8
14. Shake Shack
Burgers • $$$$ • View Menu •
691 8th Ave (at W 44th St), New York
Save
- 1 item on the menu matches pies
8.3
15. Robert
American • $$$$ • View Menu •
2 Columbus Cir (Broadway), New York
Save
- 1 item on the menu matches pies
6.3
16. Europan Cafe
Café • $$$$ •
672 8th Ave (at W 43rd St.), New York
Save
- Angela P. • October 14, 2012Love the spanich pie !!! Fresh food all day !!! Boston cheese is a must try !!! Great service ! Love this place
9.0
17. Souvlaki GR
Souvlaki •
162 W 56th St (btwn 6th Ave & 7th Ave), New York
Save
- M N. • November 12, 2017Octopus was fresh, flavorful and fantastic for appetizer. The Spinach Pie and cheese saganki were and Spinach pie were also very well executed and delicious. moussaka as the entree was excellent
7.3
18. Brooklyn Diner
Diner • $$$$ • View Menu •
212 W 57th St (Broadway), New York
Save
- 2 items on the menu match pies
?
19. This pie is nuts
Bakery • $$$$ •
F5 Bryant Park Holiday Shops (42), New York
Save
- Nilesh D. • November 25, 2014Excellent gluten free vegan pies and hot chocolate. They also have a shop at 9 Henshaw st. www.thispieisnuts.com
7.0
20. The Playwright Tavern
Pub • $$$$ • View Menu •
202 W 49th St (btwn 7th Ave & Broadway), New York
Save
- 5 items on the menu match pies
8.7
21. The Living Room
Lounge • $$$$ •
153 W 57th St (At Lobby Level of Park Hyatt New York), New York
Save
- Suzanne X. • May 27, 2018Good tea selection, great apple pie and fast WiFi.
8.1
22. Ellen's Stardust Diner
Diner • $$$$ • View Menu •
1650 Broadway (at W 51st St), New York
Save
- Linnie D. • February 16, 2012Apple pie a la mode is the best!
8.9
23. Lena Horne Theatre
Theater •
256 W 47th St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York
Save
- Dennis B. • February 8, 2020Seeing “Waitress” here was super fun, and the whole place smelled like pie.
9.2
24. 54 Below
Performing Arts • $$$$ • View Prices •
254 W 54th St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York
Save
- 1 item on the menu matches pies
7.2
25. Playwright Celtic Pub
Pub • $$$$ • View Menu •
732 8th Ave (btwn 45th St & 46th St), New York
Save
- 6 items on the menu match pies
7.9
26. Morton Williams
Supermarket •
140 W 57th St (6th and 7th Avenue), New York
Save
- Tom B. • October 14, 2014Great selection of fresh cake and cheesecakes for $1.99 - Wish I had found the Pumpkin pie cheesecake sooner!
8.2
27. Bubba Gump Shrimp Co.
Seafood • $$$$ • View Menu •
1501 Broadway (btwn W 43rd & W 44th St), New York
Save
- 1 item on the menu matches pies
6.6
28. Hudson Market
American • $$$$ • View Menu •
811 7th Ave (at W 53rd St), New York
Save
- 14 items on the menu match pies
7.4
29. Red Lobster
American • $$$$ • View Menu •
5 Times Sq Fl 1 (at W 41st St.), New York
Save
- 1 item on the menu matches pies
7.2
30. McGee's Pub
Pub • $$$$ • View Menu •
240 W 55th St (btwn 8th Ave & Broadway), New York
Save
- 5 items on the menu match pies
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.