Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Reloading results...

Suggestions for New American Restaurant near Theater District, New York

Filters:
    • 8.5
      New American$$$$
      1065 6th Ave (btwn W 40th & W 41st St), New York
      Save
      • Sarah C.

        Sarah C. • February 16, 2017Hamachi tartare, Beet salad, Brussel sprouts and strip steak are great!

    • 7.8
      New American$$$$
      228 W 47th St, New York
      Save
      • Hector S.

        Hector S. • June 1, 2018Best Bloody Mary in town and the pastrami hash is amazing also!

    • 8.0
      New American$$$$View Menu
      252 W 47th St (btw Broadway & 8th Ave), New York
      Save
      • Scott T.

        Scott T. • February 13, 2015Salmon and steak are amazing. A little expensive but well worth it!

    • 7.8
      New American$$$$View Menu
      2 Columbus Cir (Broadway), New York
      Save
      • Marcin B.

        Marcin B. • May 1, 2013Make sure you book a table by the window for full experience. Great for romantic dinner.

    • 7.4
      New American$$$$View Menu
      70 W 45th St (6th Avenue), New York
      Save
      • Robert D.

        Robert D. • March 31, 2010gorgeous and delicious. Try the Butter Poached Hake. It's like Buhta

    • 8.3
      New American$$$$
      9 W 53rd St, New York
      Save
      • Christine W.

        Christine W. • June 10, 2014get the pistachio chicken, very filling and delicious.

    • 8.7
      New American$$$$View Menu
      9 W 53rd St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave), New York
      Save
      • mathew d.

        mathew d. • October 24, 2011All the cocktails and wine are phenomenal .. Perfectly balanced. Sarah is a pleasure

    • 8.5

      8. Bea

      New American$$$$View Menu
      403 W 43rd St (at 9th Ave), New York
      Save
      • Mark O.

        Mark O. • December 7, 2013Great staff and food. Love the spicy meatballs.

    • 7.8
      New American$$$$
      305 W 46th St, New York
      Save
    • 8.8
      New American$$$$View Menu
      60 E 54th St (btwn Madison & Park Ave.), New York
      Save
      • Danyel S.

        Danyel S. • February 3, 2016the oysters the popcorn the burger the chicken salad the cocktails the clubby atmosphere lived for all of it + service was great.

    • 8.3
      New American$$$$View Menu
      551 5th Ave (at W 45th St), New York
      Save
      • James B.

        James B. • August 8, 2014Blackened tuna rueben is delish! New favorite sandwich

    • 9.0
      New American$$$$
      99 E 52nd St (at Park Ave), New York
      Save
      • Shali N.

        Shali N. • September 16, 2017Carbone’s fancy spot for delicious prime rib, cocktails and fantastic service provided a perfect date night. Get the banana eclairs!

    • 8.0

      13. Savory

      New American$$$$View Menu
      15 W 39th St (39th and 5th), New York
      Save
      • Greg M.

        Greg M. • July 18, 2015It's really about the delivery. We all expect great food, but Savory nails it. Timely, accurate and delicious. Hands down one of my favorites in midtown. Solid choice.

    • 7.8
      New American$$$$View Menu
      628 10th Ave (btwn 44th St & 45th St), New York
      Save
      • Lila L.

        Lila L. • September 5, 2015Their Peach Cobbler is to DIE for. Best I've ever had.

    • 8.6
      New American$$$$View Menu
      9 E 37th St (btwn 5th & Madison Ave), New York
      Save
      • Alex S.

        Alex S. • July 6, 2019Live music and ambiance are superb. Feels like a lost era, but in an authentic way.

    • 8.2
      New American$$$$View Menu
      160 E 46th St (btwn Lexington & 3rd Ave.), New York
      Save
      • Mary P.

        Mary P. • July 23, 2015Great rooftop bar! Great fish, great lamb, great duck!

    • 7.9
      New American$$$$View Menu
      26 E 40th St, New York
      Save
      • Stephanie D.

        Stephanie D. • September 29, 2016The Beets and Corn are delicious - this is a new Midtown favorite!

    • 7.7
      New American$$$$View Menu
      10 Columbus Cir Ste 4 (at W 60th St), New York
      Save
      • Rhonada H.

        Rhonada H. • June 25, 2013Great filet, lovely wine selection and service is excellent.

    • 8.2
      New American$$$$View Menu
      2 E 61st St, New York
      Save
      • ⭐️

        ⭐️ • March 9perrine salad, campanelle al tartuffo, roasted salmon and the creamy mashed potatoes worth to try🤤 loved the service too 👍🏻

    • 7.9
      New American$$$$View Menu
      38 W 36th St (Between 5th & 6th Aves), New York
      Save
      • Susan L.

        Susan L. • June 29, 2016Loved the olive oil flatbread and burrata and knots. Skip the meatballs.

    • 7.4

      21. Isla

      New American$$$$
      25 W 38th St, New York
      Save
    • 8.4
      New American$$$$View Menu
      100 E 63rd St (btwn 5th & Madison Ave), New York
      Save
      • Angel S.

        Angel S. • July 14, 2013Attentive services, great drink selections and food is amazing. Make sure to leave room for all those art deco dessert!

    • 7.6
      New American$$$$View Menu
      110 E 42nd St (btwn Park Ave S & Lexington), New York
      Save
      • Alex H.

        Alex H. • March 26, 2012The coffee pana cotta is unreal! Must try!

    • 8.2
      New American$$$$View Menu
      133 E 65th St (Lexington), New York
      Save
      • mgsweeten

        mgsweeten • February 28, 2015Delish! Had the burrata with grilled beets and crushed the chicken kiev

    • 9.1
      New American$$$$View Menu
      311 E 60th St (btwn 1st & 2nd Ave), New York
      Save
      • Q D.

        Q D. • January 31, 2015Nice lowkey place where the drinks are great and the beer is even better

    • 7.5
      New American$$$$
      451 10th Ave (at W 35th St), New York
      Save
      • Frank R.

        Frank R. • June 5Though the service was great, the food was very mediocre to poor, and the prices were very high! You can do better.

    • 8.5
      New American$$$$
      1150 Broadway (at W 27th St), New York
      Save
      • Christina C.

        Christina C. • May 16, 2017Mac n cheese, zucchini flatbread both great.. nice place, slightly $$$

    • 9.3

      28. Upland

      New American$$$$View Menu
      345 Park Ave S (at E 26th St), New York
      Save
      • Martin

        Martin • September 15, 2016Little Gem Salad w/ Romaine, Walnuts, Avocado, Cucumber, And Ricotta Salata

    • 5.9
      New American$$$$
      New York
      Save
      • ⭐️

        ⭐️ • March 4NewYork cheesecake is a YUM!🥰

    • 7.6
      New American$$$$
      36 W 32nd St Fl 5 (btw Broadway & 5th Ave), New York
      Save
      • Jasmine M.

        Jasmine M. • December 10, 2019Loved the decor! Good wings and surprisingly some of the Best Mozzarella sticks I’ve ever had 🤷🏻‍♀️

    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.