Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Reloading results...

Suggestions for Italian Restaurant near Sutton Place, New York

Filters:
    • 7.9

      1. Sofia Pizza Shoppe

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      989 1st Ave (btw 54th & 55th St.), New York
      Save
      • Jess

        Jess • April 17, 2018My favorite pizza in Midtown East!! Spinach artichoke is great.

    • 7.7

      2. Marinara Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      985 1st Ave, New York
      Save
      • Steve M.

        Steve M. • November 30, 2018Awesome high quality pizza. Topping all seem fresh and full of flavor. The classic square pepperoni and sausage is fantastic. Everything very good.

    • 7.4

      3. Best Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1038 1st Ave (at E 57th St.), New York
      Save
      • Star 26 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 7.5

      4. Brooklyn Pizza Masters

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      1055 1st Ave, New York
      Save
      • Russell H.

        Russell H. • June 29, 2019Best pizza in midtown east on 1st over Marinara, Soph and Best on 1st. Margherita, buff and bbq packd w. quality chicken, veg is awesome, wife loves pear and the rice balls are killer at $3.

    • 7.0

      5. Bella Roma

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      405 E 57th St (57th and 1st), New York
      Save
      • Nas B.

        Nas B. • September 13, 2014Amazing pizza!!! Cheaper than other places around it. Friendly people there. Pay cash, it'll be cheaper ;)

    • 5.7

      6. Cafe Daniello's

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1072 2nd Ave (56th), New York
      Save
      • Star 6 items on the menu match Italian food
    • ?

      7. Il Valentino

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      330 E 56th St, New York
      Save
      • Star 11 items on the menu match Italian food
    • ?

      8. Memoria

      Italian • $$$$ •
      1004 2nd Ave (53rd St), New York
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?

      9. Nicola's Specialty Store

      Italian • $$$$ •
      997 1st Ave, New York
      Save
      • amoolia

        amoolia • March 25, 2011I don't even live in midtown anymore but we still come here for prosciutto. And you can't beat the service.

    • 8.8

      10. Eclair Bakery

      Bakery • $$$$ • View Menu •
      305 E 53rd St (btwn 1st & 2nd Ave), New York
      Save
      • Star 1 item on the menu matches Italian food
    • ?

      11. Coco Pazzeria

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      1078 1st Ave (at E 59th St), New York
      Save
      • Simran D.

        Simran D. • December 29, 2022I enjoyed my Duetto pizza & the tuna tartare.

    • 7.9

      12. Blue & Gold Deli

      Deli • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1075 1st Ave (E 59th St), New York
      Save
      • Star 4 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 7.8

      13. Bistro Vendome

      French • $$$$ • View Menu •
      405 E 58th St (1st Ave), New York
      Save
      • Star 3 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 6.6

      14. Kurant Wine Bar

      Wine Bar • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1091 2nd Ave (btwn 57th and 58th), New York
      Save
      • Jenn O.

        Jenn O. • June 12, 2014Definitely try the bacon Mac and cheese!

    • 8.1

      15. Jimbo's

      Burgers • $$$$ • View Menu •
      991 1st Ave (btwn E 54th & E 55th St.), New York
      Save
      • Star 1 item on the menu matches Italian food
    • 7.2

      16. Fusha Asian Cuisine

      Asian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1065 1st Ave (at 58th St.), New York
      Save
      • Star 3 items on the menu match Italian food
    • ?

      17. L. Simchick

      Butcher •
      988 1st Ave (54th street), New York
      Save
      • The Corcoran Group

        The Corcoran Group • April 21, 2011Great old school butcher shop – friendly and exceptionally knowledgeable. Try their hot Italian sausage.

    • Category icon
      ?

      18. Bridge Parking

      Auto Repair • View Services •
      321 E 60 St, New York
      Save
      • Star 1 item on the menu matches Italian food
    • Category icon
      ?

      19. Dessert Delivery

      Desserts • $$$$ • View Menu •
      360 55 Street (1st Avenue), New York
      Save
      • Star 4 items on the menu match Italian food

    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.