Reloading results...

Suggestions for Italian Restaurant near St. Augustine

Filters:
    • 8.4

      1. PizzAlley's Chianti Room

      Italian • $$$$ •
      60 Charlotte St, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Ashley W.

        Ashley W. • April 6, 2019One of our fave restaurants!! Try everything here I’m sure you can’t go wrong. Chicken Alfredo, Caesar Salad, Fresh Bread, Broccoli and cheddar soup, Spaghetti and lasagna. Amazing!!!

    • 9.0

      2. Pizzalley's Pizzeria

      Italian • $$$$ •
      117 Saint George St, St. Augustine
      Save
      • David T.

        David T. • October 24, 2010Pizzalley's at 60 Charlotte Street in St. Augustine, Fl. 904-825-4100. they have the best Pizza at a great price. get the pizza buy the slice. I like the Garbage can.

    • 8.2

      3. The Ancient Olive

      Italian • $$$$ •
      47 King St, St. Augustine
      Save
      • katie c.

        katie c. • March 8, 2015U have to try the violet balsamic with cilantro roasted onion olive oil

    • 7.4

      4. DINA - the Real Italian Piadina

      Italian • $$$$ •
      100 Saint George St (at Hypolita St), St. Augustine
      Save
      • Nino M.

        Nino M. • November 3, 2017Simple concept tasty pizzas and good service

    • 7.3

      5. Nonna's Trattoria

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      2 Aviles St, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Star 19 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 7.3

      6. Al's Pizza

      Italian • $$$$ •
      1 Saint George St, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Rachel L.

        Rachel L. • February 16, 2013Server wasn't too attentive but the food was delicious! Try the pesto cheese bread, mussels, and pesto chicken pizza...

    • 8.3

      7. Pizza Time

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      124 Saint George St, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Lee B.

        Lee B. • June 11, 2012Pizza is excellent and make sure you get a cannoli. One of the best I've had anywhere!

    • 8.4

      8. Carmelo's Marketplace

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      146 King St, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Star 40 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 8.7

      9. Mellow Mushroom

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      410 Anastasia Blvd, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Star 17 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 6.9

      10. Cafe Benedetto

      Italian • $$$$ •
      165 Vilano Rd, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Kirsten S.

        Kirsten S. • March 6, 2018Pasta primavera, crab stuffed shrimp, and the canollis.

    • 6.6

      11. Carrabba's Italian Grill

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      155 Sr 312 West, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Lee C.

        Lee C. • March 30, 2014Try their Mac and Cheese! 👍👍 Not just an ordinary pasta.

    • 8.5

      12. 180 Vilano Grille & Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      180 Vilano Rd, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Jason B.

        Jason B. • April 14, 2013The stuffed meat pizza was fantastic. Service was wonderful and friendly. Definitely a must if you are in Vilano.

    • 7.2

      13. Amici Italian Restaurant

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1915 SR-A1a S, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Star 41 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 6.5

      14. Borrillo's Pizzeria and Beer & Wine Garden

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      88 San Marco Ave (at Hope St), St. Augustine
      Save
      • Cassandra F.

        Cassandra F. • August 7, 2014Yummy thin crust pizza! One of my favorite pizza places in St. Augustine.

    • 7.9

      15. Antonio's Pizza

      Italian • $$$$ •
      590 A1a Beach Blvd, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Amelia R.

        Amelia R. • October 15, 2019Pizza is some of the best around. I love to get slice and eat it on the beach!

    • 7.3

      16. Five Star Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      987 S Ponce de Leon Blvd, St. Augustine
      Save
      • John D.

        John D. • March 12, 2011Chicken/Bacon/Ranch Pizza is awesome!

    • 7.5

      17. De Leon Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      84 Theatre Dr, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Amanda C.

        Amanda C. • December 23, 2015Loved this place! BBQ chicken pizza was delicious and there was a good beer selection. A great value as well!

    • 6.7

      18. Papa John's Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      801 S Ponce de Leon Blvd, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Star 20 items on the menu match Italian food
    • ?

      19. Vinny's Pizza

      Italian • $$$$ •
      105 Yacht Club Dr, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Tyler Q.

        Tyler Q. • November 25, 2017Good New York style pizza!

    • Category icon
      ?

      20. Saint

      Italian • $$$$ •
      St. Augustine
      Save
      • Alex G.

        Alex G. • December 21, 2024The Chicken Saltimbocca Parmesan is delicious. The breading is very flavorful. Some of the best I’ve ever had!

    • ?

      21. Romeo's Italiano Cafe

      Italian • $$$$ •
      12 Cathedral Pl, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Mio

        Mio • September 12, 2016Mozzarella sticks are really delicious. Not that frozen- prepared supermarket sh*t

    • ?

      22. Restaurant and Cafe Solo

      Italian • $$$$ •
      8 Aviles St (Downtown St Augustine), St. Augustine
      Save
      • Sean W.

        Sean W. • November 8, 2012This place is awesome. Angelo and Julianna, father-daughter combo, are delightful. Try the Brazilian Banana for dessert: unreal.

    • 8.2

      23. Romano's

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      4010 US-1, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Star 35 items on the menu match Italian food
    • ?

      24. St. Augie’s Pizza

      Italian • $$$$ •
      113 1/2 King St, St. Augustine
      Save
    • 6.8

      25. Cucina Giovanni

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      2730 State Road 16 (at I-95), St. Augustine
      Save
      • Star 82 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 8.7

      26. The Black Molly Grill

      Seafood • $$$$ •
      265 E Marina Cove Dr, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Sandra H.

        Sandra H. • July 23, 2011Pasta Hamboli is awesome! Golden filet can't be beat!

    • 9.1

      27. The Floridian

      American • $$$$ • View Menu •
      72 Spanish St, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Michael B.

        Michael B. • August 8, 2014The vegetarian pasta was awesome!

    • 8.7

      28. Mojo Old City BBQ

      BBQ • $$$$ •
      5 Cordova St (at Tolomato Ln), St. Augustine
      Save
      • Susan H.

        Susan H. • May 17, 2014The BBQ Reuben and the Smitty sandwiches were amazing!!! Burnt ends and mac and cheese are a must.

    • 8.3

      29. Panera Bread

      Bakery • $$$$ • View Menu •
      600 Tingle Ct, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Star 5 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 8.9

      30. Chick-fil-A

      Fast Food • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1752 US Highway 1 S, St. Augustine
      Save
      • Star 2 items on the menu match Italian food

    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.