Suggestions for Pizzeria near St. Augustine

Lauren B. • April 16, 2019The combo with a slice, soda, and side is only $6. Great for a quick lunch.

Angel O. • January 16, 2014The gluten free mighty meat pizza, was really good! Sorry, no pic, we ate it all! 😜

Jennifer M. • December 17, 2014Awesome burgers, wonderful soups, love the eggplant parm, and wedge salad is always great!

Terrie M. • July 17, 2018Awesome pizzeria!

Tony H. • May 2, 2017Second-best pizzeria in the U.S., according to TripAdvisor. It's some of the best pizza I've ever had.

John D. • March 12, 2011Chicken/Bacon/Ranch Pizza is awesome!

Rachel L. • February 16, 2013Server wasn't too attentive but the food was delicious! Try the pesto cheese bread, mussels, and pesto chicken pizza...

StAugustineBuzz • October 20, 2015New York Style Pizza...huge slices, fold and eat ..YUM!!

Amanda C. • December 23, 2015Loved this place! BBQ chicken pizza was delicious and there was a good beer selection. A great value as well!

Meridith F. • December 13, 2011Large thin crust, Chicago cut BBQ chicken pizza with extra chicken and a side of cheese sauce is the dynamite!

Robert B. • December 10, 2011The Gyros are the best inSt. Augustine.

Marv H. • April 19, 2015Bread comes with real roasted garlic! Pasta is al dente! You can't go wrong.

Theresa P. • June 1, 2012Great service!!! Meatball parm is something you shouldn't miss :)

Lisa T. • May 19, 201111 tables/booths 1 waitress.That one waitress has worked there for years and does a damn good job. And I'm glad you know math ;)

Conrad C. • June 2, 2010These guys really have $10 Pizzas as advertised on their sign. I thought it was a scam.and good service to boot. Thank you Pizza Slut!!!

Josiah R. • December 20, 2013Godfather pizza was good but got some sauce on the side. Bruschetta, 10", and cream brûlée to split was perfect for two.

Elizabeth F. • October 23, 2011Share the shrimp scampi and a dinner :) you won't regret it

Thomas • October 6, 2012Pizza sizes are VERY small. I wouldn't even call it pizza. Overpriced too.

Jason F. • July 31, 2023First time at this beachside restaurant, and I must say the food and the service is fantastic! I had the fish of the day Mahi Mahi , and it was amazing and fresh. Will definitely be back!

Elizabeth B. • May 11, 2012Great new pizza place, $7 bucks for a large one topping!

Alex • December 9, 2015AYCE buffet for $5.99 is an excellent deal - pizza was good, salad bar, plenty of pasta options.