Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Reloading results...

Suggestions for Ice Cream Parlor near Montauk

Filters:
    • 8.7

      1. Ben & Jerry's

      Ice Cream • $$$$ • View Menu •
      478 West Lake Drive Extension, Montauk
      Save
      • Laura M.

        Laura M. • July 18, 2012Very nice service, let me take a taste and recommended a great Carmel flavor!!

    • 8.1

      2. John's Drive-In

      Ice Cream • $$$$ •
      677 Montauk Hwy, Montauk
      Save
      • The Corcoran Group

        The Corcoran Group • March 14, 2011Burgers, shakes and fries and the best homemade ice cream to boot! Try the John burger and the homemade ice cream. No website, but then who needs one for a popular place like this.

    • Category icon
      7.4

      3. Van Leeuwen Ice Cream

      Ice Cream • $$$$ • View Menu •
      32 Star Island Road, Montauk
      Save
    • 7.3

      4. Ralph's Famous Ices

      Ice Cream • $$$$ •
      Save
      • George S.

        George S. • September 2, 2016Italian ices and much more! Every location has every flavor imaginable and much more. Try the specialty cream ices and shakes! Fun every time!

    • Category icon
      ?

      5. Sundae Fundae

      Ice Cream • $$$$ •
      Montauk
      Save
    • ?

      6. The Ice Cream Shop

      Ice Cream • $$$$ •
      Montauk
      Save
    • ?

      7. Frozen Anchor

      Ice Cream • $$$$ •
      478 W Lake Dr, Montauk
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?

      8. John's Homemade Ice Cream

      Ice Cream • $$$$ •
      Save
      • Damian B.

        Damian B. • July 22, 2015Very sweet ice cream with multiple homemade and soft serve options. The ginger based varieties are the best.

    • ?

      9. Fro-Yo & Gelato

      Ice Cream • $$$$ •
      43 S Euclid Ave, Montauk
      Save
      • Emily S.

        Emily S. • May 24, 2019Salted caramel pretzel!

    • Category icon
      ?

      10. Dan's Ice Cream and Pop

      Ice Cream • $$$$ •
      1 S Dewitt Pl, Montauk
      Save
    • ?

      11. Sugar

      Ice Cream • $$$$ •
      28 South Edison (South ETN), Montauk
      Save
    • ?

      12. Sundae Donuts Montauk

      Ice Cream • $$$$ •
      716 Montauk Hwy, Montauk
      Save
      • Pat H.

        Pat H. • August 29, 2022No subtle flavors here. Color and sugar explosion for the kidz..

    • ?

      13. East End Ice Café

      Ice Cream • $$$$ •
      805 Main Street, Montauk
      Save
      • Jeremy P.

        Jeremy P. • May 14, 2012Nice little patio in the back.

    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.