Suggestions for Seafood Restaurant near Montauk

Sam P. • October 3, 2013The meal was nothing to write home about, but it's a nice little local spot tucked away off the main roads with an amazing view and decent seafood. Great place for a sunset cocktail.

Sally • June 5, 2015Chowda + calamari bibb lettuce basil cilantro salad for the win ....down to earth vibe with a friendly staff and regulars

Dmitry • August 29, 2012Great place for lunch or dinner. Above getaway from the glitz of the hamptons. Fish is fresh and great. Great restaurant on the water.

Nikki W. • October 1, 2020Great food. Lobster fried rice, steak are all great.

Mike t. • September 9, 2017Nice place by the marina. Solid menu. Lobster is a must as well as the breaded scallops. Go for dinner and enjoy the sunset.

Richard B. • August 13, 2018Light mayo, strong flavor on the lobster roll. Fish tacos feature mahi mahi and have just the right amount of crunch and spice. Kids menu also a win for the basics (get sweet potato fries).

Andrea B. • July 10, 2011Mussels and frites were amazing. Best dish vs ceviche and tuna tartar. By far.

Nicolas S. • May 23, 2019I had the opportunity to try their Mtk Exclusive Burger with Lobster and Fish Tacos. Burger could be really good if they would do something with seasoning for meat. Fish tacos were really good.

Jenny R. • May 31, 2015You can't go wrong with scallops. Sushi, fried. Anything scallop. And the blackened swordfish.

Char • December 27, 2019Lobster 🦞 🍔 burger was EXCELLENT!!! The chef was very friendly, totally sold me on the lobster burger, and it was fantastic, 10/10!

Elyse E. • July 12, 2017The scallop ceviche is everything! So flavorful and fresh. Wonderful, quiet atmosphere. One of my new MTK faves that hasn't gotten too crowded yet.

Ian Y. • July 26, 2011Excellent produce, fish - and meat!

ᴡ P. • October 11, 2010Can't go wrong with the Deep Sea Trio or the Seafood Curry. Hell, everything was awesome!

Jeff K. • August 31, 2011Great coconut shrimp, plus make your own s'mores! Cool, laid back atmosphere.

David 🎉 L. • June 29, 2022Outstanding local little necks and oysters on the half shell. Fish, lobster, and bbq beef tacos are large with a tasty salad and aioli inside a flour soft shell.

Jon C. • June 2, 2019Chill, but active, great place to see some boats

Nikki 🌺 • September 21, 2015Probably some of the best food I've had in Montauk! No frills, casual atmosphere. Amazing Spicy Tuna Tartare and grilled shrimp Caesar salad. Also try their jalapeño margarita 💗✌🏼️

Char • November 25, 2017The best meal I’ve had in a long time, the swordfish is amazing, the oysters are to die for and the portions are enormous! Love it!! Get reservations!👌👌👌

K G. • August 12, 2011Try the Shrimp Wreck bloody Mary.

Alex S. • August 29, 2013Mary's Lobster Roll is awesome!!!