Reloading results...

Suggestions for Ice Cream Parlor near Montauk

Filters:

8.7
1. Ben & Jerry's
Ice Cream • $$$$ • View Menu •
478 West Lake Drive Extension, Montauk
Save
- Chris P. • August 22, 2013Great selection of pints in the back room. 32+ flavors!
8.2
2. John's Drive-In
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
677 Montauk Hwy, Montauk
Save
- Ryan G. • September 30, 2017Great burgers and great ice cream. Get here early they run out of flavors.
7.4
3. Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
Ice Cream • $$$$ • View Menu •
32 Star Island Road, Montauk
Save
7.3
4. Ralph's Famous Ices
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
Save
- George S. • September 2, 2016Italian ices and much more! Every location has every flavor imaginable and much more. Try the specialty cream ices and shakes! Fun every time!
?
5. Sundae Fundae
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
Montauk
Save
?
6. The Ice Cream Shop
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
Montauk
Save
?
7. Frozen Anchor
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
478 W Lake Dr, Montauk
Save
- Michele D. • August 16, 2020Good ice cream.
?
8. John's Homemade Ice Cream
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
Save
- Damian B. • July 22, 2015Very sweet ice cream with multiple homemade and soft serve options. The ginger based varieties are the best.
?
9. Fro-Yo & Gelato
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
43 S Euclid Ave, Montauk
Save
- Emily S. • May 24, 2019Salted caramel pretzel!
?
10. Dan's Ice Cream and Pop
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
1 S Dewitt Pl, Montauk
Save
?
11. Sugar
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
28 South Edison (South ETN), Montauk
Save
?
12. Sundae Donuts Montauk
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
716 Montauk Hwy, Montauk
Save
- Pat H. • August 29, 2022No subtle flavors here. Color and sugar explosion for the kidz..
?
13. East End Ice Café
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
805 Main Street, Montauk
Save
- Jeremy P. • May 14, 2012Nice little patio in the back.
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.