Suggestions for Dessert Shop near Montauk

The Corcoran Group • March 14, 2011Burgers, shakes and fries and the best homemade ice cream to boot! Try the John burger and the homemade ice cream. No website, but then who needs one for a popular place like this.

Kathleen V. • August 8, 2015The fish cookie was adorable and it taste really good and I would really recommend you guys having the blueberry crumb cake. I would come back just for those two things. :)

Harry • June 5, 2015Everything was great! The watercress, the sea bass, and definitely the ice cream sandwich are all very recommended! Service was excellent too! Arrive before sunset see the view from the pier!

Jorge U. • August 23, 2015Best coffee in Montauk. Their cakes and cookies are great too!

Casey W. • September 3, 2013the chocolate budino was out of this world. best pistachio ice cream, EVER. take a Montauk mule down to the beach & enjoy the beautiful scenery!!

Timon • August 15, 2014Lobster roll and Fish tacos + Lava cake

Erika R. • August 30, 2013Don't leave with out getting the seasonal local pie and ice cream! I had the Peach Raspberry and it was delicious!

Thisjustinian M. • May 7, 2016Fish tacos, killer smoothie selection, and the lemon bars.

SPE Certified • June 10, 2013We recommend the SPE-certified Chocolate Mousse for dessert. It's vegan, gluten-free and just 170 calories!

Chris G. • June 18, 2012Pros: parm fries, sautéed spinach. Cons: out of edamame, bread for the table, chocolate cake. Entrees took forever, but were offered complimentary desserts. Key lime cheesecake is...odd.

Jillian • August 31, 2014Such a fun, campy vibe for relaxed Hamptons nights. Bar scene is young and fun, too! Everything we had was amazing: Cocktails, lobster buratta, clam pizza, spaghettini, and ALL the desserts.

Nikki W. • September 17, 2018Old school montauk hit! Go with lobster. Definitely stay for dessert- mud pie and key lime pie are to die for!

Lindsay K. • November 8, 2010The "stuff" is ice cream. You should get some, along with a giant chunk of fudge.

Alicia M. • August 5, 2020Great breakfast sandwiches and strong WiFi on the patio

Nat P. • August 18, 2017Egg Benedict and stuffed crepes are worth to die for! They are so good. And don't forget the coconut pancakes or their fried ice cream! So good!! S/O to waitress Toni, she's the best in this place! xx

George S. • September 2, 2016Italian ices and much more! Every location has every flavor imaginable and much more. Try the specialty cream ices and shakes! Fun every time!

Jessica L. • July 12, 2013Excellent homemade ice cream!

Joel T. • July 14, 2017Awesome bagels, amazing donuts. Great fast fresh breakfast sandwiches. Super friendly.

Renee B. • July 17, 2013Awesome selection of flavored as well as a wide variety of toppings. Blood orange is out of this world

Jenna F. • June 29, 2017Great for brunch. Cute spot! Big portions. Fresh. Knowledgeable about gluten free options.

Danielle S. • July 19, 2011best milky way ice cream