Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Reloading results...

Suggestions for American Restaurant near Lancaster

Filters:
    • 8.9
      American$$$$View Menu
      540 E Fulton St, Lancaster
      Save
      • Jeannie P.

        Jeannie P. • May 16, 2018Well almost everything is amazing! Don’t order the maitake sandwich. It’s waaayyyy too salty. I still love going here though. The Windown drink is incredible. Must have Pot de Creme dessert!

    • 8.8
      American$$$$View Menu
      1335 Fruitville Pike (at Keller Ave), Lancaster
      Save
      • Kayla H.

        Kayla H. • September 25, 2013This is a fantastic place. Chicken nachos are amazing

    • 8.6
      American$$$$View Menu
      402 N Queen St (at W Lemon St), Lancaster
      Save
      • Robert S.

        Robert S. • September 14, 2015The swordfish was great! My fiancée had the short ribs and they great also.

    • 8.5
      American$$$$View Menu
      925 Plaza Blvd (Harrisburg Pike), Lancaster
      Save
      • Jim

        Jim • August 14, 2016The food is fantastic, good beer selection. The fire roasted salsa is unbelievable!

    • 8.3
      American$$$$View Menu
      551 W King St, Lancaster
      Save
      • Jessy M.

        Jessy M. • March 19, 2016Top notch service, fresh food, 24 taps, and live music most days....what more could you ask for?

    • 8.2
      American$$$$View Menu
      1573 Fruitville Pike, Lancaster
      Save
      • Megan L.

        Megan L. • May 4, 2019Lunch with friends we selected because of the vegan options. The food was fresh, tasteful and the atmosphere relaxing.

    • 8.2
      American$$$$View Menu
      491 Park City Ctr, Lancaster
      Save
      • John M.

        John M. • April 16, 2012Creamed spinach is absolutely delicious!

    • 8.5
      American$$$$View Menu
      781 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster
      Save
      • Peter P.

        Peter P. • October 13, 2011Cheesesteak egg rolls are fantastic. I do enjoy the the Belgium beers too.

    • 8.1
      American$$$$View Menu
      300 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster
      Save
      • Shake L.

        Shake L. • January 8, 2015Pricey but never disappoints. Worth every penny. Also I don't know what to recommend bc it's all good.

    • 8.4
      American$$$$View Menu
      33 N Market St (at W Grant St), Lancaster
      Save
      • Daniel W.

        Daniel W. • September 14, 2014A great place to enjoy some live music. Their burgundy wine is delicious.

    • 8.4
      American$$$$View Menu
      302 N Plum St (at E. Walnut St.), Lancaster
      Save
      • Robert S.

        Robert S. • January 7, 2015Pulled pork sandwich ,winter warmer was great ... Could use more coleslaw that was great too.

    • 7.9
      American$$$$View Menu
      343 Comet Dr (Millersville Road), Millersville
      Save
      • Bob S.

        Bob S. • August 7, 2016Such a great meal and the service is always awesome!

    • 8.1
      American$$$$View Menu
      25 N. Queen St., Lancaster
      Save
      • Dawn G.

        Dawn G. • April 20, 2015We had our doggie with us and they are pet friendly with the outdoor seating! They offered a bowl of water for our dog too!

    • 7.7
      American$$$$
      45 W Liberty St, Lancaster
      Save
      • Robert S.

        Robert S. • April 19, 2015try their burgers. i liked them so much

    • 7.6
      American$$$$View Menu
      595 Greenfield Rd (at William Penn Way), Lancaster
      Save
      • Susie C.

        Susie C. • August 11, 2011Try the swordfish or pork tenderloin entrees. They're delish. Brunch is excellent here. Haven't had a meal I didn't like yet.

    • 7.8
      American$$$$View Menu
      970 Plaza Blvd (at Harrisburg Pike), Lancaster
      Save
      • Select S.

        Select S. • April 6, 2016Chilean Sea Bass with Chimichurri is Fantastic bread & oil always great!

    • 7.6
      American$$$$View Menu
      1000 Christopher Pl, Lancaster
      Save
      • John M.

        John M. • October 20, 2018Very good cheddar and broccoli soup. Large portions for the money. Captain Jack dessert is banging. Generous discount for veterans.

    • 7.6
      American$$$$View Menu
      600 W Orange St, Lancaster
      Save
      • Nick N.

        Nick N. • August 24, 2010The best cheesesteaks I've had in Lancaster and I've tried them all.

    • 7.5
      American$$$$
      884 Plaza Blvd, Lancaster
      Save
      • Connie W.

        Connie W. • October 17, 2013Diane is a dream server...and the classic crab cakes...yummy!

    • 7.3
      American$$$$View Menu
      1294 Millersville Pike, Lancaster
      Save
      • Suzanne M.

        Suzanne M. • April 3, 2014Shellfish Trio is really good

    • 7.4
      American$$$$View Menu
      1147 Lititz Pike, Lancaster
      Save
      • Jay M. L.

        Jay M. L. • September 3, 2019Seafood, pasta, and of course meat. Brianne did a wonderful job. We will be back soon. Started coming here 25 years ago. Wonderful.

    • 7.1
      American$$$$
      222 Eden Rd (at Best Western Eden Resort), Lancaster
      Save
      • Timothy C.

        Timothy C. • July 29, 2011Enjoy the great breakfast buffet!! Good variety!!

    • 7.1
      American$$$$
      30 W Lemon St, Lancaster
      Save
      • Ben O.

        Ben O. • October 8, 2011Simple BLT burger hit the spot.

    • 7.2
      American$$$$View Menu
      1021 Dillerville Rd, Lancaster
      Save
      • Bridget W.

        Bridget W. • October 20, 2016Here, you'll find waffles you won't find anywhere else, including one with pecans, peanut butter, and you'll find a very chatty staff that will keep you on your toes with great food and conversation!

    • 7.1
      American$$$$View Menu
      1835 Oregon Pike, Lancaster
      Save
      • David G.

        David G. • August 19, 2017Number 17 Parker was fantastic

    • 7.0
      American$$$$View Menu
      1679 Lincoln Hwy E, Lancaster
      Save
      • Cherie D.

        Cherie D. • February 7, 2022Went there this past Saturday and we really liked it. Service was great and so was the food. It is also priced reasonably. We would definitely go back.

    • 6.9
      American$$$$View Menu
      480 New Holland Ave (Plum), Lancaster
      Save
      • Frances C.

        Frances C. • March 22, 2012Tuna salad sandwich was the best I've ever had! With sweet potato fries, it makes the perfect ( and substantial) lunch.

    • 6.7
      American$$$$View Menu
      100 N Pointe Blvd, Lancaster
      Save
      • Katrina A.

        Katrina A. • January 25, 2011The Bloomin' Onion is amazing. I'm not a big onion or onion ring person, but the Bloomin' Onion is my favorite!

    • 6.1
      American$$$$View Menu
      701 N Queen St (at New St.), Lancaster
      Save
      • Eric R.

        Eric R. • July 2, 2014Cheese fries w bacon and mozzarella are the bomb. Pizza is def a NY style. Good thin crust, sauce isn't too sweet.

    • 5.5
      American$$$$View Menu
      1655 Columbia Avenue, Lancaster
      Save
      • Rae H.

        Rae H. • May 12, 2017Good food, good service, decent prices.

    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.