Reloading results...

Suggestions for Italian Restaurant near Key West

Filters:
    • 8.7

      1. New York Pasta Garden

      Italian • $$$$ •
      1075 Duval St, Key West
      Save
      • PooBear &.

        PooBear &. • May 25, 2015Spaghetti pomadoro pretty good; large portions, super tasty warm garlic rolls--yum! Got a free piece of limoncello cake!

    • 8.8

      2. Duetto Pizza & Gelato

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      540 Greene St (Ann st), Key West
      Save
      • Star 2 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 8.4

      3. Abbondanza Italian Restaurant

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1208 Simonton St, Key West
      Save
      • Star 16 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 8.0

      4. Mangia Mangia

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      900 Southard Street (at Margaret St), Key West
      Save
      • Star 27 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 8.0

      5. Clemente's Wood-Fired Trolley Pizzeria

      Italian • $$$$ •
      516 Fleming St., Key West
      Save
      • Liz E.

        Liz E. • October 27, 2019The Caesar salad pizza is awesome!

    • 8.2

      6. Salute! On The Beach

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1000 Atlantic Blvd, Key West
      Save
      • Star 6 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 8.3

      7. Cafe Sole

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1029 Southard St, Key West
      Save
      • Star 4 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 7.7

      8. La Trattoria

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      524 Duval St (Southard), Key West
      Save
      • Bobby A.

        Bobby A. • May 19, 2015Awesome food. Great staff ! Great area ! Superb selection of pastas and wines .. They take care of the smaller things .. Highly recommend it ..

    • 7.9

      9. Roof Top Cafe

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      308 Front St, Key West
      Save
      • Star 5 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 7.9

      10. Antonia's

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      615 Duval St, Key West
      Save
      • Star 10 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 7.6

      11. Only Wood

      Italian • $$$$ •
      Key West
      Save
      • Ted B.

        Ted B. • January 6, 2023Don’t be deceived by the cheesy “Hard Rock” style branding. This place is amazing. Order the dolce pizza. It’s incredible.

    • 7.6

      12. Big John's Pizza, Pasta & Subs

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1103 Key Plz (Roosevelt & 13th), Key West
      Save
      • Star 8 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 7.3

      13. Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria

      Italian • $$$$ •
      613 1/2 Duval St, Key West
      Save
      • Jim E.

        Jim E. • November 6, 2012The best pizza on the entire island. Yummy great staff very attentive. Priced right and a nice setting.

    • 7.6

      14. Mr. Z's -Old Town

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      501 Southard St (at Duval St.), Key West
      Save
      • Star 6 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 7.9

      15. Seaside Cafe At The Mansion

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1400 Duval Street, Key West
      Save
      • Star 7 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 7.1

      16. Paradise Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      503 Greene St, Key West
      Save
      • Colleen J.

        Colleen J. • January 14, 2012Best pizza. And cheap

    • 8.3

      17. Roostica Wood-Fire Pizzeria

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      5620 Macdonald Ave., Key West
      Save
      • Star 40 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 7.4

      18. Mr. Z's -New Town

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      2798 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West
      Save
    • 6.6

      19. Wingmasters Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      934 Truman Ave (at Grinnell St), Key West
      Save
      • Philip L.

        Philip L. • March 30, 2018The wings, obviously, and the pizza.

    • ?

      20. Bel Mare

      Italian • $$$$ •
      700 Front St, Key West
      Save
    • ?

      21. Bruschetta Cucina Italiana

      Italian • $$$$ •
      112 Fitzpatrick St, Key West
      Save
    • 6.1

      22. Angelina's Pizzeria

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      208 Duval St, Key West
      Save
      • Star 24 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 8.5

      23. Seven Fish

      Seafood • $$$$ • View Menu •
      921 Truman Ave (Packer St), Key West
      Save
      • Ubiratã S.

        Ubiratã S. • May 27, 2013I just have to say: as a Brazilian, I am used to eating good seafood.But the seafood marinara pasta (beware, it's spicy) is THE BEST seafood pasta I've ever had.And the curry snapper is also awesome.

    • 9.2

      24. Cuban Coffee Queen

      Coffee Shop • $$$$ • View Menu •
      284 Margaret St, Key West
      Save
      • Star 1 item on the menu matches Italian food
    • 8.6

      25. Southernmost Beach Cafe

      American • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1405 Duval St, Key West
      Save
      • Star 1 item on the menu matches Italian food
    • 8.6

      26. Sloppy Joe's Bar

      Bar • $$$$ • View Menu •
      201 Duval Street (at Greene Street), Key West
      Save
      • Star 7 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 8.1

      27. Nine One Five

      Mediterranean • $$$$ • View Menu •
      915 Duval St, Key West
      Save
      • Star 8 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 8.4

      28. A&B Lobster House

      American • $$$$ • View Menu •
      700 Front St, Key West
      Save
      • Star 1 item on the menu matches Italian food
    • 9.0

      29. Azur

      Mediterranean • $$$$ • View Menu •
      425 Grinnell St (Fleming), Key West
      Save
      • Star 9 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 8.7

      30. Cafe Marquesa

      American • $$$$ • View Menu •
      600 Fleming St, Key West
      Save
      • Star 1 item on the menu matches Italian food

    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.