Danielle C. • August 10, 2015Wings and the pizza are great. The breakfast is pretty good too.
Sean R. • June 19, 2011Ricotta meatballs, and grilled octopus....awesome!
Carmen S. • June 6, 2016I always enjoy the chicken Marsala and pepperoni pizza! Mmmm mm good! 👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽
Wayne A. • July 14, 2017Assortment of excellent white pizzas as well as red (Basil, Fennel Sausage tomato & mozzarella. Sunday Sauce/a must & from Friday - Sunday. Underrated and reviews are old. Service is excellent.
Nikki • November 29, 2016Yummers everything so fresh. Family business. Large room. Open kitchen on one side.
R Drew B. • December 20, 2017Very friendly and inviting ,,, fast too ! Food is consistently very good and fresh made to order each and every time !!! Try it once, and you’ll be back 😋
Jason N. • December 31, 2016My pizza was not "done well". It was white crust, but burned on top. I like some char, but not soot. Grew up in CT. Nick's is a far cry from Pepe's & Sally's on Wooster St in New Haven.
Brad • October 7, 2017Great appetizers, big fan of the bruschetta and fried mozzarella and accompanying salad. Really nice service too!
Jim H. • September 3, 2023Chicken parmigiana, penne alla vodka, meatballs! Beef skewers, clams, rigatoni, and the desserts are a must! Chunky monkey s’mores sundae!
Angie O. • September 14, 2010WORST Pizza Ev er!!! Thick soggy dough, salty sauce, and where's the cheese???
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.